Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    What Does Organic Mean for Beauty Products?

    By Shannon R, SELF magazine


    Most of us are striving to live a healthier lifestyle. Whether that means eating healthy, exercising more, buying organic or reducing your carbon footprint we all want to feel like we are doing the best we can to take care of ourselves and the people we love. In recent years, the beauty industry has joined the wellness trend by selling products with terms like "organic," "natural" and even "chemical-free". The question is, what do these terms really mean?


    What does organic mean?
    It really depends on who you ask. If you ask a chemist, the answer is clear. Organic means any chemical compound that contains carbon. In fact, to get a college chemistry degree you take a year of Organic Chemistry where you memorize endless chemical reactions between hydrocarbons, oxygen, nitrogen and more.


    See more: Foods That Fight Cellulite


    In the food industry, organic products are regulated by the National Organic Program (NOP) which is run by the USDA. Only producers and manufacturers that meet the standards set up by the NOP may label their products as certified organic. I won't go into the details of the program but they include things like promoting biodiversity and limiting the use of synthetic pesticides. If you want more details check out the USDA website. The main point is that organics are regulated in the food industry.

    In the beauty industry, there is no industry-agreed meaning for terms like 'organic' or 'natural'. Unlike the food industry, these terms are not regulated for cosmetics which means companies can use these terms pretty freely.


    See more: The Healthiest Cities for Women


    Are there any standard definitions in the beauty industry?
    Unfortunately, not yet. This makes it hard for people to decipher what all this means and if there really are any benefits to natural or organic beauty products.

    Some companies argue that if an ingredient comes from a natural source then it's natural. They conveniently overlook the fact that they chemically modify it to make it work the way they want it.

    Also, products like shampoo, conditioner and body wash are mostly made of water so therefore are mostly natural (because water is natural, right?). So if a shampoo is 90% water, then a company can simply claim "90% organic or natural" and be telling the truth. Certainly, this isn't in the spirit of what people believe organic to mean, but it is within the law.


    Related: 21 Good-For-You Snacks


    Is there progress being made towards strictly regulation?
    Yes, there are some companies campaigning to get tighter regulations on cosmetics that use terms such as "natural" or "organic". However, this process is not as simple as sounds. There are a few companies (very few) that uphold their own stricter definitions of what natural and organic means (following in the footsteps of food). If buying organic is a priority for you then you will have to take your own initiative and look at labels and visit websites to understand what companies really mean when using terms like organic and natural. There are a few beauty products that are USDA Certified which means they contain at least 95% organic ingredients. Look for the USDA Certified label right on the package.


    Are organic beauty products better?
    Currently, natural or organic cosmetic products don't really provide any added benefit for consumers. For the few companies who strive to actually make 'organic' or 'all-natural' products, their finished products are mostly functionally inferior to more mainstream products. This is the real trade-off of natural or organic products. That and a much higher cost for an often inferior product. However, this trade-off may be worth it for some people. And, as the demand for these types of products continue to grow there should be improvements in performance and a drop in cost.


    Bottom Line
    The 'natural' and 'organic' area in the beauty industry is a hot topic and a consistent source of debate. Beauty products that are currently available are safe and work well and are mostly available at an affordable price. However, for the person that is truly looking for more organic or all natural products there will be some trade-off as to how well the product works and of course there will be a price to pay. Hopefully, there will be more standardization in the industry soon, which will make it easier for all of us to understand what these terms mean and make companies more accountable for what they say.


    More from SELF:

    20 Superfoods for Weight Loss
    Yoga Moves for Flat Abs
    38 Antiaging Foods
    Gwyneth Paltrow's Arm and Ab Workout

     

    11 comments

    • Rhea Reyes-sanchez  •  1 month 14 days ago
      I do have very sensitive skin, my skin gets soo flaky during winter, and when it gets dry, I get rashes. I feel like I have map on my legs that doesn't go away and my scalp gets so itchy and dry that no matter how many head & shoulder and Nizoral shampoos I use, it doesn't go away. I have tried so many products that I was hoping would work but didn't. My used to be favorite brand was Aveeno. I used that for almost two years. But during winter, my skin still gets Super Dry, then I switched to Philosophy 3-in-1. I used it as a shampoo and at the same time as a body wash. It worked fine the first few uses, but I still got itchy, until I discovered Natural products. Currently I am using Goat Milk Soap bar from small businesses (handmade). Finally I found a cure to my overly dry skin. I use it on my body and my face that helps control my acne-prone skin as well. For shampoo I use Natural Shampoo and Conditioner from the Philippines. This is the best natural shampoo I could find in the market and it is uncomparable to those that you can buy at WHolefoods. These doesn't even cost more than $10 each. My shampoo is $5.99 for 200mL, conditioner is the same, the bar soap is roughly about $4. They cost almost the same as the conventional products. So using natural or organic does not really have to be expensive. And in terms of benefit, so far for me Organic/Natural products works. I grew up thinking that I'd forever have these skin problems, but going back, I realized that its not really my skin, but those what I put on my skin.
      The conventional products are probably safe in terms of what FDA calls "standard or safe level" but FDA cannot actually monitor these stuff. Cosmetic is something that does not need to have FDA registration. I am also not a fan of products that have "Certified Organic" on them., Big brands pay just to have this stamp in their product.
      Try looking for handmade natural products, they do work well, and these products are usually made by those people that have problematic skin and are searching for products that will really work. :)
    • travelgabi  •  3 months ago
      Castille products rock!!!! I HAVE GREAT SKIN! ;)
      • Reese Jacksons gma 3 months ago
        I agree with u! I make my own face soap/cleanser & my face is all cleared up! I made some for my son who was starting to break out pretty bad when he hit the teens-he now has zit free skin! It is WONDERFUL STUFF!
      • jules 3 months ago
        I just wash my face with water, next use witch hazel, then apply argon or coconut oil, I don't get acne unless I get lazy and stop doing my routine.
    • diana  •  Omaha, Nebraska  •  3 months ago
      You will have to consider the definition and use of "inferior". I have bought and used Burt Bees stuff for almost 6 years and it does exactly the same thing as regular products, but I find it at an advantage because A: I know what's in my shampoo/conditioner/chap stick/lotion because the names are familiar, B: they still do everything that all the chemically enhanced products do, C: the price really isn't that much cheaper than a lot of the other "name-brand" stuff. Even on things that claim to be "organic" I have still found coloring agents in my shampoo and conditioner of "high quality" (and definitely more expensive).
      • wildwinds 2 months ago
        better read the ingredients in burts bees products....especially the lip gloss. It has titanium dioxide....last ingredient mentioned on the label of the lip gloss. This ingredient is found in paint....sooo is it really good to use on our lips?....I think not. I have stopped using it. I too thought it was natural. It seems no one cares about women's health ....just the almighty dollar....what a sad world we live in.
    • Kathleen  •  Kansas City, Missouri  •  2 months ago
      Standardization is a key but that means honesty with education. So many people don't add up the amount of processed synthetic non-recognizeable to the body, products we breathe, eat and drink each day. Attempting to use natural self-made products or from small manufacturers who care about what they make, is the key. READ, and LEARN about ingredients from the kitchen and the garden and how they are resourced. Then make a few basic things for yourself and to give as gifts.
    • Littlehearts  •  Conroe, Texas  •  3 months ago
      higher prices for sure
    • Heathen  •  Medford, Oregon  •  3 months ago
      It is apparent that Shannon R.(?)is not that knowledgeable of organic companies, organic policies, or the toxicity of conventional cosmetics. Applying carcinogens to your face (etc.) is the same as eating carcinogens. To simply say that there is no difference and that organic products do not work as well) ignores the science that has proven that there is link between cancer and conventional makeup products.
      Shannon works for a magazine that gets paid handsomely to promote conventional products.
      So this "news article" is simply a bow to the companies that pay her bills.
      If you care about your body, the environment, and where your money goes, avoid the companies that make money off of damaging your health.
      Also, if you care about animals, most conventional companies torture (yes torture) animals, yet then still sell you their toxic product.
      Most organic companies do not test on animals.
      Testing products on animals is archaic. Modern computer models and human tissue samples are compassionate, intelligent ways for scientist to test products.
      • 78Westy 3 months ago
        Any actual facts to support that propoganda your spewing? How about a link to some info rather than an uninformed ignorant rant?
      • Heathen 3 months ago
        Be specific on what you consider "propaganda" in my comment and I will provide you with the facts. But if you spent more time reading and researching, rather than leaving negative comments to people trying to prevent corporations from taking advantage of them, you would already know the answers. I'll be happy to provide links etc. if you are truly interested. But it seems more likely that you just enjoy being negative.
      • 78Westy 2 months ago
        Ok here is what IS propaganda in your comment, feel free to support any of your unsupported claims!

        1. "Shannon R.(?)is not that knowledgeable of organic companies, organic policies, or the toxicity of conventional cosmetics."

        Do tell what is her experience and knowledge and how do you know anything at all about her credibilty?

        2. "Shannon works for a magazine that gets paid handsomely to promote conventional products.
        So this "news article" is simply a bow to the companies that pay her bills."

        Again, any support to this slander? Or was it just an uneducated rant?

        I will be waiting patiently for your response, thank you for your time.
    • tracie  •  Houston, Texas  •  3 months ago
      Not so much...
    • wendopolis  •  Chicago, Illinois  •  3 months ago
      Crap article
    • Cranberry Lips  •  3 months ago
      The one organic product that is a complete waste of money is soap. Base oils are mixed with lye to form soap and then some essential oils are added. Lye pretty much dissolves any chemical compound, whether it be a pesticide, rancid fat, vitamins, minerals, and even fish bones (true story: found a partially dissolved fish vertebra in a Chinese soap-- that's why I make my own from scratch).

      Of course, people can add all kinds of things to soap: goat milk, lavender blossoms, dead sea salt, essential oils for fragrance, but in all honesty, this is not aromatherapy. There's not enough of anything in there to help your skin, other than provide some moisture (if the soap is superfatted), smell decent, and clean your body.

      Buy or make soaps that don't contain synthetic fragrances, animal fat, or petroleum products, but don't spend the money on organic ones.
      • Rugged Rod 3 months ago
        What major brand of soap still uses lye? Irish Spring, Ivory, Dial, Lever, Dove, etc. are all lye-free and have been lye-free for over 50 years. Getting organic soap is important because organic soap is often the only soap that doesn't contain synthetic fragrances or parabens.
      • Cranberry Lips 3 months ago
        Sorry to break it to you, Rugged Rod, but all hard bars of soap are made with lye (sodium hydroxide). Liquid soap and shampoo is made with potassium hydroxide.

        Also, most major brand soaps are made with beef fat (tallow). Anytime you see "sodium tallowate" listed as an ingredient, it is the product of the chemical reaction between lye and beef fat.
      • Heathen 3 months ago
        There are many TRULY organic soaps out there, that also don't use lye. Dr. Bronner's is just one of many. If you don't know much about a company, call them and find out. Most are ready to disclose their sourcing.
    • Heathen  •  Medford, Oregon  •  3 months ago
      Certified organic means certified organic. If this label is on a product, with a known certification agency (USDA, Oregon Tilth, etc.) then it is certifeid organic.
      • 78Westy 2 months ago
        Unfortunatly that label would only be on "argricultural: products and cosmetics are not "agricultural". So, NO "certified organic" does not mean "certified organic" if it is on a cosmetic product.

        Loveallbeings, it is the blind sheep like yourself that I am trying to protect by demanding the truth in these articles. You are clearly blind to the truth. You blindly believe and trust a corporation because they put an "organic" stamp on products and yet in some cases they have no responsibility to be honest with their consumers! I am not here to be negative I am here to learn how to be better to OUR planet and well as our bodies, however when false information is spread I must stop it in the same interest of protecting OUR planet/bodies!
    • 78Westy  •  Brush Prairie, Washington  •  3 months ago
      Look how upset all the tree huggers are that there is an honest and truthfull article on Shine! Its so refreshing to not see a propaganda article here!