By rely on mascara to help give their eyes that extra pop. But which formulas really deliver on their promises to frame your peepers to their best advantage? WD tested contenders in each of six categories, including plumping, waterproof, curling and lengthening, and rated them from one (worst) to five (best). Read on to find out which brands came out on top in our tests.
Category: Separating and Defining
What WD had to say: Our reviewer gave both of these products high marks, but for different reasons. Maybelline scored higher for a noticeably thicker, darker formula, and for leaving our reviewer's lashes looking "long, separated and dramatic." NYC's formula was smoother and easier to apply, however, creating a "feathered" look. Both held up all day with no smudging. Separating mascaras typically have a hard-bristled applicator to facilitate combing and defining, so whicheverRead More »from WD Reviews: Mascara