By Elizabeth Sheer, Cheapism.com
...Ben & Jerry's Vanilla, the almost unanimous choice by a panel of 14 who participated in a blind tasting organized by Cheapism. But before anyone starts hollering that this is no cheap ice cream, the No. 2 pick was Breyer's Natural Vanilla, which probably deserves the title of best cheap ice cream. Indeed, it was the brand that kept the Vermont ice cream maker from earning a perfect score.
One warm afternoon we gathered together our panel of extremely willing volunteers with goal of identifying the best cheap ice cream. We included only national brands in the tasting and settled on vanilla because it's ubiquitous and, according to the International Dairy Foods Association (IFDA), the most popular ice cream flavor. The brands tested included Edy's Rich and Creamy Grand Vanilla (known as Dreyer's on the West Coast), Breyer's Natural Vanilla, and Turkey Hill Original Vanilla. Because frozen yogurt has been making a big splash lately, we also
Read More »from And the Best Inexpensive Ice Cream Is...


