Fashion + Beauty

Wednesday, December 2, 2009

Related Topics:

Does a Higher Price Really Equal Better Skin Care? We Put it to a Real World Test

It's an on-going debate: are drugstore skin care products just as good (or better) than fancy department store products? Since I'm one of those people who are constantly tempted by pretty packaging (a.k.a. over-priced products), I'd like to believe that the more you spend, the better the results will be. However, I know this isn't always true (as this research shows).

After our umpteenth debate in the office over our favorite bargain and splurge products, we decided to put our money where our mouths were (so to speak) and have real women compare drugstore and department store anti-aging products.

To keep it all scientific-like, we had them each take before and after photos and try the lines of skin care for the same amount of time. We also tailored the products to their specific skin needs so they would have the most potential for improvement. Check it out below, you'll never guess who the winners are:

Olay vs. Chanel:

Tester: Lucy, 36
Complexion Conundrum: Under-eye circles (puffiness and discoloration), as well as hyperpigmentation (light brown spots) around the cheek area, and bothersome crow's feet.

What She Tested:
Round 1: Olay Pro-X:

Wrinkle Smoothing Cream, $42
Eye Restoration Complex, $42
Age Repair Lotion, $42

Round 2: Chanel:
Sublimage Essential Regenerating Complex, $400
Sublimage Essential Regenerating Cream, $375
Sublimage Eye Essential Regenerating Eye Cream, $200
UV Essentiel (SPF 30), $48

Click here to see her reactions and the winner.

Olay vs. La Prairie:

Tester: Patti, 33
Complexion Conundrum: Early, 30-something fine lines and wrinkles, especially on her forehead and around her mouth area.

What She Tested:
Round 1: Olay Pro-X:
Deep Wrinkle Treatment, $42
Eye Restoration, $42
Age Repair Lotion, $42

Round 2: La Prairie:
Cellular Anti-Wrinkle Firming Serum, $205
Anti-Aging Emulsion SPF 30, $155
Cellular Eye Contour Cream, $195

Click here to see her reactions and the winner. 


Olay vs. Estee Lauder:

Tester: Melissa, 36
Complexion Conundrum: Age spots and dry skin -- typical concerns that go tandem with premature aging and wrinkles.

What She Tested:
Round 1: Olay Pro-X:
Deep Wrinkle Treatment, $42
Eye Restoration, $42
Age Repair Lotion, $42

Round 2: Estee Lauder:
Perfectionist CP+ Wrinkle Lifting Serum, $55
Time Zone Anti-Line/Wrinkle Eye Cream, $43.50
Time Zone Line and Wrinkle Reducing Lotion SPF 15, $58

Click here to see her reactions and the winner.

Oh, but we didn't stop there! Check out two more comparisons:

Olay vs. Clarins Skin Care

Olay vs. Shiseido Skin Care

Think you know who will win?

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-3 of 3
  • GirlyGirl©'s Avatar
    Posted by GirlyGirl© Mon Sep 28, 2009 5:11pm PDT

    I only use olive oil, it has always worked for me. Right after a shower, just pat it on your face with your fingertips while your pores are good and open. It works for me!

    Report Abuse
  • MaryMary's Avatar
    Posted by MaryMary Mon Sep 28, 2009 5:22pm PDT

    Wow, I see a pretty big difference with the first woman. Cool!

    Report Abuse
  • Habanero♥™'s Avatar
    Posted by Habanero♥™ Mon Sep 28, 2009 5:30pm PDT

    Girly: I use olive oil or coconut oil. Natural and no perfumes.

    I do not see one improvement.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-3 of 3

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Does Your Hair Color Measure Up?

Get 10-minute hair color in 27 designer shades.