Is $1 Makeup too Good to Be True?

From the Community…

• 
  Posted by AMBER C Thu Jul 2, 2009 7:47am PDT

  For $1.00 and no animal testing involved, I am a fan. The white nail polish is a favorite of mine lately. I plan to get most everything they have. My standard make up is still Physicians Formula but this is a nice addition to bring some color into my routine.

  Report Abuse
• 
  Posted by HK Thu Jul 2, 2009 10:42am PDT

  I personally LOVE e.l.f. The only problem I've ever had was the coloring of a all over stick, which, was perfect because it worked perfectly for my friends skin tone... so I just got the lighter shape and it's a perfect concealer and then using the mineral foundation... makes my skin look great.

  And I agree with the eyes, make sure to put a powder base on before any of the liquidy eyeshadow, stays on longer.

  And for only a dollar? AWESOME.

  Report Abuse
• 
  Posted by HK Thu Jul 2, 2009 10:55am PDT

  I personally LOVE e.l.f. The only problem I've ever had was the coloring of a all over stick, which, was perfect because it worked perfectly for my friends skin tone... so I just got the lighter shape and it's a perfect concealer and then using the mineral foundation... makes my skin look great.

  And I agree with the eyes, make sure to put a powder base on before any of the liquidy eyeshadow, stays on longer.

  And for only a dollar? AWESOME.

  Report Abuse
• 
  Posted by Kelie Thu Jul 2, 2009 4:45pm PDT

  I wouldnt even waste my 1 buck to try it.. if it is that cheap its going to be cheap. Thats why I dont waste my money on those Jane products either. I pretty much use cover girl.. I love M.A.C but honestly with the world today I cant afford that anymore =/

  Report Abuse
• 
  Posted by Delle d Thu Jul 2, 2009 7:18pm PDT

  If you're on a budget and willing to try something new, here's what i have tested from teh e.l.f. line

  Lippies - Bleh!

  All-over color sticks - bleh! not blendable enough.

  Blushes/Bronzer Powders - they are soft, finely-milled and not so harsh on the skin. the color is totalyly buildable so you can out as little or as much as you want. the shimmery blush/bronzers are great for asian skintones like mine. i wear this peachy-pink color with gold shimmer. it doubles as highlighter for face and body. there are matte shades for the natural look as well. the tiny packaging is uber cute too and fits my purse nicely.

  Brushes - really soft and keeps clean

  Liquid eyeliners (felt tip and brush-tip versions) - they're highly pigmented and smudge-able and scratchable so its ok if i goof, but after a few seconds it stays put. it stays put for the rest of the day.

  glosses - tasty but that's just about that. the gloss celphone charms are cute

  Mascaras - i use the double-ended one in brown for that natural look. the waterproof end is for my lashes and the regular end is for my brows. i lightly tissue-blot the mascara wand to avoid clumping before and after use.

  I haven't tested the eyeshadows because i have tons from CG.

  Hope this helps!

  Report Abuse
• 
  Posted by BB Fri Jul 3, 2009 9:59am PDT

  I tried a few E.L.F. products and honestly wasn't all that impressed. I used many colors and formulas purchased at the drug store. I adore Sephora and department store brands too.

  It doesn't matter what the price is, as long as it does what you want it to do. If a lip gloss lasts an hour, that's fine. If a lip stick claims to be "long wearing" and is smudged or greasy after an hour, then it's junk.

  Report Abuse
• 
  Posted by daisy*kae Sat Jul 4, 2009 6:13pm PDT

  i've tried the lipgloss and was pretty much pleased with it. was it the best lipgloss i've bought? no. however, for $1 i was happy with the results. i too like jane cosmetics. i practically hoard their loose powder. every now and then i'll find it 50% off @ rite aid and i'll clean them out, lol. one canister pretty much lasts a year for me; so buying four at a time lasts me awhile. :)

  Report Abuse
• 
  Posted by Ivonne Fri Jul 10, 2009 10:11am PDT

  i just bought several stuff..its bretty good i have to say im inpresed ..its not bad and just for a 1$ ..thats is a good deal..that now adays we dont have much money .

  Report Abuse
• 
  Posted by Tanae R Mon Jul 13, 2009 8:24am PDT

  I actually ordered about 20 dollars worth of stuff and i love it! the eyeshadows are very pretty and i have no problem with them lasting all day, the lip gloss is awesome. And although it might be cheap but the quality is good, if you would rather pay 10 dollars or more on eyeshadow or whatever then more power to you but im not spending all that money on something i can get for a dollar!

  Report Abuse
• 
  Posted by Watermelon Sun Aug 30, 2009 6:18pm PDT

  Their eyeshadows are def not worth it-they broke in my makeup bag and got powder all over. It was a mess for something that didn't stay on for more than an hour in the first place. I also didn't care for the eyeliner and found that any body poweder did not match my complexion (I'm African American). All in all not a good purchase.

  Report Abuse