Food

Thursday, December 3, 2009

Related Topics:

Sea Salt or Table Salt: Which is Healthier?

Like many cooks, I use a lot of sea salt. In fact, in the past couple of years, I've gradually transitioned from simply sprinkling it over finished dishes to using it in all recipes that don't require measuring (meaning, most of my cooking). I still keep a container of table salt on hand for baking (due to the difference in texture, a teaspoon of sea salt is not the same as a teaspoon of table salt), but when I'm cooking without a recipe, it's just so much easier to grab a handful of sea salt from the dish on my counter than to get the table salt out of the cabinet.

For this reason, I was a bit alarmed recently when I suddenly realized that most sea salt is not iodized. I don't know why this never occurred to me before, but after the realization hit me, I did a bit of research, and what I found was worrying:

You see, iodine is a nutrient that's essential for health. If your body is deficient in it, your thyroid can have problems functioning properly, which can result in depression, weight gain, and even mental problems. If pregnant women don't get enough iodine, it can cause miscarriage or babies with low IQ or developmental disabilities.

Until the early 1900s, many people around the world were iodine deficient; this was the cause of the goiters (enlarged thyroid glands) that plagued members of previous generations. In the 20th century, most Western countries solved this problem by adding iodine to salt, which pretty much eliminated iodine deficiency in the developed world. (Though it's still common in third-world countries without iodized salt—in 2006, The New York Times reported that iodizing salt would be the easiest way to raise the world's IQ.)

Most brands of sea and kosher salt, however, do not have iodine added. There's a common misperception that sea salt comes by the mineral naturally, due to the fact that sea water (and foods such as seaweed and fish) contains iodine. However, the information I turned up indicated that the amount of iodine in most sea salt is negligible—certainly not enough to supply the 150 micrograms needed daily by the average adult. And even iodine-rich foods don't supply enough, unless you eat seaweed almost every day. On the other hand, a quarter-teaspoon of iodized table salt contains 115 micrograms, so if you eat that plus an iodine-rich food such as milk (iodine is added to most animal feed in the U.S.) you're all set.

The salt issue is interesting because, like many people interested in healthy eating I think, I had just assumed that sea salt was healthier for me because it was less processed than table salt. It never occurred to me that I might be depriving my body of an essential nutrient by taking the "natural" route. And, without knowing it, I was also adding to the problem by choosing milk and eggs from local, grass-fed animals that are not given iodine-enriched feed.

This does not, of course, mean, that I'll be trading in my locavore habits for a diet of processed foods any time soon. But I am thinking about switching back to iodized table salt for cooking—especially since I've always doubted whether the difference can really be tasted once the salt is dissolved in a dish. (This article has some interesting things to say on that subject, though it's a bit reductionist—for instance, according to my research, her assertion that all salt is 99% pure sodium chloride is patently false.)

This also brings up a larger issue: How can those of us who try to eat a more "natural" diet be sure that we're making the best choice for ourselves and our families? I'd be willing to bet that many of the same mothers who spend thousands of dollars on tutoring and "enrichment" toys for their children also buy sea salt and grass-fed milk. How would they feel if they thought their dietary choices during pregnancy might have lowered their children's IQ's by a few points?

One final thought: Some types of sea salt, including many from Greece, are iodized. But flaky Maldon salt from England—my personal favorite—and fleur de sel from France are not among them. So, if you're worried about getting enough iodine and want to continue using sea salt, I'd be sure to check the label on your brand. And for more on the amounts of iodine in various foods, see this very comprehensive article from the Linus Pauling Institute at Oregon State University.

What do you think? Are you concerned about getting enough iodine in your diet?


by Sarah Kagan

MORE FROM EPICURIOUS.COM

Celebrate the Jewish New Year with recipes, menus and kosher wines

Get ready for fall with recipes for cooking with the best fall ingredients

Healthy recipes for eating for heart health

Satisfying, slimmed-down recipes for your favorite comfort foods

How to host a wine-tasting party at home

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 20
  • Question girl's Avatar
    Posted by Question girl Wed Sep 16, 2009 4:59pm PDT

    For your mineral needs it might be better to take a colloidal mineral supplement,since many commercial salts have been bleached and sugar has been added. It's important to read the ingridients in all the packeged products you consume,because u never know what it might contain.

    Report Abuse
  • cnr's Avatar
    Posted by cnr Wed Sep 16, 2009 5:15pm PDT

    For the vast, vast majority of people in the USA, iodine consumption is not a problem because of the ridiculous amounts of salt already added to nearly every food in restaurants, supermarket "salad bars", and industrialized foods. Perhaps the author should have made it clear that for 99% of people, it is still a good idea to use natural sea salt and for the 1% of people who truly eat naturally, getting iodine from table salt is a good idea. And of course, pregnant women should always pay attention and get enough iodine!

    Report Abuse
  • Tom's Avatar
    Posted by Tom Wed Sep 16, 2009 6:14pm PDT

    in my opinion eat buffalo meat deer meat season too taste eat saled after your feast too clean your system out after!

    Report Abuse
  • allyoop_58's Avatar
    Posted by allyoop_58 Thu Sep 17, 2009 4:14am PDT

    Thanks for the info! My daughter & I were discussing these differences just yesterday! Didn't have a clue on the subject of sea salt so this has been very enlightening!

    She had her lip pierced this week and was told to use warm water with sea salt in it to clean (swish) her mouth with. I figured table salt would be just as good?

    Thanks again

    allyoop

    Report Abuse
  • julia's Avatar
    Posted by julia Thu Sep 17, 2009 5:56am PDT

    If you're looking to salt to increase your mineral intake, you're eating way too much salt. Sea salt is no more healthy than table salt, they have the same nutritional value, although sea salt is fashionable and FAR more expensive. What is relevant is that there are taste differences as well as texture and color differences. Some table salt may have benign anti-caking additives, and it is still 99% sodium chloride. With our modern ability to eat a wider variety of foods, iodine deficiency is rarely an issue. Instead of using puff journalism for information (which they misleadingly present as gospel), there are better sources that are well researched.

    Report Abuse
  • julia's Avatar
    Posted by julia Thu Sep 17, 2009 7:01am PDT

    What is wrong with people? A blogger asks an intelligent question, people start talking and sharing information, then some idiot posts absolutely stupid, time-wasting, self-serving, ignorant junk.

    Report Abuse
  • anon's Avatar
    Posted by anon Thu Sep 17, 2009 1:46pm PDT

    Eat the sea salt and take a multi-vitamin and mineral supplement. Whenever possible, substitute *all* types of salt for other herbs and spices.

    Report Abuse
  • Habanero♥™'s Avatar
    Posted by Habanero♥™ Fri Sep 18, 2009 10:39am PDT

    Julia: That is why these blogs don't do well.....no one really reads the bloggers notes they are to eager to comment on nothing.

    Report Abuse
  • One day at a time.'s Avatar
    Posted by One day at a time. Fri Sep 18, 2009 12:52pm PDT

    I use sea salt and I also take an iodine supplement, which is not found in regular stores. I have to have it ordered for me through a whole foods supplement resource. Most people, even with using iodized salt, do not get enough iodine, hence the thyroid problems plaguing America. I would continue to use sea salt, one of it's unique traits is that it does not cause water retention and is easier to digest than commercialized processed iodized salt. Just one person's opionion. Good luck on eating natural.

    Report Abuse
  • Cranberry Lips's Avatar
    Posted by Cranberry Lips Sat Sep 19, 2009 8:23am PDT

    I agree with Just existing. Table salt contains around 67mcg per 1.5 grams of iodine and you need around 150 mcg daily. So you would have to eat almost 3 grams (3,000mg) of salt in order to get enough iodine. Sodium daily intake is recommended to be 2,400mg or less. It makes it even harder for people on low-sodium diets to get enough iodine. Iodine is also found in saltwater fish and seaweed. Most people, especially in recent times, don't get nearly enough Iodine as they should. I really believe they need to think of another way to supply this. At least add it to multivitamins or something.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 20

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

food byte

Thanks to the economy, cookie-exchange parties are more popular than ever. For recipes that will dazzle any crowd, check out BHG.com's 30 greatest cookie hits.