Healthy Living

Thursday, December 3, 2009

6 Reasons to eat the same thing every day

I admit it.  I'm lazy in the kitchen.  The idea of cooking something new every night for only one or two people seems like too much effort.  Sure, if I'm cooking for a big dinner party I'll be motivated to cook up a storm, but for just me or me and my husband, the inspiration level isn't so high.  As a result, we tend to eat the same thing five days a week or so.  This may sound boring, but the more we do this, the more I like it.  Here's why:

  1. It Makes Shopping Easier and More Cost Predictable: Eating the same foods every week allows you to budget properly for groceries and in the end, makes shopping faster and easier.  Every Sunday when I food shop, it takes about 20 minutes, because at this point, it has become very systematic.  I know what I want and I don't even need to make a list.  I get in and get out and always spend within $5 - $10 from week to week.
  2. It Makes Weight Loss or Maintenance a Lot Easier: Whether you want to maintain weight or lose weight, eating consistently the same things can make reaching your goals a lot easier.  Finding healthy foods that you enjoy and entering them into tools like FitDay.com can help you learn what will give you an optimal breakdown of calories, Fat, Protein, Carbs, fiber, and vitamins and minerals.  This gives you a successful eating 'formula', which means you will never have to count calories or nutritional recommended daily allowances again.  You know what works and repeating the formula most days will help you to reach your goal without a lot of time and thought.
  3. Knowing Your Body: Eating the same foods helps you understand your body and how it reacts to foods.  When you eat new or atypical foods, you will be able to hone in on what foods make you feel too full, gassy, not full enough, etc.  Further, it will also give you insights into how your body reacts to chemicals, preservatives and spices.  If you eat healthy most of the time, your body will expect that, and so, if you throw it a curve ball, it will let you know whether or not it likes it.  For instance, if you don't usually have caffeine or drinks with a lot of sugar, you may find that when you do, you get jitters.  I know personally, if on a rare occasion I eat fried foods, my body will feel awful within an hour and sometimes into the next day.
  4. It Makes Cooking a Lot Easier: I use whole foods or ingredients and don't try to get overly complicated.  Breakfast usually consists of a half or a whole grapefruit, a whey protein shake and a cup of coffee.  Lunch always includes a huge salad and some sort of protein, usually an egg-white omelet.  On Sunday nights, I tend to whip up a big batch of baked or grilled chicken (changing up the spices or sauces from week to week), which I can reheat the rest of the week and pair off with another big salad for dinner.  Lastly, I'll have a couple of well-balanced snacks (nutrition bars or a Greek yogurt parfait) in between meals.  All of this is pretty much routine and as a result, it is very easy and saves time.
  5. Greater Appreciation for Off-Days: Having a routine for meals makes dining out or those times you do get creative in the kitchen all the more meaningful.  New dishes and flavors have much more significance and tend to taste extra scrumptious.
  6. Healthy Behavior on Off-Days: If you find the optimal 'formula' from #1 above, you will have a good baseline for when you don't eat the same foods.  You will become very accustomed to how much of what kinds of foods you need and will be able to use that as a guide for the days you digress.

Trust me, I'm not implying that this is the only way to eat, but it sure can simplify things and make navigating healthy eating a lot easier.  If you have kids, this way of eating, I understand, is challenging. But remember, spices, seasonings and sauces can make a simple food like chicken, seem quite different from night to night.

Do you eat the same foods often?  Have you found any other benefits to doing so?

Related Topics:

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 11-20 of 100
  • Brett Blumenthal - Sheer Balance's Avatar
    Posted by Brett Blumenthal - Sheer Balance Thu Jun 18, 2009 8:47am PDT

    Katie B. You need protein in that salad! Try some tuna, chicken or if you can cook, an egg white omelet. For carbs, I'm a big fan of chickpeas or other beans..which also provide some protein.

    Report Abuse
  • Chris S's Avatar
    Posted by Chris S Thu Jun 18, 2009 9:41am PDT

    Dr. Oz says this exact same thing. I kinda agree with him on this (and you, naturally). If you make healthy meals and eat them consistently, you help your body stay healthy. His suggestion is to stick to the same breakfast and lunch for the most part each day. This way your body gets in a rhythm and since you are planning healthy meals, your body is getting the right nutrients each day. I don't see why you couldn't make one of the meals dinner, honestly.

    My husband and I generally eat the same meals each week. Ground turkey, veggie crumbles, turkey, ground beef, etc., with lots of veggies thrown in for color and health. There are many days we just do a vegetarian dish - spaghetti squash and veggies, mac 'n' cheese with loads of veggies. It makes shopping and cooking easier and knowing that the meals contain veggies and generally some form of protein, we're good.

    I'm not sure why people are telling you it's not healthy and for some, yes, it may be boring, but no one said you HAVE to do this. Brett is just saying what works for her and her family. Maybe it would work for yours, maybe not, but it's not a reason to blast her for bad nutrition or boredom.

    Report Abuse
  • Eddieslilangel's Avatar
    Posted by Eddieslilangel Thu Jun 18, 2009 9:47am PDT

    ive tried eating the same thing everyday-i just get so bored of it. the flavor burns off.

    Report Abuse
  • sche's Avatar
    Posted by sche Thu Jun 18, 2009 9:50am PDT

    This really isn't as boring as people think it is! I found a soup I love a few months ago, and two cans will last me the week for my work lunches. I change up what kinds of fruits and veggies and crackers I eat with it each week to provide a little bit of variety. But knowing what I need to buy at the store is loads easier than the way I used to wander up and down the aisles, wondering what in the world I was going to eat all week, and it keeps me from indulging in a lot of junky frozen meals.

    Report Abuse
  • ginas's Avatar
    Posted by ginas Thu Jun 18, 2009 10:21am PDT

    Sorry, there is no way I could eat the same thing every day! I love food way too much. I love to cook and I don't find it difficult to make delicious meals that are healthy. You just need to find some good recipes.

    Report Abuse
  • Andygirl's Avatar
    Posted by Andygirl Thu Jun 18, 2009 11:13am PDT

    This is SO me, but I'm a creature of habit, not all people are. Plus I'm still single. When I cook for a guy, I try to lix it up. And when I have children, I'll do the same so that they learn to eat a variety of cuisines and tastes. :)

    Report Abuse
  • Auguster A's Avatar
    Posted by Auguster A Thu Jun 18, 2009 11:19am PDT

    I think the whole idea (i could be wrong) is to eat basically similar things every week. I pretty much eat the same thing every week but i rotate them. For example, i had two eggs or dry rye toast for breakfast, tomorrow, i'll have smoothie (pineapple juice with strawberry from GNC) for breakfast instead. But there is a pattern to my diet which consist of salads and veggies for lunch and dinner (seafood and meat only during lunch time).

    It's better when you know what you're eating and what it does to your body. That does not mean that you can't make something new, its just better for your body when its in tune than a rollercoaster.

    Report Abuse
  • cindy's Avatar
    Posted by cindy Thu Jun 18, 2009 11:41am PDT

    Ugh, My husband likes the same old stuff week in and week out. If I try to buy something new or change it up, he doesn't like it. I end up going to the store feeling like I am always buying the same thing. I guess this is a new way of looking at it. I have the freedom to change up my breakfast and lunch, but dinner has to be something he will eat.

    Report Abuse
  • Brett Blumenthal - Sheer Balance's Avatar
    Posted by Brett Blumenthal - Sheer Balance Thu Jun 18, 2009 12:13pm PDT

    Auguster, that is a great point. You could find 3 to 4 breakfasts you love that you know are nutritious and mix them up, still eating similar things, but not boring yourself to death!

    Report Abuse
  • Jett's Avatar
    Posted by Jett Thu Jun 18, 2009 12:35pm PDT

    Hmmm. Interesting the responses you're getting, Brett. First off, I do exactly the same thing, and it DOES make shopping and meal planning much easier. Every morning I have multigrain toast with Sunbutter and coffee; for lunch I have Amy's vegetable lentil soup. Even snacks are the same every day: a banana, an apple, mixed nuts. Dinners are the only thing we really change each night, but we'd still try to have leftovers several nights a week to keep costs and mid-week stress down.

    I really have no problem eating the same thing every day and just switching up snacks a little, like soy yogurt instead of a granola bar, or a hard-boiled egg instead of nuts.

    But what I realized just yesterday is that I was getting almost no grains all day! We're supposed to get 7-10 servings of whole grains, and I was getting 1-2 servings on most days, unless I happened to have pasta for dinner one night. Incidentally, Brett, it sounds like you're not getting many grains in your day, either.

    So yesterday I decided to stop having soup for lunch each day; besides being expensive ($2.49/can, five days a week), it is allowing me to miss a great opportunity each day for including really healthy whole grains in my diet. I bought brown rice and lentils last night and made that with green beans for lunch for today and tomorrow. Maybe I'll still have soup once or twice a week for convenience, but the rice and lentils will save me money and improve my diet. Next, I bought oats and made oatmeal chocolate chip cookies last night to use as one of my snacks each day. I know, I know, cookies aren't the greatest, but I made them with whole wheat flour and oats, instead of white flour, and I plan for them to include a sugar alternative next time (succanate and molasses instead of white and brown sugar.) Hey, they're better than one of those Fiber One bars or Health Valley sugar-in-a-wrapper, right? Also, if they keep me away from the candy bowl at work, they're definitely worth it, and they're cheaper than buying a box of granola bars each week

    But my point is, it is definitely cheaper and can be very healthy to eat the same thing each day, or at least the same type of thing, if you like it. I never get bored of my same breakfast every single day, and I look forward to my same snacks and lunch. I love the consistency and knowing what I'm getting each day. And, like you pointed out, Brett, if I hadn't been eating the same thing each day, I wouldn't have realized how deficient my diet is in certain nutrients. Variety of foods doesn't necessarily indicate variety of nutrients.

    Report Abuse
Comments 11-20 of 100

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Updates Chatter on Shine…

Health Byte

Who doesn't want to look hot at all those holiday parties? ExerciseTV shares how to get in skinny jeans-shape -- and quickly!