Healthy Living

Sunday, November 29, 2009

Are you drinking too much?

This week, the American Cancer Society and the American Heart Association came out with the news that the risks of drinking might outweigh its potential health boons. In other words, all that good news we’ve been hearing about how moderate drinking helps your heart, protects against Alzheimer’s and may even strengthen bones is only half the story.

I’m not surprised by their statement, given some research that’s come across my desk recently, including that even moderate sipping might increase risk for breast cancer. Since there’s so much conflicting scientific information on alcohol and health in the news, we decided to go straight to the experts for help in weighing the pros and cons of drinking. What we found—and what it means for you—may surprise you.

Our feature “Is the Party Over?” in the current issue of EatingWell has people (including me) wondering: do I drink too much? Last night, my friend joined me for dinner. While I stirred our stew, she picked up the EatingWell Magazine on my kitchen counter and started reading. At first, she was intrigued by how alcohol positively and negatively affects your body—from your heart to your liver, and by how, exactly, alcohol affects your brain, drink by drink. Then she quickly homed in on the descriptions of “problem” drinking.

“Wow. More than three drinks on any one day is considered ‘high risk.’ I’m known to do that on a Saturday—and now that it’s football season, on Sundays too,” she told me. “I think I need to rein it in.”

“Well… and moderate drinking is technically no more than one drink a day for women,” I said, feeling a little like a party-pooper. “Maybe I need to cut back too.” (Do you drink too much? Take this quiz to find out.)

We paused for a moment before agreeing that justifying a second glass of wine with “it’s good for my heart” wasn’t going to hold up anymore. So we opened a bottle of seltzer instead.

By Nicci Micco

Nicci Micco

Nicci Micco is deputy editor of features and nutrition at EatingWell. She has a master's degree in nutrition and food sciences, with a focus in weight management. She's addicted to ice cream and pizza. But she also can’t imagine going a week without eating sweet potatoes, salad greens or kidney beans. Kale and beets also rank at the top of her favorite-foods list.



Related Links from EatingWell:

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-4 of 4
  • superkate's Avatar
    Posted by superkate Wed Oct 21, 2009 11:45am PDT

    I would of went with the wine. Save the spritzer for when you're old. Or you could have made a wine spritzer. That fun & sorta healthy

    Report Abuse
  • Giz's Avatar
    Posted by Giz Thu Oct 22, 2009 1:58pm PDT

    I think the limitations are a little ridiculous. I'm an active woman who is constantly out and about and I think I take pretty good care of myself. I eat pretty well, don't smoke, don't drink everyday and work out regularly. I could probably use to get more sleep, but it's a work in progress. That said, I'm not going to feel bad about having 2-4 drinks 3-4 nights a week. Are there health risks; sure there are, but even with my moderate drinking habits (and they really are moderate) I am healthier than most the people in this country because I don't eat crap and I exercise. I don't want to, or need to live the maximum length that I can, watching my quality of life decrease and my dependence on others increase. I just want to enjoy my time here. If you gave me the choice of living a good happy life for 65-70 years, doing the things I love and being independent or living for 90 years, watching all my friends and family wither and die, not being mobile, seeing my retirement fund run dry, leaving nothing for my children and winding up in a nursing home, I'm going to choose the first option. Maybe drinking has an added risk of cancer contribution, but I am still far less at risk than the hordes of people who eat and drink processed, packaged crap all day long, so I'm not that worried about it.

    Report Abuse
  • Giz's Avatar
    Posted by Giz Thu Oct 22, 2009 1:58pm PDT

    I think the limitations are a little ridiculous. I'm an active woman who is constantly out and about and I think I take pretty good care of myself. I eat pretty well, don't smoke, don't drink everyday and work out regularly. I could probably use to get more sleep, but it's a work in progress. That said, I'm not going to feel bad about having 2-4 drinks 3-4 nights a week. Are there health risks; sure there are, but even with my moderate drinking habits (and they really are moderate) I am healthier than most the people in this country because I don't eat crap and I exercise. I don't want to, or need to live the maximum length that I can, watching my quality of life decrease and my dependence on others increase. I just want to enjoy my time here. If you gave me the choice of living a good happy life for 65-70 years, doing the things I love and being independent or living for 90 years, watching all my friends and family wither and die, not being mobile, seeing my retirement fund run dry, leaving nothing for my children and winding up in a nursing home, I'm going to choose the first option. Maybe drinking has an added risk of cancer contribution, but I am still far less at risk than the hordes of people who eat and drink processed, packaged crap all day long, so I'm not that worried about it.

    Report Abuse
  • RJ's Avatar
    Posted by RJ Thu Oct 22, 2009 8:08pm PDT

    This seems more like an ad for the magazine than a health article.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-4 of 4

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Updates Chatter on Shine…

Health Byte

Who doesn't want to look hot at all those holiday parties? ExerciseTV shares how to get in skinny jeans-shape -- and quickly!