Healthy Living

Tuesday, February 9, 2010

Do Toning Sneakers Really Work?

Experts say these hot new sneakers can give you a great workout—if you use them the right way.
- Kathryn H. Cusimano, BettyConfidential.com
Even the biggest shoe addicts don’t believe that a new pair will change your life (unless you’re talking about Jimmy Choos…) But the life-changing claim is exactly what many footwear brands are saying these days. The supposed miracle-workers: “toning shoes” incorporating a new design that will help you slim down and firm up just by taking a walk. But can a pair of shoes really help you reduce your bum and thighs? We asked the experts whether the sneakers, which cost anywhere from $70 to $400, are worth it.

Read: The Gym Free Workout

What they claim: An innovative design gives you an automatic workout while you wear them, without having to do any exercise – other than walk, of course. Among the much-touted benefits: Compared to your regular sneakers, you will use three times as much energy while walking, tone your buttocks and thighs, and even (according to some manufacturers) relieve joint pain.

How they work: These shoes are built with an unstable sole that rocks back and forth and forces the wearer to use her muscles in a different way. “They are incorporating what they refer to as ‘wobble board technology,’” explains Dr. Emily Splichal, a New York Sports Club trainer and podiatrist. “They claim that because you are on this sort of rocking chair, you have to engage your abdominals at all times…[they work] the legs and the glutes and the entire body as you’re walking or standing because you’re on this unstable shoe or rocker.”

When to wear them: These shoes are made for walking – no running or weight lifting allowed. “I would not run in them,” Splichal says. “They have a higher heel, you’re kind of elevated and if you were to step wrong…I wouldn’t want to see an injury based on them.” John Rowley, Director of Fitness & Wellness at The American Institute of Healthcare & Fitness in North Carolina and author of Climb Your Ladder of Success Without Running out of Gas, says to avoid wearing them during weight-bearing exercises. (This type of exercise includes low-impact aerobics and using stair-step machines.) “Adding weight just accentuates everything, and if the shoes are throwing you off balance, the weight will become much more dangerous.”

Are they effective? Some users have experienced positive results while wearing the shoes. “I am down another pant size,” says Mary Pitman, a 54-year-old nurse from Vero Beach, Florida. The change occurred when she started wearing “wobble-board” shoes to work less than eight weeks ago. Though the scale hasn’t budged, Mary is constantly complimented on her new shape. “The…difference was in the hips and thighs… I never expected this level of results.” Other users also noticed their legs becoming more toned, and have seen improvements in their agility since they began wearing the shoes.

While experts say the shoes won’t do any harm when used correctly, they probably won’t automatically help you burn calories, lose weight or tone up, unless you increase the amount of time you spend wearing them. “These shoes can help tone a person only if the person wearing the shoes moves more than they ordinarily do,” says Rowley.

Splichal agrees: “If people do feel that they tone, it’s more because they’re walking more or they’re walking the right way, so they’re actually recruiting the muscles they should be recruiting.”

Rowley also cites the motivation factor: “The key advantage of these types of shoes is that they make the consumer more excited to exercise. Oftentimes people need and want a certain outfit, gloves, or pair of shoes to motivate them and get them into [gear]. If that is the case, then go out and get them.”

What if I want to buy them? There are three major companies currently marketing toning shoes, so if you’re interested, you’re bound to find a pair that will get you moving.



MBT, makers of the original rocker-soled shoes, has applied their technology to everything from athletic shoes to boots, though their bulky look and earthy color palette aren’t exactly fashion-forward. The athletic shoes are about $250, but their boots can cost as much as $400.

Skechers Shape-Ups mimic the thick rocker sole and bulky appearance of MBT shoes, but come with a more modest tag, averaging about $110 a pair. Skechers added pink and metallic lavender accents to their black, white and brown sneakers, but it isn’t enough to distract from the shoes’ girth.

Reebok’s EasyTone sneakers use “balance ball” technology to achieve the same results, but look more streamlined – no one would know you were wearing unstable shoes unless they examined the soles. Reebok makes several EasyTone models, which cost around $100 a pair. They come in black and white with pink, blue, yellow and coral accents, but our favorites are the $124.95 gold Reeinspire sneakers.

Kathryn H. Cusimano is an assistant editor at BettyConfidential.







To read more from BettyConfidential | 7 Celeb Diet & Fitness Tips
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 47
  • Coug Girl's Avatar
    Posted by Coug Girl Fri Nov 20, 2009 10:07am PST

    The nurse probably actually lost a pant size because she started exercising, period. I would rather wear regular workout shoes to the gym than these ugly things. They remind me of the Seinfeld episode when Kramer had special shoes for basketball.

    Report Abuse
  • J's Avatar
    Posted by J Fri Nov 20, 2009 10:19am PST

    I suffer from planter faciitis and nothing would help. My aunt bought me a pair of fitflops from ebay. I don't know if it is the soft sole or if the shoes have strenghtened the muscles in my foot but I have zero pain in my foot now. I don't care what they look like. I love them. I can always embellish them myself.

    Report Abuse
  • Cheri's Avatar
    Posted by Cheri Fri Nov 20, 2009 10:26am PST

    I've been wearing these type shoes for a year and a half and LOVE them. I'm also a Nurse. My heels used to be extremely tender at the end of my shift. When I started using the news shoes for work I felt much better and I rarely experience heel pain anymore. I wear them almost everywhere now! I haven't noticed much toning but my over-all balance is much better!

    Report Abuse
  • Strawberry's Avatar
    Posted by Strawberry Fri Nov 20, 2009 10:29am PST

    want to try these out but they are very expensive and I walk at work on a hard concrete surface which in truth hurts my feel in conventional tennis shoe....however I bought a pair of skecthers work shoes and they seem to help a lot in keeping my feet from hurting and more cushion on the hard surface and my legs do feel it at the end of the night and im losing weight with no other exercise....but I do walk a lot at work and have cut back on pop...but I feel better at the end of the night and it makes me want to walk more cause theres no pain ....so maybe thats how it works through your mind and if you feel better you tend to exercise more....who knows but 100.00 a shoe so I can spill grease on them I dont think so lol...

    Report Abuse
  • justin's Avatar
    Posted by justin Fri Nov 20, 2009 10:34am PST

    Toning shoes are worth a try for people who experience foot, leg or back pain when walking, but the idea that a different pair of shoes will directly impact you losing weight is a bit silly. Experiment with different brands and styles of sneakers and find one that works well for you. A lot of running stores have experienced athletes as salespeople who will video you walking or running on a treadmill and suggest a particular shoe. Many will also offer no-questions-asked 90-day returns so you can buy several pairs without worry.

    Report Abuse
  • Ona's Avatar
    Posted by Ona Fri Nov 20, 2009 10:53am PST

    I saw the ad for the Reebok shoes. I will never buy them on principal of the sexist and degrading ad no matter how awesome they may be. The commercial didn't even show the shoes, just the breasts and butt of the actress. And I'm not sure how her breasts were important since it was a shoe commercial.

    Shame on you Reebok!!!

    Report Abuse
  • AC's Avatar
    Posted by AC Fri Nov 20, 2009 12:12pm PST

    I want to try the Reebok versions of this shoe. I do alot of walking during the day and it would be nice to have that added benefit. Also the Reeboks arent nearly as ugly as the sketchers which look a little like orthopedic shoes to me. So I guess we'll see how they work! Those insoles that Molly brought up look interesting too.

    Report Abuse
  • R.G's Avatar
    Posted by R.G Fri Nov 20, 2009 1:03pm PST

    I don't know a lot about the Reebok version, but I have been around the Skechers and the MBT's for quite awhile. In comparison, the Skechers do not do nearly the amount of support, exercise benefits, or foot health as the MBT's do. I have seen many people benefit from these shoes over the past few years. Most people that have chosen to use these shoes, have been medical employees.. restaurant workers.. people with plantar faciitis and other foot ailments. Trying these shoes on, and actually walking 5 minutes in them, you will definitely feel the toning..but you will also realize your posture is better and you never feel the surface beneath your feet. Give these shoes a try, because 9 out of 10 people I have been around have truly enjoyed these shoes.

    Report Abuse
  • Linda W's Avatar
    Posted by Linda W Fri Nov 20, 2009 3:16pm PST

    I'm planning on buying those Reebok shoes and giving them a try. Now I won't probably ever look like that young girl in the video, but I do want to put them to good use. I like to walk at night, they sound like they may help tone me some.

    Report Abuse
  • Robyn's Avatar
    Posted by Robyn Fri Nov 20, 2009 9:14pm PST

    my boyfriend has the sketchers and it did help with little hard exercise areas so i vouge for them

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 47

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Health Byte

Get healthy foods for your family that won’t take a bite out of your budget.  Healthy living costs less at Walmart.