Healthy Living

Saturday, December 5, 2009

Do you really need to eat all organic food to be healthy?

http://www.wmin.ac.uk/sih/images/FruitVeg.jpg

http://www.wmin.ac.uk/sih/images/FruitVeg.jpg

Over the weekend, I was driving the countryside with my mother-in-law and we spotted a flock of wild turkeys, which always makes me crazy happy. We never used to see turkeys when I was a kid and that's all directly linked to the environmental impact of DDT on the Wisconsin wildlife. No turkeys, no hawks, no pelicans either, but now they're coming back and it's a beautiful thing. I found myself branching into a litany about the evils of pesticides, which then devolved into a rant about HFCS. Then I realized that the words coming out of my mouth sounded eerily very similar to a speech I'd heard from a crazy homeless person, only he brought his argument back around to Jesus, while mine cited the gospel of Michael Pollan. I apologized for getting on a soap box and then changed the subject, but I was left wondering how much of my crazy hippy childhood is now coming to the surface. When I was a kid, I purposely bucked against my parents' bulgar fantasies of organic foods, fetishizing Wonder Bread and Cap'N Crunch, but now I find myself gravitating toward simple ingredients lists and feeling very distrustful of The Man that hides behind the cheery faces of Betty Crocker and Sara Lee.

Boost your cancer-fighting potential by choosing produce grown without synthetic pesticides.


My husband always makes fun of me when I pass over the $3 gallon of regular milk to take the $7 gallon of organic milk. "Don't you know where milk comes from? It's all freaking ORGANIC." Well, no, not in the truest sense of the word, it's not. In the scientific world, "organic" means that the item contains carbon, or was produced "of the earth." "Organic" in the consumer packaged goods industry is a shorthand way of saying that the item was produced without hormones, chemical fertilizers or pesticides. Besides, I buy just one brand of organic milk because it tastes better, not because it's necessarily organic. But truthfully, if the prices were the same, I would buy organic every damned time without even batting an eye. The word "organic" has come to be some kind of benediction of health in my mind, even though I know that it's not always the case.

Take for example, this recent article in The New York Times about Dr. Alan Greene, who performed a three-year experiment where nothing but organic food passed his lips. After three years, he found that he's feeling much more healthy, is resistant to colds and flu bugs, and has very yellow pee (um, thanks for sharing). He credits the inherent organic-ness of his food choices, but also mentions that he had to cut back on the amount of meat he was eating in order to keep the costs down, which probably had something to do with his increased energy as well (as Chow astutely pointed out). One of the primary things I noticed when I was a vegetarian (eating distinctly non-organic fare, because I was so very poor) was the increase in energy and the immediate decrease in energy whenever I'd consume meat. Also, I would assume that Dr. Greene was eating more fruits and vegetables after going organic, too. (Don't forget about these exotic winter fruits that will keep you energized.)

Eating organic or not is a personal and financial decision for everyone, but it's frustrating to see confusing messages like "you must eat organic to feel better" coming from a health professional when really, there were at least three variables to Dr. Greene's amazing health improvement. Claiming his health benefits are all due to organic food is shoddy root cause analysis. The important take away is not "buy the $7 milk" but rather, look at the amazing stuff that can happen when you eat mostly plants. Whoops, there I go quoting Michael Pollan again. Look...turkeys!

Related:Don't eat these over-processed foods for breakfast!

MORE FROM WEETABIX AND SELF:

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 11-20 of 22
  • Adi'sMommy's Avatar
    Posted by Adi'sMommy Fri Dec 12, 2008 11:59am PST

    I did a diet for 30 days that included recipes using only organic ingredients. About half way through I decided organic was too expensive and I was going to follow the recipes and just use normal foods, fruits and vegetables. I continued to lose weight and ended up losing a total of 18 pounds. I did not notice any difference in the amount I was losing prior to going to normal foods from organic. I really believe for some things it is better, but all in all, if you are eating healthy and getting your daily amounts of fruits and vegetables, that is just as good coming from non-organic foods.

    Report Abuse
  • Zeplin522's Avatar
    Posted by Zeplin522 Fri Dec 12, 2008 1:38pm PST

    I am 56 years old and thank God very healthy. I grew up on a farm

    and drank milk right from the bulk tank. For you city folks, its

    where the milk is stored until the milkman comes to get it. We

    would just put our pitcher under the nozzel turn it and get milk

    put it in the frig. Next morning you would either scrap the cream

    off hte top if you wanted whipped cream or else just shkae it up

    and pour some. With all the concerns over the germs, God how did

    I make it this far.

    Report Abuse
  • Habanero♥™'s Avatar
    Posted by Habanero♥™ Fri Dec 12, 2008 3:31pm PST

    Zeplin522: You gave me goose bumps. Love the whipped cream thing. You can't buy whipping cream like that unless from a farm. Your comment about germs is so true. I actually have to eat 13 billion-ah never mind nobody would get it. Good for you. I am 55 years old and even my own kids think I am in my thirties. They are goofy. Must be the dirt I feed them~~~BWaaaaaah

    Report Abuse
  • Phoenix's Avatar
    Posted by Phoenix Fri Dec 12, 2008 4:16pm PST

    In answer to the main title question, no. You only need to make sure the level of toxins you take in, (that includes edible, breathable, absorbable, etc...) is lower than the level of toxins your body can naturally process. Toxins are in your life no matter what. Your body makes its own toxins under stress! You can't avoid it completely. You can only determine your personal needs by taking steps toward good health (eating organic, being active, nutritional suppliments etc...) and listening to your body. Yes, I do believe eating organic food keeps me healthy, but I don't let that get in the way of enjoying a normal life (read: cheeseburger).

    Peace

    Report Abuse
  • Habanero♥™'s Avatar
    Posted by Habanero♥™ Sat Dec 13, 2008 5:14am PST

    PLEASE ALL-Sign the Shine Christmas card, whatever your beliefs.

    Report Abuse
  • wu's Avatar
    Posted by wu Sat Dec 13, 2008 8:55am PST

    Hi,buddy!Would you like to make friends with people from other country or place? Log on ~~mixed friends. c o m~~ Then you can get help and suggestions from all over the world. While you can find your true love or friendship there.

    Report Abuse
  • MarriageFan's Avatar
    Posted by MarriageFan Sat Dec 13, 2008 10:14am PST

    It's your choice if you choose to pay more for "organic" foods, but I get annoyed when so-called "healthy" eaters (vegetarians & organic-only people, etc) pass judgement on those who cannot afford or do not choose to buy these foods. Many health-food proponents exude a serious vibe of superiority (as evidenced in this article) over those who do not share their beliefs and make the same choices they make. I eat a very balanced diet full of fresh fruits and vegetables, whole grains, and lean proteins, but I actually make an effort to avoid buying anything that says "organic" on the label. Why? Because organic does not make a difference in anything except for the grocery bill and one's ego. The benefits of eating organic are largely psychosomatic. If you think it makes you feel better, then okay...but please don't try preaching to me that the only way I will every be truly healthy is to join your crusade.

    Report Abuse
  • LMA_Mikey's Avatar
    Posted by LMA_Mikey Sat Dec 13, 2008 10:43am PST

    I was farm and ranch raised but lived in the city for many years. Being single working in the casino business I never thought about my eating habits very much for many years. I just thought weight gain was a normal fact of life. One day I mentioned it to an athlete freind of mine who was in terrific shape, also older than me. We started working out together 3 or 4 times a week for a couple years, results for me weren't bad and I felt good. Then he posed the question how were you living when you looked the way you want to look? I now live on 2acres grow a garden; order a beef from the old home place from a freind of my father's, work outside at a long slow pace. Lost over 62 lbs. in two years. I also take quite a large amount of fresh produce to the local food share program. Organic, the only thing I spray on my place is water, let nature take its course, there is plenty left over.

    Report Abuse
  • Spam I Am's Avatar
    Posted by Spam I Am Sat Dec 13, 2008 12:28pm PST

    From "Puddinghead Wilson" by Mark Twain:

    "The secret to a long life is this. Eat what you'd rather not eat,

    drink what you'd rather not drink, and do what you'd rather not do."

    Report Abuse
  • Habanero♥™'s Avatar
    Posted by Habanero♥™ Mon Dec 15, 2008 4:58am PST

    Marriage: You are absolutely correct about not having to eat organic. As long as you wash all fruits and vegetables you are eating healthy. As I mentioned earlier, I am fortunate to live in a town that has so many farms and I can eat so much more efficiently than having to go to the store or a farmers market. It is so much cheaper to visit the farm and pick out a what you need for the day instead of having to keep the fresh foods hanging around all week. I avoid strictly organic, it is not necessary. Healthy Eating and Merry Christmas.

    Report Abuse
Comments 11-20 of 22

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Health Byte

Tune in to our fitness forecast! These are the top ten exercise trends for 2010.