Healthy Living

Sunday, November 8, 2009

Elastic Waist book club: Making the Cut--the preliminaries

Okay. So a goodly number of you are going to do this crazy Making the Cut thing with me, but we've all solemnly sworn to not be crazy about it, right? If we can't do a side plank, we're not going to burst all the tendons up and down our bodies trying to do a side plank, and if we can't sprint at 9 miles an hour for 10 minutes, we're not going to sprint at 9 miles an hour for 10 minutes, right? Right. We're going to eat enough to not feel dizzy, exercise rationally and not to the brink of exhaustion, and we're going to drink plenty of water and take our vitamins. Or I'll come to your house and kick you.

So far, this is what I've got: I've read the foreword carefully. Jillian is very committed to being your god. That makes me uncomfortable. But she's also very into the whole mental preparation, if you believe in yourself, you can do it! Exclamation points! And that's something that is extremely dorky, but also kind of nice. Okay, Jillian! Let's do this thing! High five! Please don't kill me! 

Before you begin, there are pages of preparations that one must make. She suggests "goodbye photos," which I'm going to have to skip, mostly because I am not down with photographic evidence of me in my underpants. Maybe you are braver than me. Then there's body fat analysis, measurements, and a fitness test, all of which make me want to close the book, go get a cupcake, and frost it with butter. But okay. I've got a Tanita scale. I've just got to figure out how it works, with the body composition. And the fitness tests are all easy to perform at home, and make me very sad. Push-ups? DO NOT WANT. But I'll do it. And I'll post my results in the comments, and you can laugh at me. And then, you better be posting yours.

In the meantime, I've calculated my basal metabolic rate (the minimum number of calories my body requires to allow me to lie in bed all day and keep breathing). If it's to be believed, that's 1,410 calories a day. That seems terribly low. I am not going to worry too much about sticking to this number--I'm going to try to stick, instead, with the general eating plan as a guideline--it emphasizes a lot of cooking healthy stuff at home, avoiding sweets and alcohol and drinking a lot of water, and that sounds pretty reasonable to me.

The recipe section is organized in an irritating way, and it took me an endless amount of flipping back and forth between the meal plan and the pile of jumbled recipes to figure out a grocery list, which is two pages long. For five days, to start. The whole thing is starting to make me wonder what, exactly, I'm doing here, and can't I just keep eating granola bars for every meal? No? ----- .

There's also way too much flipping back and forth between the exercise plan for each day and the description of the exercises in the back of the book. I kept losing my place. I kept getting frustrated. I wanted to rip apart the book with my teeth, which is totally aerobic. I persevered, however, and wrote out my exercise plan for the next week. I wrote down the descriptions and even drew helpful stick-figure diagrams (you want me to do what with my left ankle and my right elbow?) and I am sure I will look just the tiniest bit insane at the gym tomorrow, pulling out my crumpled sheet of paper and consulting it between manic yankings at the various weight machines, but I'm okay with that. I think. Please don't let the gym be crowded.

So. Preliminary preparations: prepared. Loins: girded. Grocery shopping: tonight. The gym: tomorrow. Am I ready? No! But I'm going to do it anyway. Are you ready?


Related Links from Elastic Waist and
SELF:

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-8 of 8
  • EmilyA's Avatar
    Posted by EmilyA Fri May 30, 2008 7:42pm PDT

    Okay so I did Jillian's book before Hawaii. Don't be fooled this IS a commitment! But by the time I left I was in such great physical shape. This book will really get you the body you deserve. The first day I was insanely sore, but felt really great about the changes I was making. I recommend doing it with a partner to keep you honest about all the circuit training. Good luck!

    Report Abuse
  • mary t's Avatar
    Posted by mary t Sat May 31, 2008 6:08am PDT

    Although I haven't seen this book, it sounds very similar to Tony Horton's P90X program--a serious 90 day work out and diet change plan. P90X doesn't require a gym, though. Okay, you need some free weights or resistance bands, a yoga mat, and a pull up bar, but it's still cheaper than a gym membership.

    Report Abuse
  • BIG J's Avatar
    Posted by BIG J Sat May 31, 2008 8:29am PDT

    wow, the author sounds like a real pansy

    Report Abuse
  • BIG J's Avatar
    Posted by BIG J Sat May 31, 2008 8:29am PDT

    wow, the author sounds like a real pansy

    Report Abuse
  • Katie's Avatar
    Posted by Katie Sat May 31, 2008 9:25am PDT

    I haven't read "Making The Cut" either, and I'm not familiar with Jillian Michaels. It sounds a little over the top, do or die. Side planks?! 9 mile sprints?! Can't be fun, and if it's not fun are you really going back for more? "Sculpting Her Body Perfect", Brad Shoenfeld, is a great book if you're into getting in shape and enjoying it (isn't that the point?). No gym or special equipment required, just a couple of free weights and a resistance band. Work as hard as you want for the muscle definition you want, no pressure, no side planks. And it really works.

    Report Abuse
  • angiepants's Avatar
    Posted by angiepants Sat May 31, 2008 10:03am PDT

    i work with a personal trainer, and he is tough, but geeze... you shouldn't do more than you can handle. it's a *great* way to hurt yourself or pass out on the treadmill doing those sprints.

    i'm in okay shape and i can do a 5.5 mile sprint on a good day. this is just another way for jillian michaels to make money off of people who want to get in shape. you don't need her. just get off your rump and go to a gym or go exercise on your own.

    Report Abuse
  • PetLover's Avatar
    Posted by PetLover Sat May 31, 2008 10:15am PDT

    The crazy sprints mentioned take alot of editorial license...Our blog queen has a great sense of humor - kinda necessary for working out! I read Making the Cut, followed the meal plan (signed up for Jillian's online support for 2 weeks to get more menus) and did 30 Day Shred for the workouts (one of Jillian's DVDs). I got lost in the workouts in the book too...flipping back and forth and I'm not so good on form, so the DVD was a much better way to go. I didn't lose much (like 5 lbs) but everything fits better, my arms lost the jello jiggle, my calves are larger and firmer (not so happy with the larger but so it goes) - this works. I'm up for Round 2! My DVD and my book cost lots less than a Personal Trainer, and it all came from Amazon.com.

    Report Abuse
  • mainemommyof2's Avatar
    Posted by mainemommyof2 Mon Jun 2, 2008 7:06am PDT

    I just bought the book at Borders, read thru it, thought about it, flipped back and forth and back again, figured out my BMR (1314) which seems very low to me, found out I'm a slow oxidizer, looked at the menus and the grocery list (holy crap, that's a lot of fish to eat! and my kids are NOT going to eat it 5 nights a week) I know she hammers into you that this is a TOTAL commitment but seriously, who has the time?? I work 50 hrs a week and have a teenager and a toddler. I am going with her exercise plans and will stick to the calorie level and some of her meals but I've been doing pretty good with my own food choices. I'll buy the "30 day Shred" video and we'll go from there. I did learn some from her though and the mental "can-do" attitude with it really has you thinking.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-8 of 8

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Health Byte

You know you need to hydrate. But is the water you're drinking safe? Here are 7 ways to be sure your water's fit for you.