Healthy Living

Tuesday, December 1, 2009

Health care reform: What prevention really means

With the President's address to Congress on health care reform yesterday, the grass roots are in a highly energized state. I have received at least 4 separate e-mails yesterday from 4 separate organizations calling on me to advocate for an emphasis on prevention.  Call Congress, write the President, let your feelings be known!

Well, my feelings are in fact these: We need a bracing dose of humility.  The foundations of “health” are not built in hospitals or clinics.  They are built in kitchens and family rooms; in schools and neighborhoods; and in supermarkets and backyards. Here's what I think:

1) I believe basic access to needed care is a human right, so universal coverage -- by one means or another -- is a must.  
2) I believe we can do far better at standardizing quality, and by so doing, saving both lives and dollars.
3) I believe that how people live their lives each day—whether or not they smoke, what they eat, whether or not they are active, and so on—is the master lever of medical destiny. To look for the true power of disease prevention and health promotion in so-called “health care reform” is to look well beyond its horizon. Health care matters most when things go wrong, but can do relatively little at the points of true origin to ensure things go right.

My worry is that in expecting too much of health care reform, we may simply fail to achieve any aspect of it.  We need health care reform to ensure that what clinicians can do, they do well—and for everyone.  But we must acknowledge that clinicians alone cannot build the foundations of health.  For that, we need reforms that reverberate through our culture and society, to the places we actually live out the lives we are trying to protect.

We can, I believe, achieve both.  But not if we mistake the one for the other.

Take Charge of Your Health!
25 ridiculously healthy foods
12 ways to lower blood pressure naturally
Worst habits for your immune system
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 25
  • springtime's Avatar
    Posted by springtime Thu Sep 10, 2009 12:07pm PDT

    It's amazing that it took years to take on the big tobacco companies. Americans were finally told the truth... smoking can kill you. Then we learn that second hand smoke can kill you. Yet, look how many people still light up.

    I believe the schools should do more to serve healthier options, and their states' legislators should support that costly effort. But when has education ever been on the front burner in any state? It's difficult to get adults to change food behaviors, but children would have healthier diets if taught early.

    Report Abuse
  • KarenF's Avatar
    Posted by KarenF Thu Sep 10, 2009 1:38pm PDT

    I think education is key - tell people why they shouldn't smoke, why they need to eat healthier - and give them the long term impacts of doing so. People also need the warning signs for the onset of certain diseases and conditions such as diabetes.

    Report Abuse
  • Habanero♥™'s Avatar
    Posted by Habanero♥™ Fri Sep 11, 2009 6:09am PDT

    You, so far, are the only important voice that I have read concerning health care reform. I can not preach this enough!!!

    Thanks.

    Report Abuse
  • Lizbeth's Avatar
    Posted by Lizbeth Fri Sep 11, 2009 7:29am PDT

    Yes, I agree. A balance of equal, accesible care for everyone combined with personal initiative and responsibility.

    I don't know when it started or how to change it, but there seems to be a strong essence of enabling and entitlement in this country; glorification of the victim is rampant throughout the media and culture. I believe Capitalism is largely to blame for the attitudes we possess; this false belief that we can simply buy whatever it is 'they' tell us is missing form our lives. For all our individualism, the independant thinker seems to be an endangered species.

    I include myself in the persuasion; it's hard to look out at the world and see certain things and find myself wanting them and believing the message I'm being sold. My perception is my responsibility and I do my best to protect it and keep it in check.

    I wish people didn't feel so alone in their struggles; we're all experiencing the smae thing on various levels. If only we didn't have egos, hahaha, we could be so much more compassionate and accepting.

    I will say, practically speaking, I look forward to being able to afford a good teeth cleaning and a new pair of glasses! I'll celebrate those little things and be grateful for everything else.

    Report Abuse
  • Angela's Avatar
    Posted by Angela Fri Sep 11, 2009 8:15am PDT

    I think this is a great post from Dr. Katz.

    Funding education at the earliest age is key. My undergraduate advisor, who spent her early years teaching Catholic school, had a bumper sticker on her door. It read something like: "Students have bake sales to buy books, but the military never has bake sales for bombs." That may not be the exact wording, but the message is still clear, education funding in this nation is abysmal, but billions are thrown at wars.

    I'm happy to see that there has been a push in recent years to save recess and save gym classes. When I was a child in the 80s, gym class was once a week, and recess was a rare. Recess stopped all together at grade three, being something only for "little kids." Last I checked, eight and nine year olds were still "little kids" in desperate need of time to run around and play.

    In other nations, the best and brightest aren't just encouraged to become doctors and lawyers, because those are the best paying most important jobs; they're also encouraged to become teachers. What job could be more important that becoming a teacher? Who else fosters the best and brightest among us but teachers? We need to treat teachers better, pay them more, treat them with more respect, and perhaps then we'll start to turn out more doctors and health care professionals.

    Report Abuse
  • anonymous whatever's Avatar
    Posted by anonymous whatever Fri Sep 11, 2009 8:28am PDT

    Thank you Dr. Katz. We all know just as in education good health starts at home with the parents.

    And we all know it takes hard work to maintain good health.

    However, with this reform speech, The Dems are trying to turn that hard work into entitlements, like they haven't already.

    Report Abuse
  • Hannah's Avatar
    Posted by Hannah Fri Sep 11, 2009 11:59am PDT

    Educational funding in this country is fine, and there is no evidence that spending increases has corresponded with equal improvement in American education. Education reform efforts should focus on improving resource allocation. According to the National Center for Education Statistics, only 52 percent of public education expenditures are spent on instruction. This percentage has slowly been decreasing over recent decades.The private schools in my community all have recess and physical education programs from kindergarten to 12th grade. Teaching your children good eating habits and getting them away from the TV and computers would certainly be a step in the right direction. Continued pressure to make schools reinstate phys ed classes is a given.

    Report Abuse
  • classicalmuzclovr's Avatar
    Posted by classicalmuzclovr Fri Sep 11, 2009 1:36pm PDT

    Hannah, I agree.

    The schools here all have physical ed, which I feel is so important, and all the public schools have playgrounds, and recess. However, as you pointed out, in many parts of the country, recess, phys ed... is all but gone. Obesity rates among kids, are alarming, and with adults as well.

    Heart disease and diabetes are two of the biggest killers in our country. Heart disease being number one I believe.

    I do agree with the doc on some of his points. Except number one, I don't believe in "universal healthcare"

    I DO want everyone to be able to get affordable coverage, but I don't believe in single payer healthcare.

    However, his statement below, can be taken one of two ways:

    "For that, we need reforms that reverberate through our culture and society, to the places we actually live out the lives we are trying to protect"

    If he's speaking of "reform" in terms of parents taking charge of their kids lives again, and making healthy choices, and a general health revolution of sorts, led only by individual choice and the proactiveness of the individual, then that sounds great.

    But if he's implying, that there needs to be some sort of governmental, or state reform.... to force healthy living onto people, then that's simply not going to work.

    As much as it erks some people and as much as it hurts our health as a nation at times, people do have freedom of choice in this country.

    I wholeheartedly agree with the good doc, that living healthier lives, will help all of us in the long run. How do we do that? Without taking away people's freedom to choose?

    Aside from educating our kids about good health, and healthy eating and exercise habits, and adults trying to set a good example, there is not much else one can do.

    Hannah has it, increase the physical ed classes, any school that doesn't have recess, needs to reinstate it NOW. We need to encourage all kids to join any kind of sports team, or do some kind of activity, even if it's just telling them to get off the couch and go outside and play.

    As parents, we can eat healthy and try to remain active, when we do this, our kids see our example. This will have an effect on who they become as adults.

    Report Abuse
  • __A_YAHOO_USER__'s Avatar
    Posted by __A_YAHOO_USER__ Fri Sep 11, 2009 1:46pm PDT

    Great post! I wholeheartedly agree!

    And Angela, I'm with you on the teacher part. It's AMAZING to me that idiots like "Heidi and Spencer" make so much money for being just that...idiots; yet our teachers make such low salaries. There should ABSOLUTELY be more funding for those amazing men and women who work so hard to shape our youth.

    Have a great day!

    Report Abuse
  • classicalmuzclovr's Avatar
    Posted by classicalmuzclovr Fri Sep 11, 2009 1:54pm PDT

    You're right lala...

    I wish my husband, who is a teacher and Vice Principal, did get paid what he's worth...

    Well, truth be told, college professors, also typically don't make a ton of money.

    Too bad, that as you say, we value "spiedie" more than kids and their education...

    But, alas, teachers get paid a very low salary, in terms of what they're required to do in the classroom, and at home on their on time.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 25

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Updates Chatter on Shine…

Health Byte

Who doesn't want to look hot at all those holiday parties? ExerciseTV shares how to get in skinny jeans-shape -- and quickly!