Healthy Living

Tuesday, February 9, 2010

Health Controversy: Woman Arrested for Drinking While Breastfeeding

http://www.spokane7.com/images/2005/mar/4/martini.jpg
What do you think of this: A woman in North Dakota is facing 5 years in prison for breastfeeding her 6-week-old infant while intoxicated. Some are calling her a child abuser. Others disagree and say she doesn't deserve such a harsh punishment. Let's discuss ...

****
Stacey Anvarinia, a 26-year-old in Grand Forks, North Dakota, recently pleaded guilty to a felony count of child neglect. The reason? Breastfeeding her 6-week-old back in April after having one too many. The police officers who cuffed her noted that alcohol can be passed through breast milk, and that she was endangering her child. Now she may be facing 5 years in prison.

Where do I begin? First off, the issue of drinking while breastfeeding is very controversial. Some doctors say plain and simple: Don't do it. Others encourage the pump-and-dump method. But there are many more who note that drinking a small glass of wine now and then isn't going to harm your child.

New Low-Alcohol Wine: Bad Idea or Brilliant?

My personal rule of thumb is somewhere in the middle: As a breastfeeding mother myself, I admit to craving an occasional glass of wine. It relaxes me! But I keep it to one small glass (seriously, I use these tiny little things)--never more (unless it's my mom's low-alcohol sangrias that we're talking about). And, I don't go near "hard" alcohol. I'll save the dirty martinis for when I'm done nursing Russell.

Bottom line: Do I think that breastfeeding while drunk is a bad idea? Yes--100 percent. But do I think that a woman should be taken away from her infant and locked up for five years because of it? I'm sorry, but I just don't think so. Here's a better idea: Put the woman on probation. Make her take a year of parenting classes (which she clearly needs). Assign a CPS worker to make visits. Test her blood-alcohol level ever Friday night--whatever needs to be done. But, it breaks my heart to see a mother separated from her infant in these circumstances.

What do you think of this?

P.S. In cased you missed it, here's a story about a woman who was arrested for breastfeeding while driving and, um, also talking on her cell phone.

More from Vitamin G:

*Drinking while pregnant--Vitamin G readers weigh in.
*Would you ever breastfeed someone else's child? Salma Hayek did.

MORE FROM VITAMIN G:
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 20
  • Anita's Avatar
    Posted by Anita Mon Jun 29, 2009 1:51pm PDT

    Why was she even getting drunk to begin with? She's a new mother! Maybe she needs to go to rehab instead of prison...

    Report Abuse
  • SFgal's Avatar
    Posted by SFgal Mon Jun 29, 2009 2:00pm PDT

    This is so sad. The woman needs some help, not prison. I had a little wine in the evenings while I was breastfeeding, it is relaxing and if you're careful, not a problem. Let's support women going through the difficult early days of motherhood, not incarcerate them. Geez.

    Report Abuse
  • another hockey fan's Avatar
    Posted by another hockey fan Mon Jun 29, 2009 2:12pm PDT

    Finally, something happens in North Dakota!

    Report Abuse
  • springtime's Avatar
    Posted by springtime Mon Jun 29, 2009 3:04pm PDT

    No, she should not be separated from her child. Because she was drinking doesn't mean she is a neglectful mom; it does clearly illustrate that she was not thinking of the harm it could do to her baby. Another concern that she should think very hard about is that you can not possibly take good care of a small child if you have been drinking too much.

    It sounds as though this woman is short of good mental processing, but prison will not cure that. She should be assigned to probation with weekly parenting classes.

    Report Abuse
  • Doktor Eevol's Avatar
    Posted by Doktor Eevol Mon Jun 29, 2009 4:09pm PDT

    This is a good blog post. Yeah, that sentence is over the top, and it's going to be traumatic for both mother and child. Our society has a throw away attitude with people and it solves NOTHING.

    Report Abuse
  • who me?'s Avatar
    Posted by who me? Mon Jun 29, 2009 5:57pm PDT

    No she shouldn't go to prison. She should have to do parenting classes, drug and alcohol counseling, and probation for at least 2 years! That baby needs his/her mother no matter what.

    Report Abuse
  • __A_YAHOO_USER__'s Avatar
    Posted by __A_YAHOO_USER__ Mon Jun 29, 2009 7:09pm PDT

    I dont think a little hurts, but she really shouldn't over do it.

    Report Abuse
  • C.C.'s Avatar
    Posted by C.C. Tue Jun 30, 2009 5:58am PDT

    To me, this is no different than driving while intoxicated. The question is not "how much alcohol is being passed in the milk to the child". The mom could have dropped her kid! The child could have died! In a worse case scenario, there was a woman who, drunk and nursing, passed out and rolled over on her child, smothering it! Yes, she probably wasn't going to hurt the child, but plenty of people have "had a few and made it home OK" IT'S NO EXCUSE! If she was intoxicated and nursing, some jail time is A-OK with me! She didn't have a small glass of wine, she was drunk, according to the article. You can argue about whether 5 years is kinda harsh for a first timer but to say that there is nothing wrong with it is really missing the point. Would you drive around town with no baby seat? Our parents all did it and most kids grew up OK... Same idea---and a very, very, bad one!

    Report Abuse
  • HawkeyeGirl's Avatar
    Posted by HawkeyeGirl Tue Jun 30, 2009 7:58am PDT

    Jail time? Why would you punish a newborn by throwing the mom in jail? I agree, in this case mandatory parenting classes and monitoring are in order, not punishing the child by separating it from it's mother for the first five years of its life.

    Report Abuse
  • depends on who you ask's Avatar
    Posted by depends on who you ask Tue Jun 30, 2009 8:04am PDT

    she shouldn't have breastfed while drinking or right after; i think. but that being said what's this officers perception of one too many? could have been having a drink, two drinks, getting hammered? how did this guy determine this? personally maybe she should have thought about how much too drink and how much to pump before. she needs a little help with herr parenting but not jail, it was a drink and poor judgement. she was not sitting on top of a moving vehicle while holding her child. there are alot of worse things she could have used poor judement on actually.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 20

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Health Byte

Get healthy foods for your family that won’t take a bite out of your budget.  Healthy living costs less at Walmart.