I am not going to argue my pro-choice opinions either. I've done that in a previous blog and I think that it is irrelevant here, though slightly pertinent. However, suffice to say that I think a completely illegal abortion policy is folly. We are asking for trouble as a society (all religious freedoms aside) and I think that regulated, safe abortions performed in moderation are the best route. But, that's just me.
But, contracpetion is a whole other story. Prompted by this post that described a phramacist who refused to sell contraceptives, I decided I needed to say something here. What is going on with this? As the daughter of a former Catholic who converted to another strict Christian religion which will go unnamed, I know that the anti-contraception idea is a religious and Catholic one. But, lordy be, why is religious policy affecting state policy? Ever heard of sepatation of church and state. Just because a certain religion forbids contraceptives, does not make it ok to deny them to others who are not of that religion and who are perfectly whithin their rights to practice (or not practice) any religion they choose!
And just to be clear, I am a deeply spiritual person who respects all religions from Buddhism to Islam to Christianity, and who think they're all saying the same thing so why don't we all stop arguing already. But, what I have a problem with is when one religion tries to dictate political policy.
But, that's just me on the furious bus. Let's discuss logic for a minute. I know it's hard, but try to sit still. As my mother explained it to me, and the same with Kristi Burton, any time a pregnancy is prevented is abortion. "God created sex for procreation," so clearly if you are having sex not to procreate (even within wedlock), you are sinning in the eyes of the church (or God). Well, pardon me if I think this is a dangerous view. Well, hell, I'm preventing pregnancies every day when I wake up, go to work, go to bed alone, and focus on my career instead of husband hunting. Therefore, since I'm clearly not procreating, I must be having abortions, daily, hourly even. I am sinning by not popping babies out as fast as my eggs will drop.
And then how about women who miscarry or can't have children? They must be sinning too since they prevent pregnancies every single darn day. Every time a baby isn't born, does an angel lose its wings? Ok, bad joke, but c'mon people, the logic is seriously flawed.
That brings me to a point I've made over and over. Many people throughout the history of time have had too many children they can feed simply because they do not have access to contraceptives or they are illegal, or hell, they haven't been invented yet. And even if we buy into the religious angle (and let's say for a moment that we do), I don't think God (be it Jesus or Allah or Shiva or Jehovah or Buddha or the Divine Goddess) would rather we procreate and procreate to do "His" will only to have those children live miserable lives or die of starvation. I dare you to read Angela's Ashes and disagree. Contraception in that case saves lives, instead of preventing them. Chew on that for a bit.
And don't get me started about the plethora of diseases that condoms can prevent. And this isn't just in extramarital sex (though I don't think that's wrong and people will always have sex). But, condoms allow married couples to have sex within one partner who is infected with an STD. Think of that! Someone who has been infected with a fatal or non-fatal chronic disease still has a chance at love. Isn't that beautiful? And it has nothing to do with procreation whatsoever. So there.
But, that prompts me to put myself on the example chopping block for a moment. I have Ovarian Cysts and endometriosis. It's extremely painful and could potentially cause infertility. The one "cure" that is known, other than a laperoscopy (which isn't a permanent fix), is ironically pregnancy. But, unfortunately, that's not an option for me now. I'm single, in my late twenties, just paying off student loans, and couldn't support a baby now in any way (though I feel emotionally ready). So, I have to band-aid my condition by taking hormones, birth control pills. They make the pain go away. They regulate my hormones that were so out of wack before. What would I do if birth control became illegal? What? Because I don't see a solution. Would you rather I sleep with a random guy to get pregnant and go on welfare to support my baby? Or maybe it's my singleness that offends you?
Or let's talk about my mother for a bit. My mom had 6 miscarriages until I was finally adopted. The poor woman wanted 6 children so badly, but just couldn't stay pregant. It wasn't until her first baby, my brother, a premie who lived only a day, that my parents decided to adopt. But, the clincher here isn't that my mom decided to "stop doing God's will," (excuse me for a moment while I throw up in my mouth a little), but that my doctor forbade her to get pregant again. Her body just couldn't take another miscarriage, another D&C (because guess what, folks, the dead baby doesn't dissolve in there; they have to scrape it out like an abortion, and it's painful), or even carry to full term.
So, what is the solution there, my zealoutous friends? If contraception is a sin and pregnancy will kill her, should she have just stopped having sex with my dad? Or perhaps she should have risked the next pregnancy, perhaps killing herself in the process and most likely the new baby too? Would she be sinning then as well? Because clearly the baby died at her hand. Clearly. Are we screwed either way? And if so, why bother getting so worked up if we are all going to the fiery inferno that is hell incarnate
Bah! That's what I say. If people like Kristi would stop getting so wrapped up in the dogma of their beliefs, they could see the bigger picture. And that picture is this:
1. Things are not always so simple as you think. Take a look around at the world and see all the special circumstances that make us diverse and life challenging.It is the choice inherant in life that makes it rich. Lack of choice negates the purpose in being.
2. There are a myriad of religions and beliefs. And that's ok. Most people are doing the best they can to live good lives. Respect others and stop worrying about who is going to hell. Take a look at your own soul and focus on your own path. "Let he who is without sin..." And I'll go so far as to say that hatefulness and prejudice is as much a sin to any God and religion as the other sins you judge so vehemently. Do you honestly think God will choose a hateful, judgemental person who happens to be Christian over a non-Christian person who has lived a good life, but used condoms and birth control?
I truly have nothing left to say. This subject only leaves me with fury and the more I type the more I realize that the people I intended this post for will never open their minds up long enough to heard another's point of view.
- Let’s talk: Comment (7) | Blog
- Email to a Friend
- Print this Page
From the Community…
-
Posted by Mon Nov 24, 2008 3:27pm PST
Report AbuseI totally agree! I went to Christian school as a kid and my parents responded similarly. It's possible to believe in God and still use your own brain, rely on your own conscience.
-
Posted by Sun Nov 30, 2008 3:33pm PST
Report AbuseThe greatest thing about contraception is that I can have as many hook-ups and casual sex relationships as I want! No worries because if it fails I can go and get an abortion (as long as I catch it soon enough), but even then you can usually find a doctor to do a late term procedure. Contraception has helped our society so much! Can't you tell? STD's have only gone down and so has unplanned pregnancy... or have they?
-
Posted by Sun Nov 30, 2008 7:59pm PST
Report Abusedid you even read this? my point wasn't that contraception is a slut pass. my point is that the logic of contraception equaling abortion is flawed and that it helps the rest of us out there who need contraception to survive in this world.
-
Posted by Sun Dec 21, 2008 6:15pm PST
Report Abusewow Elise....how trampy a statement is that. That's putting it nicely too...
-
Posted by Sat Feb 7, 2009 2:10pm PST
Report AbuseSo sad to see that people use contraception so they can screw as many people as they want.
As for the post I never heard of people saying contraception is a sin and is the same thing as abortion. The egg isn't even alive and therefore it cannot be considered abortion if you take the pills. I think we've procreated enough seeing that the world is vastly overpopulated.
-
Posted by Wed Mar 25, 2009 8:32pm PDT
Report AbuseYou go girl! I love your rant. I was raised Catholic too, but could never see the logic in why my mother felt excommunicated because she and my dad used condoms. If she had more children she would also die. I can just hear the biblethumpers now screaming God's will if she died. Well, God's will is that we have free will. My mom didn't want to die anymore than her family. If God didn't want us to have contraception he wouldn't have allowed for the concept or the creation of it! Needless to say, the whole experience has left me spiritual but indifferent to organized religions. This is America and I should be able to practice any belief system I want without being condemned and having some other belief system shoved down my throat against my free will. I do believe mutual respect for each others core beliefs is essential. What I can't understand is why a medical professional/pharmacist etc. in this day and age would refuse medical care/prescribed drugs etc. based on their own personal beliefs. That is just wrong and disrespects everyone. Wouldn't their refusal of medical care etc. violate their hypocratic oath? I would think that would be cause to put a mark against their license, eventually effecting their pocketbook. Why would someone practice a profession they couldn't practice properly due to religious convictions? Let me think of some other oxymorons: Amish electrician, honest lawyer, a nun prostitute.
-
Posted by Thu Mar 26, 2009 3:56pm PDT
Report AbuseUm, you have a very one-sided view of Christianity. Don't assume that you know every Christian religion because you have been exposed to two. You made the comment that all religions say the same thing, so that goes to show you. I will not tell you what Christian religion I am a part of, but I will tell you that I went to a Christian university, and in one of our religion classes the professor said that sex--within marriage--is a "wholesome recreational activity," wink, wink. Sex is great between a husband and wife, and should be enjoyed whenever and wherever they want to. But it isn't safe under any other circumstances, because of the chance of disease and unwanted pregnancy. There are always extenuating circumstances, such as the one you pointed out where married people would use a condom to prevent the transmission of disease. That is just courteous and wise. And I agree that people who would refuse to give someone like you birth control for medical reasons is being totally unreasonable. In your case it is medicine, not birth control. But not all Christian religions believe that. Not having babies by not having sex is not the same thing as making a baby and then killing it before it is born. One is birth control, the other is self control.
leave your comment
You must sign in to post a comment