Healthy Living

Saturday, November 28, 2009

Is football too dangerous--and should we change the rules?

I am reasonably confident that all moral members of modern society feel disquiet, at least, at the thought of ancient Roman gladiatorial games in which the very goal of the contest was...death.  But what about modern games in which one of the goals is disability?  This, to me, seems a difference of degree rather than kind—and worthy of our scrutiny.

A new study commissioned by the National Football League suggests that former pro football players are 19 times more likely than the rest of us to report memory problems in early adulthood and middle age; and 5 times as likely as the rest of us to develop Alzheimer's as a result of head injuries.  This would be bad enough if the head injuries were accidental, as they can be in other sports such as basketball and soccer.  But let's be honest: bone-crushing impact is an actual objective in football, and a fundamental part of the spectacle.  Fans expect to see heads getting pounded into the turf.  They are paying for it.  These are our modern gladiators.

Now, don't get me wrong—my academic pedigree notwithstanding, I am not an effete, stay-at-home, milquetoast kind of guy.  I have perfectly good “rugged guy” bona fides.  My ideas of a good time include racing a horse at high speed over obstacles in the woods; skiing a mogul-strewn double black diamond with comparable abandon; hiking 15 miles or biking 30.  I even have years of martial arts under my (not quite black, alas) belt. And I have the wear and tear to show for it: 15 broken bones (or at least, that's how many I had when I stopped counting); torn this, that, and the other thing; far too many stitches to keep track of; and at least two concussions.

But in my case, this is simply a by-product of “boys will be boys” mayhem.  No one was paying me to get hurt.  No one was watching expectantly, hoping to see me get hurt.  Some people even regretted it—myself included.

That's not the case for our gridiron gladiators.  Getting their brains bashed is the price of glory.

So I'm just asking: is a 5-fold increase in the risk of a condition as dreaded as Alzheimer's dementia a reasonable price to pay for what is, at the end of the day, a diversion?  Or, is it time to think about changing the rules of this dangerous game?

Habits That Save Your Brain
9 breakfasts that make you smarter
The workout routine that boosts your brain

7 brain games that challenge your mind


[photo credit: Getty Images]
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-4 of 4
  • another hockey fan's Avatar
    Posted by another hockey fan Sat Oct 3, 2009 9:10am PDT

    Well, I'm not a football fan so I say let's get rid of it and put more emphasis on a REAL dangerous sport, say like, HOCKEY ;-)

    Report Abuse
  • steve m's Avatar
    Posted by steve m Mon Oct 5, 2009 7:11am PDT

    i tghink they should all wear big bulky concussion preventing helmets

    Report Abuse
  • Giz's Avatar
    Posted by Giz Mon Oct 5, 2009 7:24am PDT

    I'm sorry, but football players know the risks of playing the game and get paid well for doing something they probably enjoy a whole heck of a lot more than most people enjoy their jobs. I'm less concerned about whether the sport is barbaric (boxing and hockey are just as bad and gymanstics is just as dangerous) and more concerned that our modern day gladiators are not held accountable (or accountable enough) for their actions outside of the stadium as long as they can play the game well. I don't mind people cheering on a football team, but I do mind when the children of this country are cheering on criminals and treating them as role models. I mind when adults who should know better justify behavior and give second chances to people who have had more opportunities, regardless of where they came from, than a lot of deserving people just because they can play a game.

    Report Abuse
  • Mag's Avatar
    Posted by Mag Mon Oct 5, 2009 10:41am PDT

    Spokane Valley football player dies of injury

    Updated 6d 15h ago | Comments 3 | Recommend 5 E-mail | Save | Print |

    ShareYahoo! Buzz Add to Mixx Facebook TwitterMore Fark Digg Reddit MySpace StumbleUpon Propeller LinkedInSubscribe myYahoo iGoogleMore Netvibes myAOL

    SPOKANE, Wash. (AP) — A high school football player from Spokane Valley has died after suffering a blow to the head in a Friday night game.

    Andrew Swank, 17, was in critical condition at Sacred Heart Medical Center after surgery to relieve pressure on his brain. He died Sunday night, the hospital announced.

    "Drew is now in heaven with God," said a statement issued by Valley Christian School, where Swank was a junior defensive back.

    Valley Christian was playing Washtucna High School at Washtucna, south of Ritzville, on Friday. Team officials said Swank took a hard hit during the game, walked to the sideline and collapsed. He was airlifted to Sacred Heart in Spokane.

    Swank is survived by his parents, four sisters and three brothers.

    "His family loves him so much and is so appreciative of everyone's thoughts and prayers," the news release said. "Andrew is donating his organs so others' lives can be saved."

    Washington has the toughest sports concussion law in the country — a measure passed by the Washington Legislature this spring. The Zackery Lystedt Law requires all athletes under the age of 18 who are suspected of having a concussion to get written consent from a licensed medical provider trained in evaluating concussions before returning to play.

    More than 3.5 million sports-related concussions occur each year in the United States, according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the Brain Injury Association of Washington.

    Copyright 2009 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-4 of 4

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Updates Chatter on Shine…

Health Byte

Who doesn't want to look hot at all those holiday parties? ExerciseTV shares how to get in skinny jeans-shape -- and quickly!