Healthy Living

Friday, December 4, 2009

Is your scale lying to you?

Ever step on the scale and have a hard time believing its accuracy?  Now, I'm not talking about delusion or denial...but more about the fact that you honestly can't pinpoint why the scale is reading a three pound increase in your weight.  It happens...it happens to all of us, and it can be very confusing, let alone frustrating. 

Believe it or not, there are reasons that the scale may be telling a 'white lie' to you...not intentionally of course, but many things factor into your weight, besides your caloric intake.  Here is a look at a few magical, or for that matter, deceptive reasons that the number on your scale can be misleading:

  1. Salt Overload and Water Retention:  Eating salty foods causes your body to 1) crave liquids and 2) retain water.  This water retention can add up to numerous pounds over the course of a couple of days.
  2. You haven't Pooped:  In all seriousness, if you are constipated or haven't pooped in a day or more, the weight adds up.  Although this may vary by person, you should aim to go at least 1 time a day, although it is ideal to go once per meal (3 times a day).  Eat lots of fiber  to keep things moving.
  3. PMS/Menstrual Cycle: For all of those women out there, PMS can cause your body to retain sodium and water (Kathy Egan, R.D.).  To avoid this, eat potassium-rich vegetables and fruit(E.g., asparagus, bananas, strawberries and melon). Potassium can help balance sodium levels in your bloodstream and allows your system to flush out excess fluid, reducing bloat.
  4. Delayed Reaction:  Weight gain is not attributed to the weight of your food, it is attributed to the calories you consume.  So, if a couple of days ago you had a bit extra, you might see a slight delay on the scale.  The calories have to be digested and absorbed to actually gain the weight.  Depending on the type of food you ate, it could take more or less time to finally show up on the scale.
  5. Different Time of Day:  If you normally weigh yourself in the morning and then randomly you weigh yourself at night, you'll probably see a different weight on the scale.  This is often attributed to the liquids and food you consumed throughout the course of the day that hasn't been expelled by the digestive tract (urine and/or bowel movement).
  6. Unbalanced Scale:  Every once in awhile, a scale can become 'unbalanced'.  Make sure it is on a level surface and registers 0 prior to weighing yourself. 

Have you had any other reasons you think your scale was 'fibbing'?  Do tell!

Relevant Topics:

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 41-44 of 44
  • Brett Blumenthal - Sheer Balance's Avatar
    Posted by Brett Blumenthal - Sheer Balance Sun Oct 12, 2008 9:45am PDT

    Minneapolis Cook...it sounds like you are doing things in a very healthy way. It is definitely more difficult to lose weight as you get older, and menopause can contribute to changes in your hormones, etc., which can also make things more difficult. The fact that you are sticking with it is fantastic!

    Report Abuse
  • Katja C's Avatar
    Posted by Katja C Sun Oct 12, 2008 12:52pm PDT

    Why do people even need scales? Seriously, the weights are so subjective, and all they do is give women body issues. I know women that have their entire day ruined because of a number that can actually fluctuate several times in one day. If you drink a glass of water, the number will go up. Once you pee, it goes back down.

    Even if you're dieting, you shouldn't have a scale--god forbid you're retaining a little water one day, you'll feel discouraged and perhaps get a case of the "what's the point?" and go on a binge.

    No one in my family has ever owned a scale. I mean, granted, none of us has ever had a weight problem, but even if we did, I don't think we would've bought one. I get weighed at the rare occasions that I go to the doctor--that's enough for me.

    Honestly, for everyone, dieters and nondieters, underweight or overweight, it's much better to judge your weight and health by how you look, how you feel, and simply how your clothes fit. I'd gained 40 pounds when I was pregnant 2 years ago, and never had a number chart my progress as the weight came off. I didn't care. I knew I was 163 pounds when I delivered, and was wearing a size 12. Over the first few months, I just charted my weight loss by my jean size. My stomach got flatter every day, and I gradually wore a size 10, an 8, a 6, a 4, and by the time my son was a year old, I was back in a size 2. I have no idea what I weigh now, and I have no idea what I weighed when I went through those sizes. I looked fine in all of them, no size had any bearing on my self-esteem--but I guarentee that I would've been depressed had I known what number was on the scale. Instead of weighing myself and trying to lower the number as fast as possible when I should have been caring for myself and concentrating on motherhood (motherhood, especially when you're breastfeeding, is so draining that dieting is the LAST thing you should do. You need all the energy you can get), I simply ate healthier meals, went on walks with my baby in a sling, and just happened to notice my jeans were getting smaller.

    It's so much easier that way. As the article said, stressing about a subjective number will totally stress you out and give you a false idea of your progress. You can be a slave to that thing.

    Just concentrate on being healthy, pay attention to your energy level and overall endurance (if you can't walk up a flight of stairs without gasping, you're in bad shape regardless of what you weigh), and chart your loss by your size, which is a better indicator and won't change from day to day. Even if you're PMSing and bloated, you should still be the same size you were yesterday.

    Toss the scale!

    Report Abuse
  • R's Avatar
    Posted by R Mon Oct 13, 2008 11:18pm PDT

    Three trains pulling into the station each day and if only one leaves, you are going to "pile" up! Get those toxins out of your body, more exercise and more fiber.

    Report Abuse
  • MrsKlingonPasadena's Avatar
    Posted by MrsKlingonPasadena Tue Oct 14, 2008 1:50pm PDT

    Ladies....and gents I guess. Do yourself a favor, NEVER weigh yourself everyday. It's too much pressure! And this obsession with 2 lbs here or there is crazy. No matter how much you weigh, if you obsess over 2 or 3 lbs you will never be happy. We as women are more than just bodies. Some like 'em little, some like 'um bigger. If you are truly happy with who you are, you radiate beauty at practically any size!

    Report Abuse
Comments 41-44 of 44

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Health Byte

Tune in to our fitness forecast! These are the top ten exercise trends for 2010.