Healthy Living

Wednesday, November 25, 2009

Should You Dump Your Doctor?

Robyn Lehr

Robyn Lehr

What to do when your doctor disappoints: professional advice on seven real-life situations

Problem: His office isn't well managed.

Real-Life Scenario #1: A pregnant woman regularly waits two hours to see her obstetrician. When she asks why, he says, "I'm just really busy."

Solution: Ridiculous, say most experts, if a two-hour wait is the rule rather than the exception. An occasional delay is excusable -- if, for instance, your ob-gyn had to perform an emergency C-section and the office kept you posted on her expected return. But any wait over 30 minutes is extended and grounds for, at the very least, walking out and rescheduling, says Karen Hickman, a corporate etiquette consultant and a former nurse in Fort Wayne, Indiana. That said, consistent promptness isn't particularly common. A 2005 study by the U.S. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, a federal group that focuses on improving health care for Americans, found that only 20 percent of adults surveyed were always taken to the exam room within 15 minutes of their appointments.

If you choose to wait, ask the receptionist if the doctor is in the office and running late or if he's out of the office altogether, suggests Pamela Gallin, an associate clinical professor of pediatric ophthalmology at Columbia University's Edward S. Harkness Eye Institute, in New York City, and the author of How to Survive Your Doctor's Care (LifeLine Press, www.amazon.com). If he's not there, you may want to reschedule. When he does appear, ask if there's anything you can do to minimize the delay next time and if the wait is normal or an exception. If the doctor admits to frequently running behind, you'll know to bring a good book to your next appointment. But "if being on time is important to you and a doctor says that delays are part of the experience of being his patient, it might be time to look for a new doctor," says Vicki Rackner, a board-certified surgeon in Mercer Island, Washington, and the owner of Medical Bridges, a medical-consulting company.

Real-Life Scenario #2: A pediatrician tells a mother that the office will call her within a week with important test results for her child. After a week, the mother calls the office. "Oh yeah, they're right here," says the receptionist. "Everything is fine." "Why didn't you call me?" the mom asks. "We don't have time to do that," she responds.

Solution: Test results should be delivered in a prompt, clear, respectful way, and anything less merits a call or a letter of complaint to your doctor. If the doctor doesn't apologize and you anticipate frequent visits, consider leaving her and looking for a doctor whose office is run more professionally. Some offices have stated policies that, for instance, they'll mail good news and call with bad. If it's a doctor you'd like to stick with (your child loves her; she has excellent credentials), bring a self-addressed, stamped envelope to your appointments and request that your results be mailed directly to you. Or just accept that you'll have to be vigilant about following up.

Learn How to Find a Primary Care Doctor at Real Simple.

Robyn Lehr

Robyn Lehr

Problem: His record is blemished.

Real-Life Scenario: A woman learns that her surgeon has been disciplined by the state medical board. Having already had two minor procedures with the doctor, she panics and decides to leave his practice.

Solution: Disciplinary actions aren't always cause for alarm. A doctor can be disciplined for small offenses, such as refusing to provide a patient with medical records in a timely manner, and large ones, like negligence during surgery. You can look up a doctor's history of disciplinary actions at Castle Connelly's website, www.castleconnelly.com. This research and information company provides links to all 50 state medical boards. To find out the specifics about his record, you may need to call or send a letter to the board, says Candis Cohen, spokesperson for the Medical Board of California, in Sacramento.

If you find that disciplinary action has been taken, don't be shy about asking the doctor about it. If the record sounds extreme (he was self-prescribing medications, or he made a sexual advance toward a patient) or it makes you uncomfortable (as it did the patient above) and undermines your confidence in the doctor, then it's time to leave.

From Real Simple: 10 Medical Tests Every Woman Should Have

Robyn Lehr

Robyn Lehr

Problem: He has poor diagnostic skills.

Real-Life Scenario: A 50-year-old woman with high blood pressure visits her doctor complaining of chest pains and shortness of breath. Her doctor diagnoses anxiety and stress and sends her to a psychopharmacologist. Feeling skeptical, she sees a cardiologist, who finds that she has an arrhythmia and immediately prescribes beta-blockers.

Solution: "Cases of misdiagnosis are more common than you think," says J. Edward Hill. This is not necessarily grounds for dumping a doctor -- unless you've heard that the same thing has happened to other patients or the doctor has missed something obvious. If the misdiagnosis wasn't serious, take note of how your doctor reacts after the accurate diagnosis is made, whether it comes after more tests or is another doctor's opinion. "When I make a mistake, I tell the patient and the family, and they respect that," says author Mehmet Oz, who is also the vice chairman of surgery at New York–Presbyterian Hospital/Columbia University Medical Center, in New York City. But if your doctor hems and haws and makes excuses, he may not be someone you want tending to your health.

More from Real Simple:
Doctors with Poor Boundaries, Narrow-Minded Views
Insider Tips from Medical Specialists
Protect Your Heart's Health

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 105
  • dorisg's Avatar
    Posted by dorisg Sat Feb 7, 2009 2:32pm PST

    I have been seeing a pain specialist for over 4 years now. My main diagnosis was lower back pain with spondylosis and deterioriated disc disease. As time went on I had several falls, I finally fell and broke my ankle severely. It later caused lymphedema. During most of this time I tried to get my disability started. My pain doctor believes that I am able to work with these conditions,along with arthritis in most of my joints! Should I ditch him?

    Report Abuse
  • Sesame seed's Avatar
    Posted by Sesame seed Sat Feb 7, 2009 8:31pm PST

    Physicians are increadibly overworked. I dont know how they do it in a day. The number of patients they see in 24 hours and the number of calls they take would boggle your mind. Truthfully, the world is full of nut cases and hypochondriacs. They have to sort out the hypochondriacs, alcoholics and drug addicts from those who have legitimate health problems which arent draining the system. How many times can they tell you to lose weight, quit smoking, take your meds. I work in a hospital and we literally have patients who visit the emergency room 20-40 times a year. The number of bariatric patients we see in a year has more than tripled than when I started 15 yrs ago. We do gastric bypass and they balloon out again in 5 yrs. Its never ending. Doctors have a never ending line of work. If there are any physicians out there, thanks for doing your job and keep up the good work!!!!

    Report Abuse
  • Dusty's Avatar
    Posted by Dusty Sat Feb 7, 2009 11:28pm PST

    What if you call to set up an apointment for a Dr.visit,tell them your in a wheel chair and can't get out of it or stand,Take an access bus costing $4;50 one way,they tell you to plane on two hours,You set your bus t to pick you up at the time said and after an hour and a half you still haven't seen the Dr. And your bus comes to pick you up and can't wait.So you leave only to have to make another appt. aweek later and it happens again. An hour an a half later,still no Dr. Now you've spent $18:00 and your on dissability with a small income to live on.WHAT WOULD YOU DO?

    Report Abuse
  • Dusty's Avatar
    Posted by Dusty Sat Feb 7, 2009 11:56pm PST

    I'm a nurse/caregiver,and have been for some35 yrs or so and It amazes me how rudd people can be to someone in a wheel chair.Daily tasks are a challenge enough,Trying to cross a street with a light and not having the time to get all the way across,and drivers just are in such a hurry.Trying to go in a store to shop ,,,The store maybe ADA complient,but they put all this crap in the isles.Rester rants,okay,,,try to get a table out of every ones way,without being near the kitchen.Then when you do the table isn't high enough you don't fit under,you have to straddle the corner,,,NICE!!! Then you look up and everyone is looking at you.We even call ahead and to make sure things will be alright.Try going to get an xray,noing you can't stand up or get out of your chair,they look at you like your from outer space.Does anyone have anythoughts on this?????

    Report Abuse
  • Melody g's Avatar
    Posted by Melody g Sun Feb 8, 2009 11:05am PST

    In these cases, I would calmly and respectfully explain my situation and ask for a resolution. Doctors need to be sensitive to the ever-changing needs of their patients and make time to see those who have made appointments in advance. If they either don't make good on their word to improve or refuse, I'd write a letter of complaint. If that still didn't fix things, I'd find another doctor.

    I'd gone to a specific doctor twice, only to find out that she wasn't available. Staff knew days beforehand that this doctor would not be in to take patients. Not only did they not bother to call me (which I would have appreciated them giving me the option to reschedule or see the practitioner), they told me that I'd have to pay a cancellation fee for THEIR lack of duty. I never saw the doctor in person; not even once. I finally brushed my hands clean of their practice and found a better doctor whom I have seen EVERY time I've been there, and has been attentive to my needs. I couldn't be happier! I encourage that if you do not feel comfortable in the least, change doctors- there are many good ones out there. It's just a matter of preference and taking the time to find the right one. You may even do well scheduling consulations with doctors before you commit to becoming one of their patients. This will give you a chance to get to know their personality and their reason for being in their specific field. Ask them why they chose it; My rule is that if they tell me anything less than "because they love their job and making people feel better" or close to that explanation, I keep searching...

    Report Abuse
  • Sapphire's Avatar
    Posted by Sapphire Sun Feb 8, 2009 1:31pm PST

    Well i have seen on first hand, how hard Dr's work I work with my Dr. together on my health. The people who come in to get narcotics is unbelievable!!!! they use the system i hear them doing deals in the waiting room.... my Dr does his clinic and them he does his rounds at two to three hospitials he gets an avarage of 3-4 hours of sleep. I tell him he needs to slow down he can't keep going like that.

    But as far as if ditching a Dr........ If he or she doesnt take the time to LISTEN is the most important that is why i wait a little longer cuz i know he is compassionate and listens first... then EXPLAINS.... and if you just dont feel right there is nothing wrong with changing DR'S. Come on they need to know everything bout you and work with you. i have had the kind that talk and dont give you a chance to ask questions or dont give u a chance to bring up problems you may have and they may be important or he may not take you serious!

    so go with your gut and how your relationship feels.....

    Report Abuse
  • pixie's Avatar
    Posted by pixie Mon Feb 9, 2009 9:28am PST

    I didn't have to dump my doctor he left his practice,were were and are on good terms,but I have not replaced him and do not intend to . I have dumped western medicine,in favor of natural holistic healing and treatments. I feel better now then I have my entire 35 years and see no reason to go back the pill pushers of western medicine.

    Report Abuse
  • Andygirl's Avatar
    Posted by Andygirl Mon Feb 9, 2009 12:24pm PST

    I've dumped doctors. I think it's all about chemsitry sometimes. I'll dump doctors until I find the right fit for me.

    I dumped doc #1 because he was a pushover. I think a doctor should be demonstrative, but I could probably waltz in there today, announce that I'm hypertensive and ask for a prescription, and he would comply. Seriously.

    I dumped doc #2 because she didn't listen to my serious complaints about my medication. She just didn't listen at all. How can I expect to have a good diagnosis if she doesn't even hear me?

    I dumped doc #3 because he started judging my personal life. Not my lifestyle, mind you, because I'm pretty freaking healthy. But, he judged me for being single, for not dating, for having no family plans (he was my gyno). But, the thing is, it's none of his business (one), but it also wasn't really a choice. I had finally gotten out of a destructive relationship and really, really wanted a baby, but was not about to do that on my own. And his rubbing it in wasn't making me feel any better!

    Report Abuse
  • Sandra's Avatar
    Posted by Sandra Mon Feb 9, 2009 4:56pm PST

    I moved almost a year ago and seen this doctor twice and decided to dump her. For one she talked to me like I was stupid and acted like an airhead. She wears way too much makeup and dresses unprofessional. I tried a few times to make appointments for myself and husband and she was always booked for weeks ahead. Sometimes there are small emergencies where you can't wait like UTIs and severe sore throats. I have never had a booking problem if I were a regular patient at a doctors office before.

    Report Abuse
  • bruce's Avatar
    Posted by bruce Tue Feb 10, 2009 3:25am PST

    I have been going to a urologist for 15 years with no problems. The last exam @ his office was done by his nurse. The nurse only performed half of the exam and the doctor charged me full price. The fact that he didn't examine me must mean he no longer wants me as a patient.I have a lump in my private area but it was not detected in this exam. This says volumes about how I was treated

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 105

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Health Byte

Who doesn't want to look hot at all those holiday parties? ExerciseTV shares how to get in skinny jeans-shape -- and quickly!