Healthy Living

Tuesday, February 9, 2010

The new birth control pills: New and improved, or just new?

"I need a refill for my birth control pill, but I'm wondering if I should switch to one of the newer pills that I've seen advertised." I hear this daily, and my advice on pill switching is simple: if it's not broken, don't fix it. If you've found a pill that works with your body, and you've got predictable short periods and no side effects, there's no need to trade in your pill for a newer, shinier model. All pills are about the same in effectiveness and risks, and there's no reason for most women to switch.

On the other hand, if you're unhappy with your current pill, there are multiple new pills now available that are markedly different from the old ones. If you're thinking of starting the pill for the first time, or restarting after a break, they offer some new choices. Traditionally, pills come in what we call 21/7 formulations: 21 days of hormones, followed by 7 days of placebos. These lead to predictable bleeding (a "withdrawal bleed," as in withdrawal from hormones) once a month. The new pills come in three different formulations:


  • 24/4 pills. Two brands: YAZ and LoEstrin-24. These pills have a shorter placebo week, and many women have shorter periods of bleeding (but not everyone). They also give you a cushion of safety if you begin a pack late (not that you ever need it, right?)--your risk of pregnancy is lower if you don't miss hormones for more than seven days. Bleeding: once a month.
  • 84/7* pills. Two brands: Seasonale and Seasonique. These pills have almost 3 consecutive months of hormones before the placebo week (Seasonale) or a week of a tiny daily bit of hormones (Seasonique). Breakthrough bleeding or spotting is normal and common at first, as your body becomes accustomed to the new routine. Bleeding (after adjustment): 4 times a year.
  • "365" pills. One brand: Lybrel. With Lybrel, you take hormone pills every day--no placebo pills at all. It can take up to a year for your periods to disappear, and your bleeding may be irregular until then. Bleeding (after adjustment, for most women): never.

These pills may be especially good for women with heinous hormone-withdrawal symptoms, like killer migraines--fewer placebo days, fewer symptoms. Have any of you tried any of these newer pills? What did you think?


Related Links from Daily Bedpost and Glamour:

[photo credit: Getty Images]
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 40
  • Carrie's Avatar
    Posted by Carrie Wed Jun 25, 2008 4:21pm PDT

    You forgot to mention the ring! I always had trouble remembering to take the pill, but with the ring I just have to change it once a month! The doctors in the US recommend 3 weeks on/1 week off, but you can really leave it in up to 5 weeks and be covered. So I wear it for 4 weeks and swap it out with no time without the ring. You really don't feel it once it's inserted properly, and we never notice it during sex. One brand: Nuvaring. Bleeding: Never!!

    Report Abuse
  • Caitie's Avatar
    Posted by Caitie Wed Jun 25, 2008 7:52pm PDT

    I was trying to find the negatives to all the new pill. I was thinking about going o it for all my irregular periods, cramps, etc. Yet, my dad would have a heart attack if he found out I want to go on the pill. My grandmother died of cervical cancer (back in the 70's) and he blames the pill. He feels there is no reason to go on the pill. I am thinking it might help me.

    Report Abuse
  • Joy's Avatar
    Posted by Joy Thu Jun 26, 2008 7:04am PDT

    I'm currently on Seasonale. One of the best decisions I've ever made. I can't stand to get a menstrual cycle every month, yet, I don't want to not get them. So, getting one every 3 months works just fine for me.

    Report Abuse
  • Joy's Avatar
    Posted by Joy Thu Jun 26, 2008 7:06am PDT

    I'm currently on Seasonale. One of the best decisions I've ever made. I can't stand to get a menstrual cycle every month, yet, I don't want to not get them. So, getting one every 3 months works just fine for me.

    Report Abuse
  • Sandy's Avatar
    Posted by Sandy Thu Jun 26, 2008 8:08am PDT

    Another happy Seasonale user. Incredibly light periods only four times a year... HECK YEAH! Plus my PMDD has improved dramatically!

    Report Abuse
  • Sara's Avatar
    Posted by Sara Thu Jun 26, 2008 11:24am PDT

    My doctor has prescribed the "traditional" 21/7 pill for me, except in larger amounts (4 packs instead of 3) and I throw away the placebo week. This all came about after we both did research and determined that Lybrel was the same thing as the regular/generic pill, except far more expensive. Generic pill....$40 for 3 months' supply. No period at all...priceless!

    Report Abuse
  • Gila's Avatar
    Posted by Gila Thu Jun 26, 2008 11:49am PDT

    I'm on ortho evra - the birth control patch. My Dr. says that even though it's typically used as a 21/7 birth control (change patch once a week, then the fourth week is off) it can be used as an 84/7 birth control, and there's less break through bleeding because it's a more consistant level of hormones throughout the day and week. Also, it's easier to change the patch once a week at approximately the same time than it is to take a pill at the same time every day.

    I like not worrying about taking pills, and the breakthrough bleeding is less than when I was on the pill.

    Report Abuse
  • Sandy's Avatar
    Posted by Sandy Thu Jun 26, 2008 12:13pm PDT

    I am on Loestrin-24 and love it. After I had my baby, the 21/7 routine wasn't working. I was actually having what the doctor called "freak periods" where I was bleeding even on the hormone pills. So, I was having like, three periods a month. And then there were the cramps, and bloating, and blah blah blah. I have not only had no problem switching to the adjustment of the new pills, I have also lost some weight on them.

    Report Abuse
  • Kristina's Avatar
    Posted by Kristina Thu Jun 26, 2008 2:22pm PDT

    I took Seasonique for about a year and it felt like I never stopped having a period. The only reason I kept it up was because my doctor kept telling me that it would take time to adjust, but I never did. After my boyfriend deployed, I stopped taking them, and am currently looking for a replacement. I also took YAZ and had a period every 2 weeks. I hope there's something out there for me....

    Report Abuse
  • Jessica's Avatar
    Posted by Jessica Thu Jun 26, 2008 4:07pm PDT

    Hate to say it, but taking Seasonale resulted in multiple ovarian cysts for me. I've tried different brands, and found that Yasmin was perfect for me. Or so I thought.

    It used to control my acne. That is no longer.

    It used to control my PMS, that especially is no longer.

    And it used to control my flow in the first place, by making it light - hardly lasting for 4 days.

    And that, most importantly, is NO LONGER.

    I have been taking it for 3 years and for some reason it's just giving out on me. I am skeptical about the new 365 pill. Sometimes having a period can be very reassuring.

    I know that Yaz gives issues to many different women, ortho-cyclen - tried it.

    I'm going to try a new one, that won't give me ovarian cysts, and one that will stick with me through the years to come.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 40

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Health Byte

Get healthy foods for your family that won’t take a bite out of your budget.  Healthy living costs less at Walmart.