Healthy Living

Monday, December 7, 2009

User Post: Does Milk Really Do a Body Good?

Growing up, I drank my milk, 2-3 glasses every night, like a good little girl. This was during the 70s, way before "lactose-intolerant-this," "nondairy that," let alone "hormone-free milk" and Whole Foods. I also grew...big. I was healthy, but developed rather quickly and was "cursed" with the curse before the age of 12. Since then, my periods have always been bad -- heavy, irregular, and crampy. I've been on and off the pill, on a first-name-basis with Advil, and tried a variety of supplements, exercise, and yoga, which have met with mild improvement. Laparoscopy has been suggested as an option, but surgery is something I've filed away in a "if I'm really desperate" drawer, with lackluster resignation.

Two months before my 30-never-you-mind birthday, and after a particularly decadent weekend, I decided to detox, which included an experiment with veganism. It was surprisingly easy for me, living in a major metropolitan area (New York), laden with farmers' markets during the summer and 24-hour produce stands year-round. I made a made a conscious effort to get my nutrients from fruits, vegetables, whole grains, legumes, soy, and seitan.  Of course, proximity to great vegan restaurants was a bonus.

After the first month, I gradually started adding back fish, then meat. I continued, however, to abstain from dairy. So far, my diet had resulted in increased energy and decreased weight, and an unexpected benefit. My period, which operated on its own calendar, anywhere from 32-36 days, arrived promptly on day 28, with little fanfare, sparing me the assorted pain and other fun.

This first instance, it was difficult to pinpoint the cause, or rather alleviation, of my suffering, as I had cut back on a variety of possible triggers other than dairy -- processed food, red meat, alcohol, and caffeine. But by the second month and cycle, while most foods had been re-introduced to my diet with the exception of dairy, my period was also lighter and I had fewer cramps. Thus, I began to notice a pattern.

I'm sure an overall decrease in the amount of chemical-laden, bio-engineered foods in general played a role, but there is research suggesting a link between dairy and increased cramping. Prostaglandins, hormone-like chemicals that produce muscle contractions and cramping, are created from arachidonic acid, a fatty acid found in dairy products such as milk, cheese, and ice cream. Excess dairy can also promote high levels of estrogen, which are implicated in fibroids, a secondary cause of painful periods.

If reducing or eliminating dairy, women must be especially mindful to obtain the daily requirements of calcium, which -- in addition to being essential for bone growth and retention -- can also minimize symptoms of PMS and menstruation. Calcium can be obtained from sources such as kale, spinach, soy, nuts and beans. Calcium and vitamin D, whatever the source, have a host of benefits, bone mass just being one of them. Many people can tolerate and digest dairy...as for myself, the jury is still out. Two months is not long enough to recognize the effects of food elimination...I'm gonna try at least 6 without dairy…barring a few moments here and there of manchego weakness.


[photo credit: Getty Images]
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 31
  • Katie's Avatar
    Posted by Katie Wed Aug 5, 2009 3:51pm PDT

    Arachidonic acid is a fatty acid, not a protein.

    Report Abuse
  • avery's Avatar
    Posted by avery Wed Aug 5, 2009 4:22pm PDT

    I hate it when articles / blogs promise something they don't deliver. The title is "Does milk really do a body good?" Yet the post does not come close to answering the question. Generally, a piece of work should have an introduction, a body and a conclusion. This post just rambles on with seemingly no point. I am so NOT interested in anecdotes and vague statements like "Excess dairy can also promote high levels of estrogen." What does 'excess' mean in this case? More than 1 glass? More than 2 glasses per day? Give me a break.

    Report Abuse
  • alisha G's Avatar
    Posted by alisha G Wed Aug 5, 2009 6:02pm PDT

    I also drank 3 or more glasses a day of milk growing up. Now I am lactose intolerant. I find that eliminating dairy helped my period stay on track on have less pain. When I do occasionally fall of the wagon and must have a giant bowl of ice cream, or a piece of cheesecake, it does upset my stomach and then I break in acne on my face.

    Report Abuse
  • JoKTM's Avatar
    Posted by JoKTM Wed Aug 5, 2009 6:16pm PDT

    LOL this is a blog not a book.

    Milk is good for the body but only the calcium. Extra hormones in meats can cause some women to produce more tetosterone and grow facial hair.

    Report Abuse
  • Robyn's Avatar
    Posted by Robyn Wed Aug 5, 2009 7:42pm PDT

    "Prostaglandins, hormone-like chemicals that produce muscle contractions and cramping, are created from arachidonic acid, a fatty acid found in dairy " this explains alot it took two years but we pinpointed my 'sledge hammer to abdomen' cramping to milk products. i love milk and often just look at a glass and say " I HATE YOU" because i cant have it. but i have yet to be seriously ill for almost 3 years now that i have cut it out of my diet.

    Report Abuse
  • Eddieslilangel's Avatar
    Posted by Eddieslilangel Wed Aug 5, 2009 9:01pm PDT

    im tired of people saying milk is bad for you. its not ALL that bad for you. you just have to limit the amount you drink.

    Report Abuse
  • frosted's Avatar
    Posted by frosted Wed Aug 5, 2009 9:26pm PDT

    I found this really interesting! Growing up I drank milk like it was water, loving it almost more than other drinks. I also suffered from some of the the same problems . My milk though was skim, from a local farm and hormone free. My mom who grew up on the same diet had the same problem as I. My doctor figured it was just genetic but it's nice to learn that there are other factors too that could help in the future

    Report Abuse
  • Emily H's Avatar
    Posted by Emily H Thu Aug 6, 2009 12:15am PDT

    This is really good and I also experienced the same thing with my cycle when I cut out almost all dairy with the exception of half and half. I was on a strict vegetarian (not vegan, but vegetarian) diet and only drank organic coffee with an occasional beer now and then. I had no cramps and I lost weight and looked good and healthy. So I agree with this blog very much. Good job! And don't listen to the naysayers above me! ;)

    Report Abuse
  • Jacquelyn's Avatar
    Posted by Jacquelyn Thu Aug 6, 2009 6:09am PDT

    Yeah, I used to drink a lot of milk when I was a kid. I ended up geting my first period when I was only 11, not fun. And I've always had problems with it being irregular. If I'm not on the pill I have no idea when it will come. This isn't a genetic thing as my mum and grandmother never had this problem. Maybe it was milk.

    Report Abuse
  • Katie B's Avatar
    Posted by Katie B Thu Aug 6, 2009 6:12am PDT

    Hm... I think with the consumption of any foods though now adays there are going to pros and cons... I have been drinking milk nearly every day of my life for the past 28 years and have never experienced cramping (unless I used a tampon, which I don't do because I don't like the cramping) and yes, I am well endowed in the chest area, but that is a genetic trait (I got them from my great grandmother) and I didn't develop until I was 12ish, though I did know my 3rd grade peers that did... though I will give you the irregular cycles.. but I'm not sure if that has to do with the hormones or the genetics behind them.

    So either there are exceptions to the rule or it just happens based on a person to person bases.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 31

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Health Byte

Tune in to our fitness forecast! These are the top ten exercise trends for 2010.