Healthy Living

Sunday, November 22, 2009

User Post: What is my ideal weight? 5 tips for finding your happy weight

If you're trying to lose weight, you probably have a goal, your ideal weight, in mind. A good question to ask yourself is, "Where did I get this number?"

Is it what you weighed in high school? Is it what health experts suggest you should weigh, based on your age, body frame and body type?

While weight loss is an admirable goal for a woman who is truly overweight, many women who want to lose weight don't need to.  In study after study, researchers have found that the majority of normal weight women think they need to lose 10 or 15 pounds:  what I call vanity pounds. 

Why is this a problem?

If our happy weight is based on unrealistic expectations, it will cause us much pain and suffering. We'll exhaust ourselves, trying to achieve the impossible. We'll live in fear:  when we've lost weight, we're fearful of gaining it back; when we've gained a few pounds, we're fearful that the scale will keep rising. We may delve into all sorts of whacked out behaviors:  crash dieting, food obsession, fasting, and overexercising in our desire to reach our goal.

Unrealistic expectations can create an unhealthy focus on our appearance. You can only be 10 pounds underweight if you're working very, very hard:  by exercising for hours a day and being very stringent about what you eat. These behaviors can easily morph into an eating disorder.

The flip side, accepting a realistic happy weight, may mean giving up our wishful thinking of being a size 2. This can be painful; I know. But the rewards of letting go of our impossible expectations are many: vitality, feeling satisfied by the variety and amount of food we eat, energy, stable moods, confidence and a healthy appreciation for our appearance instead of obsession. It's also a sure way to temper the jealousy you may feel about other pretty women.

How can you find a weight that is realistic for your body? Here are 5 tips:

1. Look at the unique factors of your body. Self magazine has a calculator to determine your happy weight which takes into account your age, exercise habits, and if you've had children. You can also factor in your eating and self-care habits:  Do you have ways of comforting yourself without turning to food? If not, accept that this may mean weighing a bit more than you'd like until you have stronger nurturing skills. As you learn how to care for yourself, your weight may go down. But accept where you are right now. Then, as Maya Angelou says, as you know better, you do better. And then you can adjust your goal. Having realistic expectations is about looking at what is - not what you'd like to be - and using that information to shape and mold a positive, yet honest expectation for change.
2. Aim for a healthy body fat percentage. One of the best ways to compute a realistic happy weight is by basing it on a healthy body fat percentage. Start by figuring out your current body fat percentage. Then, you can use this number to figure out how much of your weight is comprised of core, lean mass:  your organs, muscles, water, and tissues, and how much of your weight is fat. It can also tell you if your body fat percentage is in a healthy range. So, if you want 22% body fat, which is considered a healthy body fat percentage for a woman, you can see whether you need to lose a few pounds, or if your body is healthy just as it is. With hard data, and real numbers, you can see if your expectations are realistic.
3. Look at media images of women with a critical eye. Look at window mannequins in most women's clothing stores, and you'll see a woman whose body fat would make her underweight. Likewise, the "ideal body" that is touted in the movie industry, fashion industry and media is also underweight. This skews our perception, where, as Stanley Tucci's character in The Devil Wears Prada famously quippped, a size 2 is the new 6; a size 6, the new size 14. Separate yourself from these images by recognizing them for what they are: unrealistic. This doesn't mean turning into the body image police. When I see celebrities who look clearly underweight, I bypass judgment. But I do feel compassion for them -- think of the enormous pressure they must feel to always look their best. I know I wouldn't want to live with that kind of scrutiny on my appearance.
4. Give yourself enough time to lose weight. If you are wanting to lose weight, one of the best ways you can support yourself is by giving yourself time to accomplish your goal. You didn't gain weight overnight; you won't lose it overnight, either. If you're holding onto an unrealistic expectation about how quickly you can lose weight, you'll either be discouraged and frustrated because it's taking longer than you think it "should," or you'll delve into drastic measures to lose the weight faster, such as starving yourself, purging, or overexercising. This is being kind to yourself, allowing time for changes to manifest. It's nature's way - growth and change take time.
5. Recognize that your happy weight will change over time. Health is dynamic, not static. Our bodies are always changing, and life is always in flux. The media focus on Jessica Simpson was ridiculous because it denied this basic truth. It is normal for our weight to go up and down, particularly as women. One year you have a baby; another year, you have major surgery and have limited exercise capabilities; another year, you're under tremendous stress and gain weight. All of these things can effect what a realistic weight is for your body at this moment in time. Accepting that your ideal weight may be higher than you'd like - for now - doesn't mean that this will always be the case. Accept the ebb and flow; the highs and the lows, and learn to love a weight range for your body, not just one ideal weight.  

We are so much more than a number, but as women in an appearance-conscious society, it is very, very eased to get hooked by the promise of an ideal body. It's easy to believe that it will solve all our pain - our confidence, our needs, our desire for intimacy, acceptance, and belonging.

These needs are valid and important. But the problem is when we use our bodies to feel these needs, instead of our innate worthiness, our beingness. It creates too much pressure, too much focus on one area of our lives. It keeps us from enjoying the present moment, trapped in a place where we are never satisfied; always striving to improve. It keeps us from appreciating what our bodies can do, how we live in them and enjoy their many gifts.

It's a gift to live in a female body. Our beauty should be cherished and appreciated; our sexuality, enjoyed; our strength, celebrated. Yes. While we are not our bodies, we do live in them --- and when we love and care for them, we send a message of love and care for our entire selves.  

So, yes, love and care for your body as a loving caretaker, even as a mother lovingly cares for her children. Exercise. Move, sweat, dance, run play. Rest when you're tired. Eat when you're hungry. Feed it whole foods that nourish your particular body (because no one diet is right for everyone.) Breathe. Dream. Release your hurts.

But do so with detachment.  Do it out of love, not out of hatred, fear, jealousy or disgust --- I am such a fat cow! ... I am going to run 5 miles because I ate that pizza last night.... I am so sick of being fat ... I hate that skinny b***ch. Love your body with acceptance, embracing every stage and weight of your body, recognizing that your real worth has nothing to do with a number on a scale.

Other articles you may like:

Want more of First Ourselves? Want to transform your relationship with food, your body, and your children through self-care? Sign up for our free newsletters on loving your body, overcoming sugar addiction, and self-care. Or download our free books on body image and sugar addiction.

[photo credit: Getty Images]

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 265
  • sita's Avatar
    Posted by sita Tue Feb 24, 2009 7:49am PST

    nice! really liked the post, I hope those (including myself) that read it can get something out of it to help them lead/start/change to a healthier lifestyle.

    Report Abuse
  • B. J.'s Avatar
    Posted by B. J. Tue Feb 24, 2009 1:55pm PST

    Excellent!

    Report Abuse
  • Parvathy's Avatar
    Posted by Parvathy Tue Feb 24, 2009 11:20pm PST

    Iam Forty years old women. My weight is 75 kgs at present I am suffering from knee joint pain. my height is 4.8 feet. please let me know the correct weight for my height and age. and give me a nice tip to reduce my weight.

    Report Abuse
  • 29_and holding's Avatar
    Posted by 29_and holding Wed Feb 25, 2009 6:55am PST

    A woman that is 5 ft tall should weigh 100 lbs. For ever inch above 5 ft you should add 5 lbs.

    5'1" ____________ 105

    5'2"_____________ 110

    I am 5'5" so I should weigh 125. I am quite a bit over this. I have lost 30 lbs since Christmas. I need to lose about 45 more.

    I learned this weight/height measurement in my nutrition class in nursing school. this is just a base line. Remember that it is not an exact number.

    Also I have read that for every pound that you are over weight it add 4 pounds of pressure to you knees. So that is another great reason to lose weight.

    Report Abuse
  • __A_YAHOO_USER__'s Avatar
    Posted by __A_YAHOO_USER__ Wed Feb 25, 2009 8:28am PST

    29_and holding

    That dosn't work. I'm 5'4" so according to your method i should weigh 120, but i stop mensturating at 123.

    The Healthy Weight Calculator mentioned above says my Happy weight is 125, but the Doctor doesn't want me below 130.

    Everyone is different.

    Report Abuse
  • Sarah J's Avatar
    Posted by Sarah J Wed Feb 25, 2009 8:45am PST

    I just tried the "Happy weight" calculator...my body doesn't like 130. It's a HUGE struggle to get there if I do and it takes all of a month before I am back up 15-20 lbs if I am not on the verge of starving myself. What a hooey....not to mention I am a 36 DD....where is that weight accounted for in a 130 lbs.

    Report Abuse
  • Donna's Avatar
    Posted by Donna Wed Feb 25, 2009 9:13am PST

    29_and holding, a 5 foot woman who weighs 105 pounds would have a BMI of 20.5, which, is underweight. You might want to read new information about weight. You probably aren't as overweight as you think that you are. Also, I have read that estrogen is stored in the fat, so that older women want to have a nice fat store, so that menopause goes a little easier.

    Report Abuse
  • Fire Wife's Avatar
    Posted by Fire Wife Wed Feb 25, 2009 9:50am PST

    I am 5'2" and according to the calculator my happy weight should be 121lbs. I currently weigh about 125 so I am close. Based on '29 and holding' I should weigh 110lbs which would be about a size 2. I used to weigh that and looked VERY unhealthy. However, I feel FAT at my current weight...

    Report Abuse
  • Zeplin522's Avatar
    Posted by Zeplin522 Wed Feb 25, 2009 12:16pm PST

    I'm 56, 5'8" and weigh 120 and have all of my adult life. Was a

    very skinny teenager. I eat healthy always have and have stayed

    the same weight as have my brother and sister. "They" say I

    should weigh 140-145, why? I'm healthy aways have been, and as

    for menopause, for me no syptoms other than no period anymore

    Everyone is different, so I just do what works for me and so

    far so good.

    Report Abuse
  • Tracy G's Avatar
    Posted by Tracy G Wed Feb 25, 2009 12:45pm PST

    The problem with body mass index is that they dont take into account the persons body shape and frame. I have a larger frame naturally. I was just born with hips which means that I need more "stuff" to cover it so I would naturally weigh more than a person who was considered average. Your best bet is to see your Dr. to find out what an ideal weight for you would be. According the happy weight calculator I should weigh between 5-10 lbs less than what my ideal weight should be. Ask a professional who can see you in person and see what your body shape really is then find out what a good weight for you would be.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 265

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Health Byte

Are your feet aching? Do you suffer from plantar fasciitis or varicose veins? Relief could be as simple as stretching your toes.