Healthy Living

Tuesday, February 9, 2010

What's the dumbest diet you've ever been on?

When I was in high school and a skinny little thing, I had a boyfriend who liked that about me. This was only one small part of the much bigger, eye-rolling drama that developed in that relationship. But in the beginning, I was wee and he complimented my looks and I liked it. It's not pretty, but it's how it was.

Part of the reason I was a skinny little thing back then is because I was a late bloomer. Years later, I had a college roommate who said she got her boobs, period and driver's license all in one week, and that made me laugh because that is pretty much how my own mid-high school experience played out. I just happened to add boyfriend to that list then, too.

My body was changing rapidly and that was a good thing. But as I was growing and developing (as I should have), my boyfriend began making comments about my boobs and hips and weight. He did it in a way that seemed casual but still held an assertive message. Bigger -- to him, at least -- not better. Well, unless it was him getting bigger by lifting weights or eventually putting on the Freshman 15 on the Great Frat Boy Diet of Bad Beer and Taco Bell.  Even though I was a smart and opinionated and level-headed girl back then, I was also sixteen and in love and very aware of how I sized up among my friends.

So I did what many of us did during slightly desperate and silly and misguided moments like those: I went on my own version of the grapefruit diet.

I thought it would be a quick and easy way to drop a few pounds -- a few pounds I didn't need to drop at all. But I was determined and so I ate only grapefruit and drank water for the first two meals of the day, then had a regular dinner with the family. I was careful not to let my family see me trying to make a meal out of a grapefruit, which is plenty of indication I knew then that it wasn't healthy or wise.

Still, I kept it up for three days. I aimed to do it for a week, but on the afternoon of that third day, I got a flash of light-headedness and slowly wobbled backward to the floor. I didn't pass out but I came very close. My teacher helped me to my feet and then sent me to the nurse's office, where I drank water and gobbled down a bag of chips I found in my backpack.

I was groggy and hungry and irritated at myself that I felt so awful and ashamed. All of that to lose a little bit of weight for an insignificant boy. 

I wish I could say I learned my lesson that day, but I didn't. Long after that boyfriend was out of the picture, I went on many diets, weight loss plans and exercise programs to try to squeeze my body back into "skinny little thing" shape. Some of that was to try to un-do my own Freshman 15 on the Great Welcome to College Where You Can Eat Lucky Charms and Ice Cream for Dinner Diet. Some of those attempts were healthy and some were not at all. Some of them worked for a while and some of them only inspired crabbiness and cravings.

The one thing I haven't done since the grapefruit diet debacle is try to lose weight for a man. It doesn't mean my intentions have always been the greatest or the messages to myself have always been empowering, but it is one part of the equation I am glad I've since left out. 

I'm also happy to say I've never tried the grapefruit diet again. I do enjoy grapefruit, but now am good having it as a part of a much healthier breakfast rather than as the entirety of my meal. I glad to report I've never done the Master Cleanse or cabbage diet or lemon diet or miso soup diet or any of that other craziness that leads us to feel hungry and irritated, to be completely unhealthy and misguided, and to eventually end up on the floor.

As for the boyfriend, I delighted in the irony that he'd gained a good deal of weight when I ran into him on the street a few years ago. Of course, I wouldn't wish ill will or health upon him. But I did laugh to myself to think that maybe, just maybe, all that criticism was thrown back at him like rotten, karmic fruit.

Now you weigh in: What's the dumbest diet you've ever tried?

[photo credit: Getty Images]
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 38
  • laura's Avatar
    Posted by laura Fri Oct 17, 2008 7:43pm PDT

    For A year and a half I ate only a half of a grapefruit. If I ate more than that I made my self sick.. I lost weight. only 60 lbs. and of course once I stopped .... it came back and more... after all I totally screwed up my matabolizm ....... I regret doing it now.. but, it worked.

    I haven't had much luck with any thing else I even tried weight watchers. Gained 5 lbs the first week.. I knew it was too much food, even though I followed the program.

    bound by fat, bound to be fat.

    Report Abuse
  • Jigga187's Avatar
    Posted by Jigga187 Fri Oct 17, 2008 7:51pm PDT

    When I was 10 years old, my dad thought it was a smart idea to put me on Slim-Fast. However, he missed the part about the shake being the entire meal and he was making me drink it as a beverage to accompany my meal. In addition to the fact that I was on asthma medications, which are steroids and cause weight gain. 19 years later, needless to say I've never recovered and I feel destined to be overweight for all eternity. Talk about a recipe for disaster!

    Report Abuse
  • G's Avatar
    Posted by G Fri Oct 17, 2008 8:31pm PDT

    A liquid diet my crazy doctor put me on .I lost a whole pound. It was gross and I felt sick and weak all the time.

    Report Abuse
  • maiko i's Avatar
    Posted by maiko i Fri Oct 17, 2008 10:59pm PDT

    Look

    The best diet is sex... sex .sex sex... you will maintain your waistline and feel great in the process... don't do the lifting and jogging and not eating... just find someone you are hot for and

    go sex crazy..... *(disclaimer)

    Report Abuse
  • KONSTANCE H's Avatar
    Posted by KONSTANCE H Sat Oct 18, 2008 10:41am PDT

    i have tried load of stupid diets and in truth i think they are all a con just another industry trying to con people into buying a load of old nonesense, a bit like those breast enlargement cures and all that stuff.

    if you belive the critics and the nutritional nonsense on TV you would never eat another thing again, and some of the diets are potentially dangerous.

    eating or living of grapes, grapefruits, and cabbage water, will send you to hospital!

    so would that stupid Kelloggs two bowls to weeks of starvation later and your instantly cured of flab!

    diets who needs them?

    Report Abuse
  • Amihobbit's Avatar
    Posted by Amihobbit Sat Oct 18, 2008 7:51pm PDT

    My crazy diet was that Kombusha Tea one, it didn't do a thing for me it tasted like gross slimey vinegar water it was pretty gross.

    Report Abuse
  • Tiadora's Avatar
    Posted by Tiadora Sun Oct 19, 2008 1:06am PDT

    Humm im the type of person who invents diets....so i guess it counts as stupid but it actualy worked for me!!

    I just ate soups salads and sandwitches for a month or so and i lost about twenty pounds and have kept it off almost a year later :-)

    And it actualy made me feel good just eating lite meals all the time instead of fried and greasy food......

    Report Abuse
  • Gabi's Avatar
    Posted by Gabi Sun Oct 19, 2008 4:31am PDT

    I was on the "cabbage diet" a few years ago it didn't work! Then I was on the "detox diet", also didn't work. Not only was I hungry, but I also felt very tired and really down. I gained the weight back. All these diets are stupid, I regret that I ever decided to put my body through so much trouble.....

    Report Abuse
  • Habanero♥™'s Avatar
    Posted by Habanero♥™ Sun Oct 19, 2008 5:22am PDT

    LIQUID PROTEIN: Back in the late 60's to late 70's the craze was a liquid protein (COW'S STOMACH LINING) It was a craze amongst employees of health Spas. It was dangerous beyond words and didn't contain vital vitamins and minerals. Many people died of heart attacks, including some people I worked with.

    Report Abuse
  • MARYGOLD's Avatar
    Posted by MARYGOLD Sun Oct 19, 2008 5:52am PDT

    After having my son I weighed almost 200 pounds from 107 so I stopped eating meat and drinking soda and exercised 20 minutes a day. I went down to 102, and I have maintained that. I eat meat now. It was exciting to check my weight every week. It took two months to lose all the weight and it was not painful, but I sure missed those cheeseburgers.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 38

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Health Byte

Get healthy foods for your family that won’t take a bite out of your budget.  Healthy living costs less at Walmart.