Healthy Living

Sunday, December 6, 2009

Why losing weight is so hard and gaining weight is so easy

Scale

You just went away for the weekend and you came back to find that you gained 5 pounds over the course of 3 days. In your disbelief, you quickly curse the Weight Gods for being so cruel. Sound familiar? This was me last weekend. A little jaunt to Montreal, eating at decadent cafes, packed it on quick. This inspired me to discuss the seemingly unbalanced equation of weight gain vs. weight loss, the facts that surround the issue and how losing the 5 pounds feels so much harder than gaining them:

FACT 1 - It is Simple Math: To maintain your ideal weight, you need to eat as many calories as you burn in one day. The balanced equation looks like this:

Calories Eaten = Basal Metabolic Rate + Physical Activity

If what you eat equals more than what your body uses, you will gain weight. In the situation of a vacation, it is likely that you eat more unhealthy food than normal and possibly get less exercise, resulting in an imbalanced equation, with a higher number of calories on the eaten side than on the burned side. That imbalance over the course of a few days can easily represent a few pounds. (To assess an approximate of how many calories you need, click here.)

FACT 2 - A Pound is a Pound is a Pound: One pound of body mass represents 3,500 calories. Regardless, if you are trying to lose a pound or gain a pound, the pound will always represent 3,500 calories. So, if you eat 3,500 calories more than your body requires, you will gain 1 pound. Similarly, if you eat 3,500 calories less than your body requires, you will lose 1 pound.

FACT 3 - Exercise is Weight Discriminating: Whether you are 120 pounds or 175 pounds, you will gain one pound from eating 3,500 calories more than you need. Unfortunately, this doesn't hold true for burning calories. How much you weigh actually dictates how many calories you burn per hour. The more you weigh, the more you burn, and as a result, the easier it is to lose the pound...sound crazy? It is true. Check out the Calories Burned Chart .

FACT 4 - Aging Contributes to Weight Gain: As if aging doesn't contribute enough to unfavorable things, it also contributes to weight gain. As we get older, our metabolism slows down, requiring us to need less food and calories. If you don't modify your caloric intake as you get older to reflect this change in metabolism, you will start to see weight gain.

The Bad News: Unfortunately, eating an extra couple of unhealthy snacks or drinking a few extra glasses of wine can happen in a blink of an eye. However, the time and energy required to burn off those calories takes a lot more effort. We have provided a chart on what 1,000 calories looks like on both sides in the chart below (remember, it is 3,500 calories that make up a pound).

Calorie Chart

The Good News: Whether it is rapid or slow weight gain that you have experienced, losing the extra weight can be tackled through two avenues (and should be): calorie reduction and exercise . Choosing to lose weight through both calorie reduction and exercise will accelerate the process. If for seven days you burn 200 extra calories through exercise and reduce your food intake by 300 calories each day, you will lose that extra pound. Further, it is a lot easier than trying to either reduce your caloric intake by 3,500 calories (which is physically impossible) or burning an extra 3,500 calories during exercise (which takes a ridiculous amount of time and energy).

What you Can Do: Assess whether your weight gain was a rapid gain due to atypical behavior (E.g., vacationing) or a longer-term gain. If it was a rapid gain, there is a good chance you will lose the weight by returning to your normal habits. You might have to be a little strict for a day or two, but you shouldn't feel like a major overhaul is in order. If, however, you have gained the weight over a period of time, assess your habits and think about what has changed in your life. Have you stopped exercising? Have you let your eating habits go? Have you hit a milestone birthday? Once you can assess the reality of your situation, remember the equation: to maintain balance, burn the calories you eat.

Relevant Topics:

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 11-20 of 136
  • Patrick's Avatar
    Posted by Patrick Wed Aug 20, 2008 6:39pm PDT

    Excellant info we should be greatful to the author

    Report Abuse
  • Patrick's Avatar
    Posted by Patrick Wed Aug 20, 2008 6:48pm PDT

    Very valuable info provided by the author. We should be really be greatful for such people who would share their knoledge with others.one of the most valuble.informative and timely material.

    Report Abuse
  • makestoomuchsense's Avatar
    Posted by makestoomuchsense Thu Aug 21, 2008 8:20am PDT

    On paper, this logic that is sited by those in the health industry is correct. However, it is not that simple for many people. There are too many factors that influence this equasion. Personal metabolism, hormone levels (everyones varys within what is considered the normal range), and yes - genetic composition. What works out neat and simple on paper can often mislead people and give them unrealistic expectations for weight loss. Though this article is trying to be helpful, for many who don't do research of their own, it will be hurtful.

    I have been trying to maintain my weight since being obese as a child. Last year, following this golden standard of calories in, calories out I followed a military like regimine or weighing and measuring every morsel of food and drop of liquid that entered my mouth. I exercised using a heart rate moniter to more accurately measure calories burned. Using these tools, I burned had a calorie deficit of 1000 per day. At that rate, I should have lost 2 pounds a week. But I never once in 6 months lost more than 1/2 a pound tops per week. Some weeks I even lost NONE.

    If weight loss were as simple as you claim, everyone would have an easy time losing weight and you wouldnt have examples like me. I doubt that I am simply an exception to this "rule" of weightloss. Everywhere I tell my story others say that this was their experience too. Like I said, this works on paper - but in the unique and complex human body, not so much.

    Report Abuse
  • Brett Blumenthal - Sheer Balance's Avatar
    Posted by Brett Blumenthal - Sheer Balance Thu Aug 21, 2008 8:40am PDT

    rachiebaby...you are correct...the equation is 1 piece of it. Metabolism has a huge part to do with it. And so do other personal factors. I would actually recommend that you speak to your physician. If you are having that much trouble losing weight, you may have a condition that is preventing you from losing the weight. Additionally, WHAT you eat can actually influence your ability to lose weight if you have allergies or sensitivities or problems digesting certain foods. Nutrition is extremely complex and extremely personal...Good luck...

    Report Abuse
  • livetothemax...'s Avatar
    Posted by livetothemax... Thu Aug 21, 2008 11:09am PDT

    Actually a lot of the myths and misconceptions can now be dispelled...Leptin has been discovered to be the hormone that tells your brain to store fat. By lowering the Leptin level, healthy fat loss occurs, no dieting required. Over an 8 week clinical study, an average of 21.5 pounds of fat (Not muscle or water) were lost by women taking a new patented product, Max WLX. You will be hearing more about this product from Dr. Rosedale of The Rosedale diet who is endorsing WLX for healthy fat loss. No stimulants, no side effects and safe for diabetics and the insulin resistent. Check out www.lindysmaxsite.com for more information.

    Report Abuse
  • dk1's Avatar
    Posted by dk1 Thu Aug 21, 2008 3:31pm PDT

    Vanessa,

    How hard do you walk, and be honest. I don't mean this in a mean way at all. I know it is hard. But unless you are at least a little out of breath and sweating a little, you will not make a difference. as well your walks need to be hard and last for at least 15 min but longer is better. Keep a hard pace and get yourself to the point where you are uncomfortable. Then you will see results.

    All the best.

    _______________________________________________________________

    It's better to get healthy slow than unhealthy fast.

    Report Abuse
  • dk1's Avatar
    Posted by dk1 Thu Aug 21, 2008 3:40pm PDT

    Correction, For my above comment.

    Save your cards and letters folks, I realize mine was a pretty general statement. Their are plenty of people that do have other issues that get in the way of losing wieght. In that case I second Brett a couple posts up. One more general comment. Don't forget to do stregth training if you can as well. your muscle will help you lose wieght by feeding off the fat in your body as well. And if you are doing healthy things but feel like your just not losing the pounds, that does not mean you are not losing fat. Muscle weighs more than fat so while losing fat you may be gaining muscle as well.

    ____________________________________________________________

    It's better to get healthy slow than unhealthy fast.

    Report Abuse
  • Barachiel's Avatar
    Posted by Barachiel Thu Aug 21, 2008 6:16pm PDT

    If I may be so bold livetothemax.

    Too date I have yet to see a single diet drug that has proven to result in any greater weight loss then ten percent. Which means they are worthless to anyone whose weight is a concern. And everything has side effects, mild or serious, everything does.

    So I would love for you to post a link to your new miracle Leptin product, with the lab studies that proves it. I know of studies influencing leptin in mice, as well as injections, which are expensive. But to my knowledge any oral delivery is a mute point considering dealing with this 167 amino-acid based hormone.

    This may be coming across harsher then intended but when you are dealing with hormones, it is a dangerous game. Especially when you can find a connection between leptin and metabolic and hormonal adaptations such as decreased/increased metabolic rate, decreased/increased voluntary energy expenditure (exercise), immune function, reproductive function, and anabolic hormonal output (GhRH and GH, GRH and Testosterone, TSH and Thyroid hormones), even CRH and adrenal hormones.

    Yes, leptin is fascinating and the studies in these last ten years are promising. But I'd like some evidence before promoting a miracle treatment. When eating healthy and staying active has worked for centuries.

    Report Abuse
  • Brett Blumenthal - Sheer Balance's Avatar
    Posted by Brett Blumenthal - Sheer Balance Thu Aug 21, 2008 7:03pm PDT

    Barachiel...I couldn't agree more. I hate the concept of diet, fitness or any health wonder drugs...

    Report Abuse
  • Barachiel's Avatar
    Posted by Barachiel Fri Aug 22, 2008 2:16pm PDT

    Thanks for the confirm Brett. Here to help spread the good word. 8)

    Report Abuse
Comments 11-20 of 136

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Updates Chatter on Shine…

Health Byte

Tune in to our fitness forecast! These are the top ten exercise trends for 2010.