Healthy Living

Wednesday, December 9, 2009

Would you tell your partner how much you weigh?

I love this post about the one thing we won't do in front of our partners, up now in Love + Sex. It made me laugh, it made me think and it made just a little grossed out to read (OK, skim) the 400 (and counting) comments. The reason why it's funny and thought provoking, and yes, even rather disgusting is because it's true that there are those things we just cannot bring ourselves to reveal in even the most intimate relationships.

To get my mind off of some of the bathroom behavior some readers (oh no, not you) clearly felt comfortable revealing in the comments but not to their boyfriend or girlfriend or spouse (strange, true), I turned my attention to healthy living.  Surely, I thought, there are aspects of our diet, exercise and well-being we don't feel comfortable sharing with the ones we love.

Before that thought was fully formed in my mind, I knew exactly what it was I could not reveal to a partner. My weight.

And really, that holds true whether the scale is up or down for me, whether I'm with a long-term partner or have just met someone new. It was at that point I remembered that a guy I dated for about five minutes a million years ago asked me to tell him what size I wore. At the time, it was a smaller size than I'd been wearing for years, but I am sure when I gasped he knew I was uncomfortable with telling him anyway. He back-pedaled, explaining awkwardly that he might like to buy me clothes (which was weird enough in itself) and so it would be nice to have all my sizes and measurements.

Umm, no thanks. A gift card will do nicely. That's what I thought then, and honestly, what I think now, years later and with a body image that is thankfully much, much better.

Even when I was with my (almost-ex) husband, I cringed to let him see the weight I tapped into my heart rate monitor or even stand too close to the scale when we both joined Weight Watchers before our wedding. Analyze as much as you'd like, but it just felt like my size and weight were my private domain and any way my spouse supported me could be done without specific statistics.

What about you? Would you tell your partner how much you weigh? Does (clothing) size matter when you're being honest with your spouse?


[photo credit: Getty Images]






Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 11-20 of 75
  • DEBRA's Avatar
    Posted by DEBRA Tue Oct 7, 2008 2:31am PDT

    already done

    Report Abuse
  • Nini Poo's Avatar
    Posted by Nini Poo Tue Oct 7, 2008 5:18am PDT

    yes, why wouldn't I?

    Report Abuse
  • dt's Avatar
    Posted by dt Tue Oct 7, 2008 6:29am PDT

    i think its horrible how much stress people put on the number. you could be 155 lbs and most of it lean muscle, or weigh 110 with mostly fat!

    Report Abuse
  • Amanda's Avatar
    Posted by Amanda Tue Oct 7, 2008 6:33am PDT

    if i were happy with my weight then i wouldn't have a problem telling him, but i'm not...so i don't. he don't ask anyway. he loves me for me, so it's not important.

    Report Abuse
  • melissap's Avatar
    Posted by melissap Tue Oct 7, 2008 6:36am PDT

    he sees me naked (lights on an all). he can know my weight.

    Report Abuse
  • 's Avatar
    Posted by Tue Oct 7, 2008 7:40am PDT

    I WENT TO THE DOCTORS YESTERDAY AND FIND OUT I GAINED 12LBS WITHIN TWO MONTHS. I WAS SO DEVISTATED!!! MY BF CAME HOME AND NOTICE SOMETHING WAS WRONG. I TOLD HIM WHAT HAD HAPPEN AND HE SAID HE WILL LOVE ME REGARDLESS OF MY WEIGHT AND HE GOT ON HIS KNEES AND PROPOSED TO ME WITH A RING. HE SAID HE WAS WAITING FOR THE RIGHT TIME TO DO IT AND HE DISCOVER THAT IT WAS AT THAT MOMENT WHEN I WAS GOING THROUGH THAT TRAUMA. I SAID ALL OF THAT TO SAY THIS, YOU SHOULDN'T HIDE WHO YOU REALLY ARE AND IF A MAN LOVES YOU THE WAY HE SAYS THEN HE WILL BE SUPPORTIVE AND NOT USE CRITISIZM. OBIVOUSLY YOU NOT COMFORTABLE WITH WHO YOU ARE AND THATS SOMETHING YOU NEED TO WORK ON FOR YOURSELF.

    Report Abuse
  • ambi's Avatar
    Posted by ambi Tue Oct 7, 2008 7:46am PDT

    Even if you dont tell him, men can always guesstimate. They see you naked.

    I really don't care what if my man knows my weight (and currently i weigh more than him by twenty pounds).

    I would much rather be up front an honest with him and say "i weigh 230 pounds and i want to weigh 140" I am a big girl, but i am working on loosing. One pound at a time.

    Report Abuse
  • kristin's Avatar
    Posted by kristin Tue Oct 7, 2008 8:17am PDT

    I actually lie and say I weigh more than I do. I'm 5'7 and 1/2 and weigh about 100 lbs(think Kate Moss) and say I weigh about 115. Most do not ask becasue you NEVER ask a woman her age or weight:)

    Report Abuse
  • LoriFB's Avatar
    Posted by LoriFB Tue Oct 7, 2008 8:29am PDT

    I've been with my husband for 4 years now and he has no clue how much I weigh. There are only 3 people that know. Myself, the nurse at my physician's office (because she weighs me), and my physician.

    Report Abuse
  • Abiodun A's Avatar
    Posted by Abiodun A Tue Oct 7, 2008 9:08am PDT

    Well as a man, I wouldn't mind what she really weighs, after all I saw her, I was attracted to her and I have decided to go out with her, why should her size now be an issue........

    Report Abuse
Comments 11-20 of 75

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Health Byte

How likely are you to be a workout drop-out? Take our quiz to size up your chances of exercise success.