Manage Your Life

Tuesday, December 1, 2009

Credit card companies are watching you

Getty Images

Getty Images

Oh, you bet they are.

Now that credit flows less freely, and customers are struggling to pay off debt in a tough economy while Congress has taken a tougher stance with credit card companies, the companies are mining the data available to them about how and where we spend. Then, as this fascinating New York Times Magazine story shows, they are using some very basic psychology training to figure out what it all means when dealing with customers one on one.

Have you ever gotten one of those calls from a credit card company to alert you to an unusual purchase out of concern that a thief had gotten hold of your card and was using it for ill gain? How nice, you thought. Isn't that great. They are keeping an eye to make sure my card and credit are secure. Well, think about it. The same data-profiling metrics used to spot an unorthodox purchase can be used to assess all of your spending habits, and any changes that may trigger concerns about money problems and risky behavior.

Data profiling allows credit card companies to judge whether your spending indicates you are having money trouble. They are using the info gleaned from your purchases to decide whether your credit limit should be reduced or, more seriously, you need to be targeted for some heavy-handed collection calls. It is not a perfect science, so often the judgments reached will be unfair. Alcohol purchases, according to this NPR piece, are top of the list for triggering concerns that, say, maybe you're letting off steam because you're worried about losing your job.

Being frugal doesn't always put you in a good light, either. Say you usually shop at mall department stores then start shopping regularly at Wal-Mart. Yep, you could very well receive notice from a credit card company that your credit limit has been reduced soon after the switch.

NPR rounded up 10 purchases to avoid (or at least think twice about) putting on your credit card because they are just the kind of thing data-mining programs pick up on. Number one: traffic tickets. "You look reckless. And tickets can push up your insurance rates, which could put a strain on your finances, which could make it harder for you to pay your bills. A lot of people who have charged traffic tickets have defaulted on their cards," NPR reports.

The other purchases, beside alcohol, include:
  • marriage counseling
  • lottery tickets
  • income tax payments
  • retreading tires
Retreading tires? It indicates you can't afford new tires. "Credit card companies don't like desperation," NPR reports.

Does any of this come as a surprise? Or do you make all of your purchases knowing someone is watching?

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 11-20 of 31
  • Aj's Avatar
    Posted by Aj Sat Jul 11, 2009 7:23am PDT

    This is a sign of govt control! I cant stand credit cards!

    Report Abuse
  • springtime's Avatar
    Posted by springtime Sat Jul 11, 2009 9:38am PDT

    Sure, I use credit cards. I have three. I also pay each one off each month.It's all about self control. I'll never use a debit card. If it's stolen or lost, your bank account will be emptied in a heart beat. There are safeguards with credit cards.

    Report Abuse
  • LisaC's Avatar
    Posted by LisaC Sat Jul 11, 2009 2:00pm PDT

    I frankly don't care if they see what I buy. My spending is incredibly sporadic. I shop at both the Dollar Tree and have a Direct Buy membership I use to buy thousand dollar items on a regular basis. If they want to check it - fine. But, I had my identity stolen and someone wrote checks in my name. You think the bank cared? No. Credit cards provide a type of safety that checks, cash, and debit cards can only dream of. AND, I just got a FREE ticket to London with my points. I also used my points for a trip for 2 to Vegas the year before last. But, I never go over my limit (by even half) and I pay it in full every single month. I have never paid any interest or late fees. I have a budget, and I (mostly) stick strictly to it, allowing for some last minute emergency stuff (like a blown tire). If you can't utilize a CC like you would cash, then you don't have the self control to keep yourself out of trouble and should avoid them at all costs. If you are a bit more disciplined, then by all means you should reap the rewards. Make the cards work for you, not the other way around.

    Report Abuse
  • appleblossom's Avatar
    Posted by appleblossom Sat Jul 11, 2009 6:22pm PDT

    Over the past 5 years I have paid off all of my credit cards and currently only have my debit credit card, I am trying to but a new car and it has been very difficult because I do not have enough of a credit history. ARE YOU KIDDING ME??????? so being fiscally minded is now some how a bad thing. This is such crap!!!!!!!

    Report Abuse
  • kingtj's Avatar
    Posted by kingtj Sat Jul 11, 2009 7:43pm PDT

    It's not *really* about being fiscally-minded, though. It's about fitting the profile of an "ideal customer" for a lender (credit card company). They hate people who always pay their card off in full, on-time! That makes you a "leech" as far as they're concerned. You keep borrowing their money for as long as 25 days or so at a time, without them ever being able to make a dime off of lending it to you.

    What THEY want are the people who keep a balance on their cards, but are predictable and appear to be financially able to make payments without any issues. I also have some suspicions that some lenders like using credit cards as a way to gain "insight" into your spending habits, because you have a much larger car or home loan with them, or other bank accounts with them. I've noticed that the companies offering me the best credit card offers (largest balances, lowest interest rates, etc.) are either the banks I already have a checking and/or savings account with, or the ones I have a car loan with.

    Report Abuse
  • david's Avatar
    Posted by david Sat Jul 11, 2009 8:38pm PDT

    big brother is watching us

    Report Abuse
  • dashdorj's Avatar
    Posted by dashdorj Sun Jul 12, 2009 1:08am PDT

    games

    Report Abuse
  • Spam I Am's Avatar
    Posted by Spam I Am Sun Jul 12, 2009 8:49am PDT

    kingtj, I was about to post...all the things that you posted.

    Well said.

    Report Abuse
  • Ms. High's Avatar
    Posted by Ms. High Sun Jul 12, 2009 3:35pm PDT

    No this doesn't come to a surprise, it just reminds me that I need to get rid of the f'ers.

    Report Abuse
  • Ms. High's Avatar
    Posted by Ms. High Sun Jul 12, 2009 3:37pm PDT

    Annie, if you used the cash in the first place, your number would have never been hijacked. get it???

    Report Abuse
Comments 11-20 of 31

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

manage your life byte

from Target

All kinds of wonderful. Gifts, solutions and savings all in one place. Find every merry solution at Target.