Manage Your Life

Saturday, November 21, 2009

Don't cash out your 401(k)!

Getty Images

Getty Images

Talk about a glass-half-full, glass-half-empty time. Just when we can be encouraged by news that the recession is over, it's hard to feel happy when so many people remain out of work and unemployment is expected to rise even more before it falls.

Here's another reason it's hard to feel good about any possible forward momentum: A Hewitt Associates study finds that even though we have talked a good game about the importance of saving during this economic crisis, it turns out that half of all workers continue to cash out their 401(k) plans when they leave or change jobs.

It's easy to see how it happens, especially if you're a worker in your twenties who thinks that you've got lots and lots of time to save for retirement.  This AP story features a 29-year-old who found a need to tap into his 401(k) funds in his twenties after he gave notice to one job after getting an offer for another, only to have that offer rescinded. Out of work, he cashed out $10,000 in retirement savings and was surprised to find out that he needed to pay about a third of it upfront in taxes and penalties, and more taxes later to the IRS because the money was considered income that year.

Here's an example of what happens when you cash out 401(k) funds, from Hewitt: "An employee who cashes out a $5,000 retirement balance at age 25 would get a check for just $3,500 after taxes and penalties. Left in an account, that $5,000 may have grown over decades to $75,000 at retirement."

Easier said than done when cash and jobs are short, to be sure. But if there is any way to look at 401(k) money as if it doesn't even exist so you don't think of it as ready cash. do it. By continuing to let it ride out the market and reap the benefits of compounding interest, you may have some more options when you age--besides working until you can no longer work.

Have you felt forced to use 401(k) funds as a last resort?
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-6 of 6
  • Ahleah G's Avatar
    Posted by Ahleah G Tue Nov 3, 2009 11:35am PST

    Also don't take a loan against your 401K. My BF did this at his former job. A deduction was taken from his paycheck every month to repay the loan in addition to any new contributions he made. While there was no tax penalty for the loan, it certainly caused problems when he found himself out of work in the summer. He either had to pay back the loan in full (~$3000, hard to do when you just lost your job) or it was counted as a distribution from his 401K and he has to pay taxes on the amount that was never paid back.

    Report Abuse
  • haley's Avatar
    Posted by haley Wed Nov 4, 2009 6:26am PST

    We just got a check in the mail from my husband's 401k. He's been out of work for awhile now and we did it as a last resort. To go a long with that, i'm putting in a percentage more per paycheck into my own 401k, hopefully that helps in the long run.

    Our main problem is we live in Duluth, Mn and while there are plenty of benefits for us the state is having trouble as well. We've qualified for fuel assistance but sadly, our city hasn't received any of that money from the state yet. Now this october is mild luckily but in the past we've had two feet of snow already by halloween.

    We cashed in his 401k to NOT freeze and have our pipes burst this wonter, now hopefully the state money comes in soon so we can put most of that money into savings but fuel oil can get expensive. I'm awfully worried about the other families out there that can't afford even the minimum delivery of fuel oil that we got (around 375 dollars) as we're getting frost overnight now.

    Report Abuse
  • Lori's Avatar
    Posted by Lori Thu Nov 5, 2009 6:15pm PST

    I lost my job of 14 years,in March, I had to cash in my 401k so they wouldn't repo my car..and I also had to buy heating oil. Around 1000.00, I might have to fill the tanks again before winter is over...This Sucks!!

    Report Abuse
  • kris's Avatar
    Posted by kris Thu Nov 5, 2009 11:14pm PST

    I took out a lump sum of my 401k ($9000, but only received $7500)to help when my wife is on short term disability for 8 weeks and to care for my third child. Paid off some of my small bills and my school loan. Im only taking one weeek of unpaid FMLA to be with wife and kids. So thats what I had to do.

    Report Abuse
  • William's Avatar
    Posted by William Thu Nov 5, 2009 11:20pm PST

    Stop spending your money on gifts, pleasure items, snack food, cigs., alcohol etc. Your loved ones should still love you even without birthday gifts or christmas gifts. Just 1 game can cost $45.00-$70.00

    If there is any type of game machine in your home you do not deserve sympathy. You are causing the youth in your family to waste valuable education time!

    Report Abuse
  • terry b's Avatar
    Posted by terry b Fri Nov 6, 2009 9:43am PST

    well, I could leave my 401k alone and sell my 05' truck that I rarely drive (so that it will be worth as much as possible...IF I gotta sell it...35,000 miles onnit...) 'cuz I drive my '97 4-cyl pickup for its' economy...REALLY don't like its' smallness, but it's CHEAP...or dig out some major $$$$ from my 401k and pay penalties, taxes, blabla...shux, I'm inna unhappy place...SUMPIN'S gotta let go, n' I'm hopin' it's drilling for oil stateside...that puts EVERYONE back to work.....I know that there's plenty of 'non-oil'-ers out there, but guess what?...it's OIL that greases our economy, NOT 'paper-pushers' that skim off $$$ from banking and debt-services companies....(There!...I feel a lil' better...)

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-6 of 6

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

manage your life byte

from Target

All kinds of wonderful. Gifts, solutions and savings all in one place. Find every merry solution at Target.