ETFs What Only A Man Could Love
<p>ETFs, or Exchange Traded Funds, are a type of
investment fund that only a man could think up. Men have
this thing about equations, like E=mc2, or E+T+F=
I'm a genius. <br><br>To understand ETFs,
without getting into arcane market jargon, we can look at
the male psychology behind their
creation. <br><br>ETFs were designed
to be better than mutual funds, in certain respects. Mutual funds,
as you know, are "mutual"
assets. You send a mutual fund your money and you get
a proportional ownership of a basket of stocks.
When you redeem your money they either pay you out
of their cash account, or sell the stocks in the portfolio
and pay you from that, but everyones shares are worth the
same. When you send them money, they buy more
stock. <br><br>A mutual fund is a kind of
co-op food pantry, only it holds stocks and bonds. There
are many women who run mutual funds, Lynette Schroeder, Michelle
Stevens and Ami Domini, to name a few. One of the
downsides of a mutual fund is that you can only buy or redeem at
the end of the day. You can send your order in at any
time, but the value of what you put in, or take out, is determined
after the market closes.<br><br>As you probably know,
there are many men who like to go into and out of the market three,
four, five, maybe ten times a day. (Have you ever met a
female day-trader? I haven't.) Anyway,
these men find mutual funds frustrating. There are a
"closed-end" variety of mutual funds that you can
trade during the day, but they have premium/discount problems we
won't get into here. Mutual funds are designed
for the long-term, but we all know men like to play around in the
short-term.<br><br>So men got to thinking, how can we
create a mutual funds that can trade any time during the day like a
stock. That way we can add them to our equations and
charts and market-timing systems. You wouldn't
believe the amount of thought and energy that went into the
creation of ETFs. So many loop-holes have to be gone
through that it costs an ETF provider about $1 million in legal
fees, and a year of waiting, to get the SEC to give them exemptive
permission to create one. There are over 600 ETFs as I
write this.<br><br>The problem the ETF men faced was
how to allow investors to go into and out of the fund during the
day without hurting the value of the other investors. For
example, if Adam decides to sell $50 million worth of his fund
shares during the day the fund might have to sell that much in IBM
stock. Such selling would drive the price down, making
other fund holders end up, at the end of the day, with
less value in their holdings.
<br><br>It's accepted in the market that people
buying and selling stock will drive the prices up an
down. But in a fund you can't allow one
shareholder to do something that hurts other
shareholders. Otherwise, how would you sleep at
night?<br><br>As I get closer to having to explain how
ETFs work I'm thinking, there's no way to explain
this except to say Men Are Nuts!<br><br>An ETF starts
with an index. The index is a list of stocks in a model
portfolio. An ETF manager then forms a
relationship with a financial heavyweight, called an authorized
participant, or AP. The AP, who owns every stock known to
man, in its own account (think Goldman Sachs), trades a basket of
stocks listed in the index for shares in the
ETF. <br><br>You can think
of an ETF like a special lunch basket. The AP is the food
wholesaler. The ETF creates lunch baskets out of the
wholesalers food. But here's where it
get's complicated. When you buy your ETF you
don't get rights to the food behind it, like you do a
mutual fund. You can't trade in your apple, to
the wholesaler, and get what it's worth. You must
sell your lunch basket to someone else.
<br><br>This is where men really get lathered
up. How do you prevent the lunch baskets from losing too
much value if you can't get them to sell your proportional
ownership? What if no one wants to buy your lunch
basket? You want your ETF to be worth what the index is
worth, not something less (though you wouldn't mind
something more). The answer is arbitrage.
That's malespeak for buying something from some innocent
person who doesn't know it's worth more
across the street.<br><br>The arbitrage works like
this. If the ETF value gets too low, the AP would be
motivated to sell his ETF shares at the discount and resell the
component stocks at their market rate, which is higher, and earn a
profit. For example, if you bought your lunch basket for
$10, and it only contains an apple and a sandwich, and it went down
to $5, while apples were still worth $5 alone, then the AP would
buy the ETF from you, resell the apple for $5, and then whatever
the sandwich was worth would be pure profit.
<br><br>Working in the other direction, if the ETF went
up very high, the AP would create ETF lunch baskets with its food
and resell the ETFs for a profit. Through this process,
ETF shares are created and redeemed in a way that keeps them
naturally close to the index value.<br><br>ETFs, then,
are exactly what they say they are, Exchange Trade Funds, or Funds
that are traded on the stock market. Though
they're not really funds in the traditional
sense. They are stock market shares that are supposed to
follow the value of an index representing a theoretical
fund, like the S&P 500, or NASDAQ 100, or some stocks
representing the stock market in China. Mutual funds,
again, are not traded on a market. Once a day every
shareholder can put in, or take out, money from the mutual fund
directly.<br><br>So if your husband or boyfriend thinks
something good is going to happen to financial stocks at 2:30 pm,
he can buy an ETF following a financial stock index at 1:00 pm,
wait for the event to happen, then sell the ETF at 3:00 pm and put
you to sleep with his exploits that same
night.<br><br>Well, that's enough for
now. Let me know if you want me to write more about ETFs,
or any other fund subject. <br><br>I also
hope you'll visit my site <a rel="nofollow"
href="http://www.fundanalyze.com">FundAnalyze.com</a>
where you can work on your current portfolio of mutual funds,
should you wish to lower your costs.
<br><br><br><br><br><br></p>
- Let’s talk: Comment (0) | Blog
- Email to a Friend
- Print this Page
Syndication:
From the Community…
Be the first to comment on this post.
leave your comment
You must sign in to post a comment
