Manage Your Life

Wednesday, February 10, 2010

Is Religion Really Mind Control For The Illiterate?

I came across this article in my local Saturday paper. The author really got me into thinking even more of why I don't believe in religion - especially Christianity. I think he has a point.  Also, in the early 1960's he was a Minister of the First Ward Methodist Church and was a Professor of International Politics at Slippery Rock University in Pennsylvania.

So what do you think of his point? Please note the particular part I italicized below.


Old texts are a valued part of the history of humankind Saturday, June 06, 2009 By Donald F. Megnin, Contributing writer

While it is possible for persons to assume too much about what they believe because they think such a belief system will enable them to qualify for whatever comes after this earthly existence, I believe human existence is the same as for any other species.

We are born, grow, are taught, become self-sustaining individuals, have our own progeny and then die in the continuous cycle of life, growth, contribution, old age and death. Whatever we have been "taught" about religion and the next stage "following death" is pure projection of desire unsubstantiated by evidence.

Most of the world's population has been "taught" to believe in some first cause, deity, higher power or "God." The names are various depending upon which religious tradition a person has been born into.

In the Judeo-Christian tradition, we have been taught to believe a series of stories contained in the Old and New Testaments about the earliest periods of the history of the Semitic peoples as if these times were sacred, inspired by deity and therefore, not to be questioned or considered as anything other than the "truth."

From my perspective, however, these ancient stories were written by persons who believed themselves to have been "appointed" by deity to set forth the way people of that era were supposed to live, behave and continue to thrive in the face of the hostility, threats, wars and various natural disasters which have occurred throughout the history.

The early books of the Bible were written by men with a message which they wished to impart to their fellow tribal members about what is real, what they should do with their lives and how they should behave toward their neighbors and enemies. Hence, we need to keep in mind that these "authors" were talking to people who were not educated, had no knowledge of distinguishing fact from fiction, and had no access to any education which might cause them to question what their religious and political leaders were saying, writing or requiring them to do.

The tribal, political and religious leaders of those days sought to place themselves in positions of authority from which they could continue to gain merit and status through the accumulation of wealth and power. The manuscripts, books and religious claims were used as tools to keep the "authorities" in positions of power and while continuing their domination over benighted, illiterate followers.

We can, indeed, say that some of the old texts were and are highly valued as part of the collective history of humankind, which has helped to elevate and raise the standards of human behavior. However, the claims which exceed the test of confirmation through the study of proven evidence must be regarded as "truth claims" rather than as substantiated facts.

So, what do I believe? I believe the world is continuing to evolve. We have no idea what its ultimate fate will be, nor do we know our own. We should not be puzzling these questions if we cannot substantiate them through evidence. Conjecture is not certainty, and "truth claims" should not be accepted as fact.

We can only recognize patterns of desired behavior in the actual lives which have been and are being lived as demonstrations of how we should pattern our own lives and behavior. In the words which go beyond the claims of those ancient writers, we should "love mercy, do justice and live humbly," patterning our lives after the highest examples of human beings which history has laid before us.

http://www.syracuse.com/news/index.ssf?/base/news-1/1244278675274090.xml&coll=1

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 598
  • Angela's Avatar
    Posted by Angela Sun Jun 7, 2009 11:19pm PDT

    Hi Yogurt. I'm glad you posted this. It's an interesting piece. Slippery Rock isn't very far from where I live. I've known a lot of people who've gone there. It's not just a university; it's an actual place. McConnel's Mills is a state park on Slippery Rock Creek, and it's really beautiful there. If you're ever looking for a great place to visit in north western PA, that's definately a place to check out. Slippery Rock creek is so named because giant boulders line the creek all up and down each side and when the water rises, they become extremely slippery. It's beautiful, but dangerous. A lot of people have died there.

    Okay, thus concludes my tour guide section of my post. Hang on...I'll start another on topic post.

    Report Abuse
  • __A_YAHOO_USER__'s Avatar
    Posted by __A_YAHOO_USER__ Sun Jun 7, 2009 11:23pm PDT

    YoLo: It's been a long day of reading and editing. I'm going to stop back tomorrow so I can give your post the consideration I feel it deserves........Good night....Canis.

    Report Abuse
  • Angela's Avatar
    Posted by Angela Sun Jun 7, 2009 11:37pm PDT

    Okay, on topic...I both agree and disagree with this writer. I will have a lot more to say about this post when it's not so late. People here believe that I'm anti-religion and anti-faith, and I'm not. What I am against is people telling others what they MUST believe and how they MUST interpret not just the Bible, but all religious texts. I've had "Christians" refuse to acknowledge that other religious texts even exist, condemn me to he11 just for reading other holy books (and daring to call them "holy"), and for being educated about religions. We've all seen it enough times here to know that there's no reason to doubt that it's happened in my real life. I also know I'm not alone.

    I will stick to discussing the Bible since that's the topic. I agree with the author that the time that the Bible was written wasn't any more special or holy than now. And I have always agreed that the Bible was written by MEN with political power to control the powerless.

    However, I am not so jaded as to believe that there is not good to religion, especially to faith. Faith is the personal understanding and belief in religion or "God"--whatever someone thinks that is. The Bible is a work of literature. Although I'm sure some of the people who wrote it would have liked very much for it to have been interpreted literally, I don't think even the original authors ever expected that to fly. They knew they were compensating for knowledge they lacked. They knew they were taking from stories that had been passed down to them. They also knew that people are flawed. And besides, it's clear that a lot of people worked it. It contradicts itself again and again.

    Anyway, I thought I'd share just one little thing I wrote about Moses and Genesis for one of my Theology classes. It's just 2 paragraphs. It's about leadership ethics:

    "As I was rereading this book, I was reminded so strongly of the images from the Charleton Heston movie, The Ten Commandments. I specifically remember the images of debauchery when the Israelites began to doubt God and forget how their deliverance was made possible by Him. In my interview with Sr. Rita that I turned in for the previous assignment, she said that ethics was “right living.” So many times, Moses illustrates again and again examples of “right living” as he leads his people from slavery into freedom. Always, he subjugates himself before the Lord, never doubting His words, only doubting himself, humbling himself as a leader, questioning himself and his worthiness to lead and to speak to the people in the Lord’s stead.

    The granting of the Ten Commandments to Moses shows ethics in his leadership because they demonstrate that he is not unto the Israelites as Pharaoh was unto them. Moses answers to a higher authority than himself. Moses realizes that he is not a god on earth, but simply a man who must answer to God in Heaven, and he shows this before all his people by speaking God’s word and sharing the laws of God with his people."

    So, the thing is, what IS THE MESSAGE? The problem we keep having, not just on Shine, but in the world is that when it comes to religion, in this case, Christianity, most people don't agree on the message. And we're still killing people over that.

    Report Abuse
  • Angela's Avatar
    Posted by Angela Sun Jun 7, 2009 11:50pm PDT

    Sorry, I meant Exodus, not Genesis.

    Report Abuse
  • J Montana™'s Avatar
    Posted by J Montana™ Mon Jun 8, 2009 8:31am PDT

    Excellent Post, Yogi. I believe that there is a God.

    I do not how ever believe in organized religion. The Holier than thou Religion thing just ticks me off. I also agree with Angela. I am against people telling others that they Have to believe in their faith or they are going to heII.

    I do not believe I am naive in believing in the Christian faith.

    I am honoring My Mother and Father and the way I was raised.

    I do not go to church,Nor do I only Wear dresses, I dont do the No make -up and obstain from SEX and Television. I am not a hypocrit.

    I could not be a GOOD Christian. So I chose to be a Good Samaritan

    instead. I see Christians acting like hypocrits on a daily basis.

    I would rather be a sinner in good faith with God then A

    Christian who sins. Thank you for the Post. I respect your beliefs and I value your friendship.

    The Parable of the Good Samaritan is a New Testament parable appearing only in the Gospel of Luke.[1] (Also known as The Good Neighbour). The majority view indicates this parable is told by Jesus in order to illustrate that human kindness and fellow feeling must be available to all, and that fulfilling the spirit of the Law is just as important as fulfilling the letter of the Law, see also Letter and spirit of the law. Jesus puts the definition of neighbor into an enlarged context, beyond what people usually thought of as a neighbor.[2] See the minority view also.

    The parable

    The parable is found in the Gospel of Luke, chapter 10, verses 25-37.

    [the preceding context of the parable here]

    On one occasion an expert in the law stood up to say to Jesus. "Teacher," he asked, "what must I do to inherit eternal life?". "What is written in the Law?" he replied. "How do you read it?" asked Jesus. The man answered: " 'Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your strength and with all your mind' and, 'Love your neighbor as yourself.'" "You have answered correctly," Jesus replied. "Do this and you will live." But he wanted to justify himself, so he asked Jesus, "and who is my neighbor teacher?"

    [the parable starts here]

    In reply Jesus said:

    "A man was going down from Jerusalem to Jericho, when he fell into the hands of robbers. They stripped him of his clothes, beat him and went away, leaving him half dead with no clothes. A priest happened to be going down the same road, and when he saw the man, and he passed by on the other side. So too, a Levite, when he came to the place and saw him, he too passed by on the other side. But a Samaritan, as he traveled, came where the man was; and when he saw him, he took pity on him. He went to him and bandaged his wounds, pouring on oil and wine. Then he put the man on his own donkey, took him to an inn and looked after him. The next day he took out two silver coins and gave them to the innkeeper. 'Look after him,' he said, 'and when I return, I will reimburse you for any extra expense you may have.' "Which of these three do you think was a neighbour to the man who fell into the hands of robbers?" The expert in the law replied, "The one who had mercy on him." Jesus told him, "Go and do likewise."

    Samaritans were hated by the story's target audience, the Jews, to such a degree that the Lawyer did not mention them by name but as "The one who had mercy on him." The Samaritans in turn hated the Jews. The enmity was in essence religious: both groups accused each other of misinterpreting the Torah, of falsely considering themselves God's chosen people, and of conducting false worship, unacceptable to God.[citation needed] Thus the parable, as told originally, incorporated the current religious and ethnic tension to teach, "For I desired mercy, and not sacrifice: and the knowledge of God more than burnt sacrifice" (Hosea 6:6). But as the story reached those who were unaware of the oppression of the Samaritans, this aspect of the parable became less and less discernible: fewer and fewer people ever heard of them in any context other than as a description. Today the story is often recast in a more modern setting where the people are ones in equivalent social groups known to not interact comfortably[citation needed].

    Thus cast appropriately, the parable regains its message to modern listeners: namely, that an individual of a social group they disapprove of can exhibit moral behaviour that is superior to individuals of the groups they approve; it also means that not sharing the same faith is no excuse to behave poorly, as there is a universal moral law. Many Christians have used it as an example of Christianity's opposition to racial, ethnic and sectarian prejudice.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Good_Samaritan

    Report Abuse
  • Kenda's Avatar
    Posted by Kenda Mon Jun 8, 2009 9:55am PDT

    If I had to simply classify myself I would say I'm a Christian. I believe in Christ and that he died for my sins and in the Father God. I think I am more spiritual than religious. As a child, I followed closely what I was told in church, I believed as I was told. However, as I grew up and could discern and read for myself, my beliefs grew and changed. I have had some very disturbing situations in church and I don't go anymore. However, my relationship with God and Christ is still as strong as ever and growing. I can't really speak on others, and only myself. Believing in God and having faith gives me more than something to place blame on, be a victim to, or blindly follow. It gives me a purpose in life, if gives me comfort that there is something bigger than myself at work and I don't have to fear. I know God expects me to make mistakes therefore I don't have to be perfect. Yet I strive to be pleasing only in the eyesight of myself and Him. It gives me confidence that in following my heart is the right thing to do.

    Report Abuse
  • __A_YAHOO_USER__'s Avatar
    Posted by __A_YAHOO_USER__ Mon Jun 8, 2009 11:37am PDT

    Kenda, I feel the same way.

    If a saved person committed a sin and at that very moment he died and was not able to confess it to God...where will his soul go?

    When a saved person commits sin, that sin is already under the blood in reference to eternal life. Colossians 2:13 states, "And you, being dead in your sins and the uncircumcision of your flesh, hath he quickened together with him, having forgiven you all trespasses." All trespasses (or sins) have already been forgiven us. You see, before God saved you, He knew every sin you had ever committed but He also knew every sin you would commit. He gave you eternal life with that knowledge and forgave you of all your sins at that moment.

    This goes back to the method by which we are saved. God does not save us by giving us a clean slate that we now must keep cleaned up in order to make it to heaven. God saves us by making a switch. He puts our sin on Christ and He puts the righteousness of Christ on us. 2 Corinthians 5:21 says, "For he hath made him to be sin for us, who knew no sin; that we might be made the righteousness of God in him." Christ was made sin for us so that we might be made righteous in Him. [By the way, what if God only put your past sins on Christ? He would have to put each new sin on Him as you confessed it. Certainly, this did not happen. Christ paid the entire debt for sin on the cross. Each person who believes in Him enters into forgiveness through Him.]

    You may recall that the New Testament often speaks of the believer as being in Christ or in Him. You see, when the Father looks on us concerning our eternal condition, He does not see us as standing in our own righteousness, but in the righteousness of Christ. Concerning Christ, Paul said that he wanted to be "found in him, not having mine own righteousness, which is of the law, but that which is through the faith of Christ, the righteousness which is of God by faith" (Philippians 3:9). When we trust in Jesus Christ by faith, we are placed into Christ and are seen by the Father as having His righteousness.

    Now, you may ask, why do we need to ask for forgiveness of sins at all if they are all forgiven? The reason is that the present forgiveness of sins which we seek on a continuing basis deals with something entirely different from salvation. Though we are saved eternally by our position in Christ, we have a walking relationship with God in this life that is based on obedience and submission to His will. Even though we can never cease being saved, we can cease to be in a good present relationship with God.

    Let me give you an example. When my children were little, they would sometimes disobey me. I might even be angry with them and use some form of correction with them. However, there was nothing they could do, no matter how bad, that would make them cease to be my children. They were flesh of my flesh. To deny them would be to deny myself. Their family relationship to me was based on their birth (just as our eternal relationship to God is based on the new birth). Yet, they (just as us with God) could be my children and still not have all things right with me. They never ceased to be my children and I never had to make them my children a second time, but there were many times that we had to work out a right relationship that had gone sour. This is the way it is with God.

    So, I agree with what you said. God made us human. He knows we will continue to make mistakes, but because we have accepted Him as our Savior, we are forgiven. We just have to strive to keep a good relationship with Him.

    Yes, I follow the Bible. But the Bible is a book that is subject to interpretion. I also believe that is it also subject to change in relation to modern existence. The author of this article tends to believe that everyone's Christianity and faith is based on the Bible alone. Mine is based on the Bible, but also on the many miracles I have personally experienced in my own life,also, not just because it may have been my parents religion. I have researched other religions, so I am by no means, illiterate.

    As for whether we know for a fact that there is an afterlife....I KNOW there is...but I will not relate my own personal experience here to have it scrutinized and demeaned.

    Report Abuse
  • HurdyGurdyDibbleDabble's Avatar
    Posted by HurdyGurdyDibbleDabble Mon Jun 8, 2009 12:03pm PDT

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5GEhfzbX8lA

    I'm Catholic and will always be.

    I won't set here and say anyones going to hell for their actions, but you won't change my mind in what religion I choose, Or what goes along with that.

    We've all been on here long enough to respect others views whether or not we like what they say.

    We have a certain order in the church some people may not like..

    And the way I act on here may not be picture perfect of what a catholic may look like. That doesn't make me a hypocrite, that makes me a fun loving person.

    Because at the end of the day WHAT WE ALL WANT IS The SAME!! We should "love mercy, do justice and live humbly," patterning our lives after the highest examples of human beings which history has laid before us.

    Report Abuse
  • del (hot chick)'s Avatar
    Posted by del (hot chick) Mon Jun 8, 2009 1:30pm PDT

    wow you guys are getting deep! this is why its best not to bring up the topic so many views.

    power to all of ya. i believe in love.

    Report Abuse
  • Big Ron's Avatar
    Posted by Big Ron Mon Jun 8, 2009 1:38pm PDT

    Yogurt

    I believe and I respect...... I try and act out of love !!!

    That is what I feel the big message is ... Hugs Ron

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 598

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

manage your life byte

It shouldn’t cost more to live healthier.  Get the healthy items you need at Walmart, for less.