Manage Your Life

Tuesday, February 9, 2010

User post: Women are getting unhappier -- myth or fact?

by Karin Manske

1413564166_33d578bf35

1413564166_33d578bf35

I read an article on Huffington Post the other day that has been bothering me ever since: What’s Happening to Women’s Happiness by Marcus Buckingham. In the article Buckingham argues that women in the Western world are getting increasingly unhappier (he’s using research data from the past 40 years) while men are getting happier.

Now, I don’t know if Buckingham is using this as a clever marketing strategy to sell his book and seminars on personal development, but according to the data of research and surveys conducted across time and countries, the evidence seems to be there.

I also know that if you take a man and a woman and ask them how happy they are, the man will say he is happier than he really is and the woman will do the opposite. That’s part of how differently we approach the world: Women look for causes within themselves when confronted with an issue, while men will look for causes outside of themselves.

So, if you tell a woman that women all over the world are getting unhappier, she will immediately look inside to find evidence for this, while a man will most likely say “Show me” or, “If that’s true, I know it’s not happening to me.”

After mulling the whole thing over in my own head for a few days I have come to this: It’s not up to someone or anyone to just stroll along with a few smart graphs and statistics to tell us how happy or unhappy we are, it’s up to us. It’s time that we take responsibility for our own happiness.

Do I believe that women lose their happiness when they get older? I think that each of us has to answer that for herself. However, there are a few interesting trends that I have observed in working with women that I want to share with you. These are my initial thoughts on the topic and I’d love to hear what your experiences are.

While most men define themselves by their accomplishment, many women have learned to define themselves by their beauty: Can you see the dilemma right here? While a man’s accomplishments increase when he gets older, a woman’s beauty fades, or lets say, changes with age.

I think women have a natural affinity for beauty. We like to make things beautiful, look beautiful, help others to look beautiful, etc. Unfortunately, the media, advertising agencies and the fashion industry are ruthlessly taking advantage of this love for beauty by putting it in a competitive context: I received a mailing the other day selling rejuvenation treatments with slogans like ‘Stay Young & Competitive’, ‘Conquer the Competition’ and ‘Move up to Management’.

This obsession with looking young has lead many women to neglect their inner beauty. While looking good on the outside can be a lot of fun, it is devastating if it’s all there is. It will keep us from looking within to find out what it is we deeply love about ourselves: Our gifts, our values and our unique female strengths. Because deep down we all know, there is nothing more attractive than a woman who knows her values and is kind, passionate, and, happy in her own skin.

Another trend I have observed is the lack of community among women: Women relax by communicating with other women (as shown in a landmark UCLA study on friendship among women). Have you ever listened to a group of women happily talking among themselves, laughing, giggling and having a good time? It’s delightful! It’s like listening to the joyful cheers of happy kids playing on the playground.

Women listen in a way that is nurturing and receptive. We comfort each other by telling stories, by laughing, crying and having a community of like minded friends. A lot of times this is missing in our day-to-day lives and while we are getting more accomplished in our careers, and more competitive with each other, we also lose our connections.

This brings up another point, competition, and how it is hurting women: Competition among women is not in our nature, yet it is something we are doing in all areas of life. For men, competing is part of the game and they do it often and for fun. I overheard two little boys at the beach the other day talking to each other while munching on some sandwiches: “Did you know that Michael Jackson died?” asked one the other. “Yes, I found out the minute he died,” was the response. “And I found out the second he died!”

For women, competing does not come as natural. We like to tell stories and share experiences. When we compete we separate ourselves from other women which leads to isolation, not only in business but also in our private lives. If we start collaborating more, we will be able to build strong connections and help each other in getting what we want.

Maybe it’s time we get more courageous about adapting the existing rules to what we need to be happy. Maybe working hard and being competitive is fun for men, while for women taking breaks, having time to relax and talking to other women is what helps us to recharge our batteries.

How about you? Would your life change if you put happiness first? Dare to try out what works for you and put it into action.

——————

Do you want to find out what lights you up? Take our ‘What Lights You Up - Questionnaire’

Photo Source: Flowereye via Flickr under a Creative Commons License

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 38
  • Super Abuelita's Avatar
    Posted by Super Abuelita Wed Sep 23, 2009 11:25am PDT

    Choices, is what I think about. Do I look at the glass "half empty" or "half full?"

    Regardless, of what has happened to me, either good or bad, I choose to be happy.

    I learn from the bad and cherish the good.

    It's all how one perceives things.

    Report Abuse
  • Patriot's Avatar
    Posted by Patriot Wed Sep 23, 2009 11:41am PDT

    Well from a male perspective, Women have persued the right to equality to the point that it has hardened society to the simple sweet frailtied that women posses. Things that I think are beautiful qualities have been deminished in alot of women especialy single women as now they have to try and compete on the same level. As you say women are not natural competetors, more nurtures and compassion driven as a whole. For women to have to put that aside and persue a more driven lifestyle I believe has had an enormous effect. I will be more than happy to kill all the spiders as long as you guys stay just so sweet and wonderful as you can be. Just my thoughts.

    Don't be afraid to be women we love you for it. I know I do

    Patriot

    Report Abuse
  • ShawnnaB's Avatar
    Posted by ShawnnaB Fri Sep 25, 2009 7:55am PDT

    its hard to feel comfortable in my own skin, since i know that the only thing most people look at is my appearance. but yes we all must strive to enjoy ourselves to the fullest, i am going to try harder to enjoy myself and to feel comfortable, but its going to be difficult :)

    Report Abuse
  • Mauna's Avatar
    Posted by Mauna Fri Sep 25, 2009 8:00am PDT

    I know the women who would be unhappy are the ones who are suppressed and repressed from there utmost desires of what they would find fulfilling in the department of success and talent in order for them to express their own brilliance and creativity from their soul. However, more piled on expections that are usually due to their own external surroundings who fail to do their fair share of participations in....can also make women very unhappy and feel like nothing more, but that of a MACHINE who will some day wake up telling herself...What the hell I am here for and why am I doing this?

    Report Abuse
  • cindy's Avatar
    Posted by cindy Fri Sep 25, 2009 8:12am PDT

    It is hard for me to make friends and feel welcome with a group of women. I don't have any close friends and like I go on here and post a comment, other women attack your opinion. We dont support each other, we are very judgemental and catty. It seems to be getting worse and you see the shows like Desperate Housewives, where women smile in your face but sleep with your husband and gossip behind your back. That is very close to reality, because i have worked with all women for the past 5 yrs and that is how it is. I cant even be friends with people at work because of the cattiness.

    Report Abuse
  • M22's Avatar
    Posted by M22 Fri Sep 25, 2009 8:59am PDT

    Simple. Hollywood. Women are getting more scandalous and naked and women are getting more selfconscious and worthless.

    Report Abuse
  • M22's Avatar
    Posted by M22 Fri Sep 25, 2009 8:59am PDT

    Women on tv I mean, compared to real life women that still have values...and morals.

    Report Abuse
  • Carolyn's Avatar
    Posted by Carolyn Fri Sep 25, 2009 9:12am PDT

    Remember when women used to get together to quilt, sew, break beans, peel apples, make candy and pies, put up(can)100's of jars of vegetables, juice and fruit? All the while, our kids were playing together, making lifelong friendships. We women were trading information about everything from what stores were having the best sales to the argument they had with their husband last night, the bright spot was exchanging sexual information. No, not about what went on in bed with their husbands, that was secret. I'm talking about sex in general. And all aspects of life in general. Somehow, women could "guage" themselves, the care they took with their children,their homelife, husbands, in-laws...everything. (Not that they actually believed everything said, but it did put them in the ballfield of what was going on.) If one woman was having a very personal problem she could pick the (in her opinion) most trusted and "air" her feelings, maybe have a good cry and come out understanding what was actually going on and how to better the situation. In my case, my life would be completely different (I believe) if women still got together in way's other than card games. I would have had that friend I trusted so I could "air out" my secret problems. Others see you when you can't see yourself. Too late I learned that mental disease is a stealth killer of lives, homes, families, feelings, love. There are many problems that we all face alone which could be solved if we could quilt, cook, bake...and talk together again. OH, by the way....same goes for you men. Thanks for listening. :)

    Report Abuse
  • Tara's Avatar
    Posted by Tara Fri Sep 25, 2009 10:00am PDT

    Only in the past few years have I began considering my happiness when making a decision and I am extremely happy because of it. Up until that time I always did what was needed or expected of me and that can become horribly frustrating. I think women have trouble with their happiness sometimes because of an inborn need to please and yes most of us do that. There comes a time when you want nothing more than to please yourself so when that time comes embrace it and be happy.

    Report Abuse
  • Karin Manske's Avatar
    Posted by Karin Manske Fri Sep 25, 2009 10:21am PDT

    Wow, thank you for your interesting comments! There really seems to be a big need for women to have community (and yes, I, too remember the times when my kids were little and were able to play in the street until dark. This was in a small German town, but nevertheless).

    I think it's time for women to take responsibility for our happiness and do the things that make us happy rather than what we think we should be doing or what others expect of us. We may be surprised to find out that the world wants us to be happy, too.

    Make time for friendships, have your girl friends over for coffee or tea and talk, knit, bake, or, do business together, help each other make money, etc.

    All the best! ~Karin

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 38

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

manage your life byte

It shouldn’t cost more to live healthier.  Get the healthy items you need at Walmart, for less.