Celebrity dating pools: Which stars you’re convinced you could or couldn’t be with

Dave M. Benett and Stephen Shugerman/Getty Images

Dave M. Benett and Stephen Shugerman/Getty Images

Upon my obligatory gossip reading for my job, I somehow end up submerged in this world of celebrities. I constantly read about and interview stars and envision myself amongst them. Like every one of you, I’ve had my celebrity crushes, and perhaps I’m delusional or maybe just a bit silly, but I’ve several time convinced myself that given the right circumstances I could befriend or even date some of them.

The biggest one being James Franco. Though now infinitely more famous for his portrayals of a stoner in “Pineapple Express” and Harvey Milk’s lover in “Milk,” I interviewed James Franco several years ago in a small press event for a movie of his called “Flyboys” and sat next to him for 30 minutes and daydreamed about how I could, while still being professional, give him my number, scrawled on the back of my business card. We had some witty banter, I grew increasingly smitten, and he was whisked away by as publicist about 30 seconds after I asked my embarrassing last question: Was he dating anyone. The answer was no and he giggled. (Swoon)

He seemed so accessible and funny and smart and like a normal guy  around my age that I’d date! There were about six other reporters in the room, and several of them commented on how we were flirting. But I couldn’t even rejoice: I knew I’d never get my chance again.

Before you think I’m totally bonkers, can I attempt to convince you I’m not and am happy in a relationship with a non-celeb?

Moving on. My biggest Hollywood crush has been Leonardo DiCaprio for many years. Besides being a talented and handsome actor, he’s always come across as very intelligent to me and I love how much he actively cares about the environment. I loved that he became buddies with Al Gore and my all-time favorite director Martin Scorsese. What a catch he is!

But you know what I finally realized today? I could never be with Leo. Why? His girlfriend, Bar Refaeli, is on the cover of the Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Issue. And she’s freaking gorgeous. His dating a model though isn’t a fluke. His last long tern girlfriend was supermodel Gisele Bundchen, who uh, also was on the cover of the Swimsuit Issue. Okay, so he dates stunning and successful models. I’m out of his dating pool. I’ll just consider this one strike against him.

Am I alone here? Have you ever read about a celebrity and thought, given the right opportunity, that you would be right for each other? Or maybe that you wouldn’t stand a chance? Tell me all about your famous crushes below!
 
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 11-20 of 66
  • Holly J's Avatar
    Posted by Holly J Wed Feb 11, 2009 11:46am PST

    Shia LeBouf, Jake Gyllenhal (sp).

    Report Abuse
  • Mar's Avatar
    Posted by Mar Wed Feb 11, 2009 12:37pm PST

    *sigh* Most of the cast of Milk: Diego Luna, Emile Hirsch and James Franco.

    Report Abuse
  • lily-rose's Avatar
    Posted by lily-rose Wed Feb 11, 2009 12:38pm PST

    i've had a crush on Orlando Bloom since the first time i saw him in the lord of the rigs...he dated Kate Bosworth, now he's with a victoria's secret model

    i guess i have to chance! lol

    Report Abuse
  • The Colonel's Avatar
    Posted by The Colonel Wed Feb 11, 2009 1:34pm PST

    I would love to be with Robert Carlyle. But he's happily married and has a family. Lucky LUCKY woman. Hmmph! lol!

    Report Abuse
  • Carmen's Avatar
    Posted by Carmen Wed Feb 11, 2009 2:08pm PST

    HAHAHA to CJ - I totally hear where you're coming from. Jason Segel is totally rad. I have a huge nerd-crush on Jay Baruchel myself.

    And I love that twentytwenty mentioned Mos Def - he seems like the coolest human being alive.

    James Franco is definitely tops of the list. He seems really decent and easy-going. Who hasn't watched Freaks and Geeks and swooned over Daniel Desario at some point??

    I think all the guys in the Apatow crew (even though most of them are married or dating) seem really accesible and attainable.

    I'm gonna throw Zachary Quinto on there too just because I also have a major nerd-crush on him too, haha.

    Report Abuse
  • Suicidal Dream's Avatar
    Posted by Suicidal Dream Wed Feb 11, 2009 2:52pm PST

    besides johnny depp (omg, what a beautiful sight!), i have always had a thing for gary oldman and robert downey jr.

    totally.

    Report Abuse
  • Joanna Douglas, Shine Staff's Avatar
    Posted by Joanna Douglas, Shine Staff Wed Feb 11, 2009 3:00pm PST

    Carmen- I totally agree! And I LOVE Zachary Quinto aka Sylar mostly because of his character on "Heroes." Another TV crush of mine is Matthew Fox... I love seeing him take charge on "Lost." :)

    Report Abuse
  • Sharon's Avatar
    Posted by Sharon Wed Feb 11, 2009 3:03pm PST

    There's only one man I dream about day and night... every thing about him makes my heart do all sorts of weird things. His eyes, his curls, his face, his sense of humor, his laugh, his heart...just everything!!! But especially his VOICE... I hear his voice and picture his face and I melt.. his name is Josh Groban.

    Report Abuse
  • Noe1's Avatar
    Posted by Noe1 Wed Feb 11, 2009 4:13pm PST

    My biggest Celeb crush was several years back...Jim Carrey. He seems like he would be a nice guy and well you just have to love a guy that's funny! Granted I realized it would never happen because honestly how many stories have you heard of a Celebrity of any stature dating common people?... It just does not happen, they stick with their own, people in the rich and famous circles, people who they can trust are in for them not for their status. But for me it's ok, I still get hollywood crushes, and dream of what that life would be like...But also realize that reality will never let it happen.

    Report Abuse
  • CamilleW's Avatar
    Posted by CamilleW Wed Feb 11, 2009 4:46pm PST

    I've had a crush on Dean Cain since I was 8!

    he seems like such a great guy.

    I'm also hopelessly devoted to Milo Ventimiglia, Josh Brolin, Jason Behr, Ryan Reynolds (all for years) and most recently Jason Statham =)

    *le sigh

    Report Abuse
Comments 11-20 of 66

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Health Byte

Tune in to our fitness forecast! These are the top ten exercise trends for 2010.