Sunday, November 29, 2009

Fake vs. real materials: The pros and cons

Annie Schlecter

Annie Schlecter

Use this guide to decide when to go natural and when to choose the new synthetics.

Upholstery

Pleather

What it is: Components of plastic PVC (yes, the kind used in pipes) stretched very thin and coated onto a woven backing.
What it costs: About $35 to $100 a yard.
Pros: Tough and stain-resistant, plastic leather is shedding its tacky rep, and new versions have more aesthetic appeal.
Cons: Vinyl and other synthetics feel hot in summer, and most don't age gracefully. When pleather finally shows wear (which, in high-end versions, could take decades), it cracks.

Leather

What it is: Animal skins and hides tanned in a chemical stew, stretched, and stained.
What it costs: About $250 to $500 a hide.
Pros: It develops an alluring luster as it ages. Since it's a natural product, it breathes and feels cooler than vinyl.
Cons: It scratches and stains easily and is hard to clean. You can find products that claim to remove spots, but often only a pro can give you good results.

Learn How to Organize Home Décor Samples at Real Simple.

Curtain Fabric

Polyester

What it is: A petroleum product spun into yarn.
What it costs: About $20 to $50 a yard.
Pros: The name may be synonymous with leisure suits from the 70s, but new polyester fabrics can be satiny and luxurious. The material is slow to fade and typically doesn't need ironing.
Cons: It stains more easily than natural fibers and may require pretreatment with a stain remover or dry cleaning. Polyester often hangs more stiffly than natural fabrics.

Cotton

What it is: A natural fiber derived from a seedpod.
What it costs: About $30 to $60 a yard.
Pros: It has a natural, soft look that drapes well. "And it's been around since the beginning of time," says Steffany Hollingsworth, an interior designer in Santa Fe, so it works in any setting, from traditional to modern. Generally, it can go right into the washing machine.
Cons: It fades and wears out faster than many synthetics.

Floorboards

Laminate

What it is: Planks made of resin, ground wood, and paper, then printed with a wood grain or some other natural design.
What it costs: About $1 to $6 a square foot.
Pros: Snap the planks into place and you're done. The latest laminates look more like wood than ever before and resist scratching. Dog claws? Stiletto heels? No problem.
Cons: It can't be refinished with, say, a different stain. Aesthetically, it lacks the wow value of genuine wood.

Wood

What it is: Planks or strips cut from trees.
What it costs: About $4 to $20 a square foot.
Pros: It gives a bit, making it pleasant underfoot. It is beautiful and warms up a room, and over time it can be resanded to restore the original sheen.
Cons: It should be professionally installed and topped with polyurethane (or stained and regularly waxed) to prevent damage from household attackers, like grit and grime.

Annie Schlecter

Annie Schlecter

Carpeting

Nylon

What it is: A petroleum product liquefied and forced through small holes to form strands that are twisted together.
What it costs: About $20 to $75 a square yard.
Pros: "You can set a heavy desk on nylon for five years," says Odette Lueck, an interior designer in Oakland, Maryland, "and the carpet will pop right back up when you move it."
Cons: Nylon carpet can look and feel stiff; when you walk on it barefoot, you won't think "freshly mowed lawn."

Wool

What it is: Sheep's fur spun into yarn and woven or pulled through a backing to make tufts.
What it costs: About $30 to $130 a square yard.
Pros: Because it's a natural fiber, it absorbs dye readily, so "you get richer colors" than with nylon, says Wes Connelly, a wool-industry expert in Atlanta. Wool is also softer than most synthetic yarns and doesn't show wear as readily as nylon does.
Cons: Professional cleaning is usually required.

Countertops

Corian

What it is: A blend of acrylic polymers, minerals, and pigments bonded together to look like stone.
What it costs: $45 to $75 a square foot.
Pros: It comes in many colors and patterns and stands up to all kinds of abuse. It is sturdy, doesn't stain, and lasts a lifetime. Scratches and burns can be buffed out.
Cons: It has to be installed by a certified expert. It looks a bit artificial, and don't expect it to gain character over time.

Marble

What it is: Dense crystallized limestone.
What it costs: $65 to $95 a square foot.
Pros: It's gorgeous. It comes in a number of colors, and no two slabs are alike. Its naturally cool surface is great for rolling out pastry dough. Over time it develops a pleasing patina.
Cons: It's delicate; the edges can chip. The surface is porous, so wipe that red-wine ring away quickly. A sealant must be applied periodically to prevent staining and dullness.

From Real Simple: Tips for Choosing a Paint Color

Flooring

Vinyl

What it is: A plastic composite stamped with a pattern to resemble stone, wood, clay, or some other natural material.
What it costs: 50 cents to $6 a square foot for tile or sheet flooring.
Pros: Today's vinyl tile is of a high quality; it resists scratching, gouging, and dents, yet it's softer than ceramic tile. Drop a glass and it may very well survive the fall.
Cons: No one will mistake it for a natural material.

Ceramic

What it is: Clay pressed into squares, sometimes glazed, and fired at high temperatures.
What it costs: About $3 to $10 a square foot.
Pros: "It's more durable than vinyl, hands down," says Michael Nagel, chair of the National Association of Home Builders Remodelers. Easy to clean, it comes in many colors and styles.
Cons: Installation often requires a pro. It's cold and hard on the feet. Drop that glass and it will smash.

More from Real Simple:
Solve 9 Fashion Emergencies
How to Wash Cashmere
The Best Throw Pillows

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1 of 1
  • Rose's Avatar
    Posted by Rose Thu Feb 12, 2009 12:17pm PST

    I have PERGO laminate floors that look like wood and I LOVE them.

    My kids like to hide their messes or tell me about them a couple of days later. I've found dried up kool aid and milk on my floors, wiped them away with a damp cloth and it still looks the same.

    Since my kids are all under the age of 5, I believe this to be the perfect flooring for families with kids and it DOES look GREAT.

    My house came with Corian and I am not disappointed. I would have preferred granite. I agree that it is heavy duty and looks nicer than laminate countertops. But it does miss the 'Wow!' factor as compared to granite. For now, I'll keep my Corian.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1 of 1

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Health Byte

Who doesn't want to look hot at all those holiday parties? ExerciseTV shares how to get in skinny jeans-shape -- and quickly!