Sunday, November 29, 2009

Giving Good Advice

I'm always looking for ways to foster a climate of engaging and constructive conversation on Shine, so I was very excited when I stumbled on an Allure Magazine article called "How to Give Good Advice". In the article, NY Times columnist Randy Cohen (aka "The Ethicist") offers 6 quick tips on giving advice, and while they may not radically change the way you comment on Shine posts, I hope you'll consider them the next time you bestow your sage wisdom. :-)

These were my personal favorites:
 
Tip # 3 – “Keep it to yourself. While it is tempting to launch into a personal anecdote, that changes the subject to you – and that’s not what empathy is all about.”

Tip # 5 – “Be kind. Being honest doesn’t excuse a lack of tact, so be careful not to insult someone, even if you’ve chosen to say something tough. Keep your thoughts focused on the issue, not on the person.”

On a related note, for a long time now I’ve been impressed by Shine users “Lizbeth” and “B E L L O V E D 21”. Whether they agree with the subject matter and user opinions or not, they always keep their comments honest, helpful, and respectful. I found two recent comments from each user that demonstrate that it is possible to disagree without resorting to hurtful comments. Don't forget - constructive comments will always get you further than negativity. Thanks ladies!

Lizbeth's comment on "The Myth About Exercise May be That it Doesn't Work"

"I've read many responses and I agree with the other women; the article is very skewed and harmful to the public, fitness is an individual thing and exercise should be part of our lives for health and well being.The problem is we're all so compulsive and entitled and exhausted, that we think hard work should equal "gimme, gimme, gimme"; why do we all feel so empty? The picture on the cover says it all; we only do work while thinking of the reward, as opposed to simply doing it and seeing the act itself as pleasureable; like loving your spouse, spending time with your kids, doing a favor for a friend,...doing any of these things and feeling fulfilled by the act of giving/doing as opposed to feeling FILLED from a Big Mac or 3 glasses of wine.There just seems to be a major void within people these days...maybe it's always been there, and before food we filled it with other forms of debauchery, throughout history. Now instead of chasing the dragon, we chase The Burger King, on our treadmills.

I think Time should be ashamed, this article is going to discourage lots of people who are struggling with their wieght and have comitted themselves to the gym (I have two friends right now who've been busting their butts at the gym, but they both admit it's their diets that haven't changed much)4-4=0+8 still equals 8 and eating 600 calories from two slices of pizza is a far cry from eating 600 calories from celery and apples.

Don't eat food that comes in boxes, burn 500 calories per workout 5-6 times a week, strength train for 30 minutes 4 times a week, eat 1800 calories a day and limit your 'cheat meals' to 2 per week. You'll get lean and you'll stay healthy.

All this craziness. If all else fails see a shrink."


B E L L O V E D 21's comment on "What Makes A Guy Creepy?"

"Wow, Amazing how some people think this is superficial, then way too deep, then way into the woods or shoe on the other foot. I think that if something bothers you about someone else you should first and foremost check before you project. Creepy is a two way street, are you creeped out because of thier behavior or is it because YOU have a problem with it, if you do, communicate that dislike and either tolerate it or get out of the creepy situation. It is funny how we blame the other person for just being themselves when in actuality it is bothering US, if you really dont care about something then 20 guys could stare at every inch of you and you would be like, oh, what-ever. and creepy interpretation is more what we are experiencing. We do not have to interpret everything as creepy. Although I have had the in your face when you wake up, and standing outside of your place or your car experiences, if the person is not killing you then quit worrying :D There are too many hateful things out there, admiration, even the creepy kind, is kinda cool."

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 118
  • J Montana™'s Avatar
    Posted by J Montana™ Wed Aug 12, 2009 8:28pm PDT

    Brenda,

    Thank you so much for the tips on how to give advice. I will certain take them into consideration. I know it is hard at times to be nice. I have been guilty of losing my temper on a few occasions.

    Report Abuse
  • RIVER's Avatar
    Posted by RIVER Wed Aug 12, 2009 10:43pm PDT

    Hi Brenda..Just wanted to take a minute and thank you for your support on PEACE DAY..It means alot to me..

    I also appreciate the tips you give in this post..

    we are all here to help and support one another the Shine way..we are just people trying to live our lives the best we can eh?

    river

    Report Abuse
  • kim r's Avatar
    Posted by kim r Thu Aug 13, 2009 6:56am PDT

    http://shine.yahoo.com/channel/life/please-take-the-mint-for-me-by-kimr-500557/

    Report Abuse
  • IRISH's Avatar
    Posted by IRISH Thu Aug 13, 2009 8:35am PDT

    Dear Brenda,

    Thank you for bringing us this information. One of the things I enjoy most about Shine,are the positive advise and cheerful anecdotes!!! I enjoy my daily "fix"

    Report Abuse
  • Brenda, Shine Community Manager's Avatar
    Posted by Brenda, Shine Community Manager Thu Aug 13, 2009 9:08am PDT

    Hi Ladies,

    Thanks so much for stopping by! As always, I appreciate your kind words and support. A little positivity goes a long way in this Community. Let's hear it for our Shine "regulars"...Wooo hooo :)

    Report Abuse
  • Katie B's Avatar
    Posted by Katie B Thu Aug 13, 2009 10:28am PDT

    Hmm... I never thought about keeping it to myself... I am very guilty of giving anecdotes when giving advise... In my mind I think that it shows the person that I have been in a similar situation and understand what they are going through... *shrugs*

    Report Abuse
  • kim r's Avatar
    Posted by kim r Thu Aug 13, 2009 10:37am PDT

    Thanks Brenda!

    I am flying out in October. I will keep your advise in mind, just in case.

    Report Abuse
  • BrokenHeartedGirl.com's Avatar
    Posted by BrokenHeartedGirl.com Thu Aug 13, 2009 12:26pm PDT

    This is a great article. I will have to check out Allure.

    But I think when you're dealing with a breakup and people are giving advice, it actually helps to hear another person's anecdotes. It kind of helps you realize that you're not all alone. And whatever you're feeling has been felt before.

    Report Abuse
  • Brenda, Shine Community Manager's Avatar
    Posted by Brenda, Shine Community Manager Thu Aug 13, 2009 1:27pm PDT

    Your're so right, Katie & BrokenHeartedGirl! It definitely helps to hear a friend's experiences - especially when it comes to relationship problems!

    I think Randy was just suggesting that we're careful to not let our own tales steer the attention away from the one whose really asking for advice. :)

    Report Abuse
  • M.J - Fierce Beauty and Fashion's Avatar
    Posted by M.J - Fierce Beauty and Fashion Thu Aug 13, 2009 5:25pm PDT

    I definitely liked this post Brenda! A good reminder to keep things positive! We are all here to learn and grow from one another and its real easy to lose sight of that! Thanks for bringing it all into focus! :)

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 118

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Updates Chatter on Shine…

Health Byte

Who doesn't want to look hot at all those holiday parties? ExerciseTV shares how to get in skinny jeans-shape -- and quickly!