Tuesday, February 9, 2010

Is There Racism in Star Trek?


This is a question I am asking to everyone, not just "sci-fi" buffs, IS there racism in Star Trek?
My point is while the Universe of Star Trek preaches tolerance and harmony among it's many different human and alien cultures in the show and prejudice and bigotry are a thing of the past,and In the fictional Organization of Starfleet there are Black,White,Female and ALIEN(male and female), commanding officers, (i.e. Captains and Admirals)
In Reality, for 3 seasons during the run of Deep Space Nine, Captain Benjamin Sisko (played by Avery Brooks) was a COMMANDER!











Captain James T. Kirk

























and Young James T. Kirk


























Captain Jean Luc Picard























Captain(later,Vice Admiral)Kathryn Janeway


  


















                                                            
Captain Jonathan Archer







I know what you are going to say: "No Way!"
but follow me here, I mean he made Captain eventually, but why was he a Commander for the first 3 seasons?
Were the powers that be(i.e. writers,producers,studio execs) at Paramount not too sure of how the "StarTrek" Audience would react to a "Black Captain"?
Also, during his commander days, he was STILL obviously the HEAD of the Space Station in the show, and the pics of the other 4 captains? They were all CAPTAINS from the first episode of their respective series until each went off the air.
Hmmmm, What do other 4 captains have in common?
I also find that an episode entitled "Far Beyond the Stars" has strange parallels the Reality of the situation
Here is the Plot:

"In the episode "Far Beyond the Stars"", Sisko considers resigning his commission after losing an old friend during the Dominion War and the Prophets intervene making Sisko briefly live the life of "Benny Russell", a science fiction short story writer in 1950s America . Every day, Russell faces the prejudices of his world - his publisher does not even allow his photograph to be printed. Russell writes a story called "Deep Space Nine" that takes place in a universe without prejudice and bigotry. However, his publisher refuses to release the story because he makes the commander of the space station a black man. This injustice eventually drives Benny insane; and soon after, Sisko finds himself back in the 24th century, understanding his place is aboard the station but questioning the nature of reality."
______________________________________________________________________________________

Now, with that being said, even though all shows have been off the air for some time, I have been pondering that question for a long time, and DS9 to me, is the BEST Star Trek series, hands down, and it's NOT Because "The Captain was Black", the whole show had some of the best writing, storylines and action scenes out of the whole franchise,  there were episodes not even centered around the captain that were  the BOMB!
So, my question is:Did they make Avery Brooks' character a "commander" because they did not know how the trek audience would react to a black Captain?
______________________________________________________________________________________
Starfleet Rank and Insignia are listed below to give you a clue:

Captain                    Commander      Lt.Commander       Lieutenant      Lieutenant Jr.Grade       Ensign




So....Am I wrong?
or just being silly?
Tell me Shiners, Do you think there is racism in Star Trek?
What do you think?
You DON'T have to be "into"  Star Trek to answer this question, just give your honest opinion based on what I said.
peace
V
                                                                                                                                                 
     
                                           
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 69
  • m@r!@'s Avatar
    Posted by m@r!@ Wed Jul 22, 2009 3:59am PDT

    HI Valiant ~ Sorry I've been MIA for a bit (again). I just can't get time on this computer with all these kiddiez! How are ya hon?

    P.S. I don't watch ST so I can't comment. Sorry dude...

    Report Abuse
  • MELISSA's Avatar
    Posted by MELISSA Wed Jul 22, 2009 5:27am PDT

    AHH HUH ! DARK HAIR AND DARK EYES???HMMMMMMM LOL..... WOHOOOO !!!

    Report Abuse
  • m@r!@'s Avatar
    Posted by m@r!@ Wed Jul 22, 2009 5:38am PDT

    Not much shakin here 'cept my b00tie :D

    How's everything? How's my Pepper girl?! :oP

    Report Abuse
  • m@r!@'s Avatar
    Posted by m@r!@ Wed Jul 22, 2009 5:44am PDT

    P.S. I see our friend Ash is STILL at it LOL!

    Report Abuse
  • simfelicity's Avatar
    Posted by simfelicity Wed Jul 22, 2009 5:59am PDT

    yes there is....racism is evrywhere.....

    Report Abuse
  • wildchild's Avatar
    Posted by wildchild Wed Jul 22, 2009 6:05am PDT

    I really just wanted to say that's it's so good to see some of the friend's i started out knowing to begin with. So many new folk's which is wonderful, but like to see my old family. Have a great day friend.

    Report Abuse
  • m@r!@'s Avatar
    Posted by m@r!@ Wed Jul 22, 2009 6:06am PDT

    Let's hope he scores one of these days. m@r!@ is getting annoyed by his desperation LOL!

    I have a new venting blog up. Waiting to see your new one...

    Report Abuse
  • m@r!@'s Avatar
    Posted by m@r!@ Wed Jul 22, 2009 7:27am PDT

    I saw your comment on Apple's post. Good looks obviously run in your family :D

    Speaking of her post, she got herself a hater. What is UP with people??? Why does someone always have to jump in with their negativity? :(

    Report Abuse
  • *GoldenGirl*™'s Avatar
    Posted by *GoldenGirl*™ Wed Jul 22, 2009 7:36am PDT

    Good Morning! Thanks for the comment. Have a awesome day :)

    Report Abuse
  • MELISSA's Avatar
    Posted by MELISSA Wed Jul 22, 2009 7:52am PDT

    ha ha haha!! SCORE !!!!

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 69

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Health Byte

When you need to rehydrate, do you grab a Gatorade or automatically reach for a soda? We weigh the pros and cons of each drink.