Reality shows with bad messages—MTV’s “Model Maker” joins in

AP

AP

As long-time viewers of "America's Next Top Model," we know that weight is an important factor in the modeling biz, but MTV's upcoming "Model Maker" is making it the focal point of the show. Their casting site states:

"We want to make you a model. Are you up for the challenge?

"Women come in all shapes and sizes, but models don't.The term model conjures an image of stick-thin, towering beauties oozing confidence, glamour, poise and sexuality from every pore.

“ 'Skinny,' 'no body fat,' and 'size zero' are the words and phrases associated with models. 'Chubby,' 'well-fed,' and 'big- boned' are not…”

The casting call asks for women who are between the ages of 17 and 24, 5'9" to 6' tall, and 130 to 190 pounds all of whom the industry would likely now call "plus size." Is glorifying rapid weight loss on young women whom perhaps aren't natural model types sending a bad message to the young and often preteen audience of MTV?

Self-aggrandizing celebrity reality shows can easily be dismissed as lightweight television or disposable garbage, but plot-driven reality shows set to deliver a message tend to struggle. And "Model Maker" is far from the first of its kind! We're not sure who has given the green light to obviously offensive programs ("The Littlest Groom" or "My Big Fat Obnoxious Boss" for example), but the following reality shows, among others, really bother us.

"Temptation Island"
Couples are sent off to an island with dozens of hotties who deliberately test the strength of their fidelity. A totally unrealistic scenario full of potential cheaters. No thank you.

"Who Wants To Marry A Multi-Millionaire?"
We get an icky feeling watching two strangers become engaged on "The Bachelor," but this show, driven solely by money, is even more unnerving.

"Moment of Truth"
Contestants win up to $500,000 if they answer questions correctly according to a polygraph test, such as if they find their husband less attractive since he went bald. Oh and their friends and family are present at the time. Sometimes little white lies are a good thing.

"The Swan"
People who have always felt badly about their appearance get an extreme makeover with multiple plastic surgeries performed only to receive praise by the show's host and their family and friends who can now barely recognize them and encourage viewers to alter their bodies for gratification.

"The Bad Girls Club"
Are you a crazy woman who disrespects her closest friends, has no morals and craves constant attention? You too can have your moment of TV fame.

"Baby Borrowers"
In an attempt to prevent the next Juno, this show forces adolescent couples to care for newborn infants as a lesson in abstinence.

"Exiled!"
Another new MTV show where the ladies of "My Super Sweet 16" are sent by their fed-up parents to foreign countries for a crash course in cultural experience and charity work as punishment. We're not feeling it. Plus we know these whiny brats will probably get a $30,000 welcome home party hosted by Diddy.

Which reality show really bothers you? [Jossip][NY Times]
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 11-20 of 372
  • Malika Harris's Avatar
    Posted by Malika Harris Tue Aug 26, 2008 8:11am PDT

    I'm a Model so what, why are people so obsessed with Models? why why why? its a job like any other if not harder, it has a shorter lifespan and requires way more dicipline however, they should take that stupid show off the TV if they are tryin got make all these people lose weight and get sick I mean NOT everybody's meant to model they should do something else, its not worth it!

    Report Abuse
  • Geri's Avatar
    Posted by Geri Tue Aug 26, 2008 8:12am PDT

    I don't watch them because I'm embarrassed for the people, but one I caught last night at the behest of my cousin, who is getting married in 2 months was 'Bridezillas.' That show was absolutely terrible, the women were crazy & I totally pitied their husbands-to-be.

    Report Abuse
  • Mmgirl's Avatar
    Posted by Mmgirl Tue Aug 26, 2008 8:31am PDT

    I personally only like the shows on the fashion chanel. Like say yes to the dress and what not to wear. They are not trying to tear anyone down. The rest are ridiculous and should not be poisoning our minds.

    Report Abuse
  • g_alactic's Avatar
    Posted by g_alactic Tue Aug 26, 2008 8:40am PDT

    I think people who go on shows like The Moment of Truth get what they deserve from friends and family. All I can say is one small discrepancy in a relationship or white lie for $500,000 is not worth ruining a lifetime of friendship for me.

    Report Abuse
  • Christine B's Avatar
    Posted by Christine B Tue Aug 26, 2008 8:43am PDT

    at least there is a new one on that glorifies woman's curves and celebrates bodies "au naturel" How to Look Good Naked with Carson Pressly! I love that show!

    Report Abuse
  • Nana Ama's Avatar
    Posted by Nana Ama Tue Aug 26, 2008 8:57am PDT

    IS IT REALLY NECESSARY TO BE ENGAGING OURSELVES IN WATCHING SUCH THINGS ON TELE REALITY SHOWS, THE WORLD IS MOVING FORWARD AND SHOULD ALL DO SAME THANK YOU.

    Report Abuse
  • Super Abuelita's Avatar
    Posted by Super Abuelita Tue Aug 26, 2008 9:06am PDT

    I don't watch any shows that encourage women or men to change themselves in order to please others. I'm beautiful, smart, short and NOT skinny. So what? I have people who truly care and respect me. I wouldn't want to change my looks or anything about me. Too bad self esteem isn't a quality people wish to have.

    Report Abuse
  • chaz_valentino's Avatar
    Posted by chaz_valentino Tue Aug 26, 2008 9:07am PDT

    rail thin is gross ladies guys dont like it

    Report Abuse
  • mabcosmic's Avatar
    Posted by mabcosmic Tue Aug 26, 2008 9:41am PDT

    Joanna is right on with this one. Reality TV is definitely NOT positive reinforcement for women. It's the equivalent of dog food for the human mind. Most of the plotlines involve women either A. getting a man to win the show or B. making herself more physically attractive to win the show. As if getting a man or being beautiful should be the ultimate goals of women everywhere. Where are shows that women can win because they are smart, honest, and inventive? You know, one that doesn't encourage women to resort to being catty, underhanded and backstabbing?

    I do disagree that making adolescents care for babies for a lesson in abstinence. How about, a lesson in being more responsible with sex?

    Report Abuse
  • kim's Avatar
    Posted by kim Tue Aug 26, 2008 9:59am PDT

    I HATE REALITY SHOWS! THE NETWORKS GET RID OF GOOD SHOWS TO PUT CRAP LIKE THIS ON THAT HOPEFULLY NO ONE WILL WATCH.

    Report Abuse
Comments 11-20 of 372

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Updates Chatter on Shine…

Health Byte

Tune in to our fitness forecast! These are the top ten exercise trends for 2010.