Things we don’t get: John Mayer


Call me ignorant, but I do not understand the fascination with John Mayer. I suppose he’s somewhat attractive. I know that his smash hits like “Your Body is a Wonderland” and “Waiting on the World to Change” are supposed to get under my skin with their tender and positive messages. But there’s something I can’t get past. It’s not that his voice irritates me, or that I think he’s undeserving of his Grammy awards. It’s not that the specific male pop singer/guitarist thing has never appealed to me (if a guy does pop, I’d prefer he was more straight up about it a la Justin Timberlake)—there’s just something about John Mayer’s overall person that annoys me beyond description. He seems arrogant, cocky and completely phony.

Between his narcissistic blogs about the “poignant statement” that is his new 80s-style feathered haircut, charging fans $10 for a photo op, and the mysterious gossip about his exceeding abilities in bed, it’s more than I can stomach. His seemingly all-knowing and romantic treatment of women via his lyrics on songs like “Daughters” actually comes across as disingenuous to me. Does anyone else see where I’m coming from? He’s climbed his way up the celebrity dating ladder from Jennifer Love Hewitt to Jessica Simpson to Jennifer Aniston, and it troubles me that many other women are in fact charmed by him.

After doing my research I do feel badly, because, yes, John Mayer did work for over a year at a gas station to save up for his first guitar and yes, he has been involved with a number of charities as well as starting up his own non-profit. So maybe he’s not the worst dude in the world, but it doesn’t mean I have to like him, or his music.

Now you tell me: what’s your take on John Mayer?
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 738
  • Jessica's Avatar
    Posted by Jessica Mon Jun 2, 2008 5:56am PDT

    There are a lot of "P" words to describe him... pretentious, pompous, preening, pr*ck, etc. "Poignant" is not an appropriately descriptive term. What a toolbox

    Report Abuse
  • pandela28's Avatar
    Posted by pandela28 Mon Jun 2, 2008 6:42am PDT

    I completely agree, he's not that great looking, and he just seems like a jerk.

    Report Abuse
  • SarahM's Avatar
    Posted by SarahM Mon Jun 2, 2008 6:52am PDT

    What makes you think that any media is truly forthcoming of what any celebrity is "really like?" Just because he is famous and "not perfect" in your eyes, I don't believe that should give you cause to demean him or any one else for that matter. We truly only see a glimpse of people who are in the public eye and anyone who believes the media nonsense is short by too many brain cells. Why don't you work on "perfecting" your self instead of publicly focussing negativity on someone you don't know.

    Report Abuse
  • Tinaport's Avatar
    Posted by Tinaport Mon Jun 2, 2008 7:09am PDT

    first of all...THANK YOU!! i just had this conversation with someone two days ago. he looks like he's half dead or something and talk about arrogant? he is gross and WHO disses jessica simpson and calls jennifer anniston a "summer fling"?? who does he think he is??

    Report Abuse
  • all most there's Avatar
    Posted by all most there Mon Jun 2, 2008 7:13am PDT

    i don't think he's attractive AT ALL! i really don't see what people see in him. and before i knew what he looked like i didn't like his music. then i saw him and was disgusted....

    Report Abuse
  • Disgruntled's Avatar
    Posted by Disgruntled Mon Jun 2, 2008 7:45am PDT

    Glad I'm not the only one. I have never understood the appeal of John Mayer. He's a young guy but his music is soooooo boring. Why does he make music for middle aged women? He makes Coldplay sounds exciting.

    He's kind of cute, but he's too skinny and has too many tattoos for my taste. As for his personality...no idea. He seems to veer from self-effacing to a giant ego and neither persona seems entirely sincere. (My guess is the giant ego is probably closer to reality though.) I don't understand how he has gotten a reputation as a major stud either.

    He looks like the kind of guy who got beat up regularly in high school.

    Report Abuse
  • Heidi's Avatar
    Posted by Heidi Mon Jun 2, 2008 8:13am PDT

    LOL... i live in the hometown of Mayer and have met him at a local bar before he became all the rage (7+ years ago). He is a nice guy but a bit different and back then a bit reserved/shy. I personally too don't find him at all attractive but having met and spoken to him I can't dislike him.

    Report Abuse
  • Omar Khayyam's Avatar
    Posted by Omar Khayyam Mon Jun 2, 2008 8:13am PDT

    Come on Joanna, give people a break. We walk the sidewalks of Huge cities, Chicago, New York, and other's. While we walk & happen to observe hundred's of different people, we instantly form some opinion of them. Their faces, their walk, the way they look at other people. John Mayer is simply a man. As always, there have been better & worse men, & women. As far as music, I'm a Hard Core 159 I.Q. man that listens to older Supergroups like YES, ELP, then move down the line to Jeff Beck, ZZ Top, Deep Purple. There is No Good Music today! Between Mayer & Timberflake... neither. But I'd check out a Mayer concert. Under dislikes, what is the Last word you use, Haters? Is the Star a step up for you? Wow, I don't know if I could handle 'that much excitement in NYC'! Yeah, now I'm positive Mayer is a Good man. I would...change my ways if I were you, you're ridiculous!

    Report Abuse
  • samarama82's Avatar
    Posted by samarama82 Mon Jun 2, 2008 8:38am PDT

    i have NEVER liked him, and i was always the only one of my friends! Not only is his music annoying and uninspired...he's not that cute, and pretty pretentious. blech.

    Report Abuse
  • lipstickchick's Avatar
    Posted by lipstickchick Mon Jun 2, 2008 8:44am PDT

    I agree with Jess.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 738

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Health Byte

You know you need to hydrate. But is the water you're drinking safe? Here are 7 ways to be sure your water's fit for you.