Things we don’t get: John Mayer


Call me ignorant, but I do not understand the fascination with John Mayer. I suppose he’s somewhat attractive. I know that his smash hits like “Your Body is a Wonderland” and “Waiting on the World to Change” are supposed to get under my skin with their tender and positive messages. But there’s something I can’t get past. It’s not that his voice irritates me, or that I think he’s undeserving of his Grammy awards. It’s not that the specific male pop singer/guitarist thing has never appealed to me (if a guy does pop, I’d prefer he was more straight up about it a la Justin Timberlake)—there’s just something about John Mayer’s overall person that annoys me beyond description. He seems arrogant, cocky and completely phony.

Between his narcissistic blogs about the “poignant statement” that is his new 80s-style feathered haircut, charging fans $10 for a photo op, and the mysterious gossip about his exceeding abilities in bed, it’s more than I can stomach. His seemingly all-knowing and romantic treatment of women via his lyrics on songs like “Daughters” actually comes across as disingenuous to me. Does anyone else see where I’m coming from? He’s climbed his way up the celebrity dating ladder from Jennifer Love Hewitt to Jessica Simpson to Jennifer Aniston, and it troubles me that many other women are in fact charmed by him.

After doing my research I do feel badly, because, yes, John Mayer did work for over a year at a gas station to save up for his first guitar and yes, he has been involved with a number of charities as well as starting up his own non-profit. So maybe he’s not the worst dude in the world, but it doesn’t mean I have to like him, or his music.

Now you tell me: what’s your take on John Mayer?
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 731-738 of 738
  • Nate's Avatar
    Posted by Nate Thu Nov 20, 2008 6:32pm PST

    His music is so boring! Has anyone heard his cover of Tom Petty's Free Fallin? Mayer absoluely butchered it.

    Report Abuse
  • Veza's Avatar
    Posted by Veza Tue Nov 25, 2008 11:24am PST

    I completely love John. He is a brilliant song writer and musician. However, I think this girl hopping has got me a little mad. Jen is great, she deserves better.

    Report Abuse
  • Beth's Avatar
    Posted by Beth Wed Dec 3, 2008 2:42pm PST

    To each their own. I personally adore him.

    Report Abuse
  • *'s Avatar
    Posted by * Thu Jan 15, 2009 11:53am PST

    He may have been a nice guy at some point in his existence, but right now, I find him to be a self-important, delusional douchebag. As someone else posted, what sane man could date Jessica Simpson and Jennifer Anniston and diss them both on his blog? He's not that talented and also not that good-looking. If he approached me on the street, I'd laugh and walk the other way.

    Report Abuse
  • nonnie's Avatar
    Posted by nonnie Fri Feb 6, 2009 8:34pm PST

    does anyone else see some resemblance to Johnny Depp or is it just me? I think they're both kinda' cute in an odd sort of way...never heard his music so can't judge him on that!

    Report Abuse
  • stephanie's Avatar
    Posted by stephanie Sun Mar 1, 2009 2:59pm PST

    I personally think you ladies don't understand the man (Mayer) so you just say you don't like him. You aren't supposed to understand everyone by looking at them. You have to know his background and know a little of his past. I love his music and I love his guitar skills. maybe he is a little self conscious so he holds his head high, which makes him seem arrogant. and for the Aniston thing he had a a good point. Wouldn't you rather a guy say he's not diggin you than for him to lead you on in a long drawn out turbulent relationship? I am a 36 year old black woman and i like the man and that to me seems weird because i cant get enough of his music. i think a lot of you are young and have a lot to learn. Give the man a chance before you label him a weirdo. do some background work.

    Report Abuse
  • J's Avatar
    Posted by J Fri Apr 17, 2009 9:00pm PDT

    Well, as a musician myself, I will add in this huge post a few words. John Mayer is very talented at guitar and sings ok, but his arrogance is VERY ANNOYING. Maybe he is making up for some past insecurities in his past, who knows. That's just speculation. I just bought his new Blu Ray DVD and at the very beginning he brags about opening for himself. I am sorry, John Mayer, but that really was annoying, arrogant and turned me off. I do remember someone telling me that they went to his concert and found him to be arrogant. This was about 2-3 years ago. I have always liked his music, however being at a second hand concert so to speak,I am glad I didn't spend my money on one of his concerts and encounter his arrogance first hand like a friend of mine did. It's funny, I am typing this up now and my girlfriend is asking to turn him off. LOL

    My message to John Mayer: your talent does not give you the right to think you are better than everyone else and have an arrogant attitude. You may be talented but there is always someone who is better. I guess you could say I used to be John Mayer fan. If I get any use out of his DVD it will be to use the DVD to learn some of the songs, if I can stomach his little lectures in between sets touting how awesome he thinks himself to be.

    Thank God for true legendary musicians like Eric Clapton and BB King who are at least humble and can relate to other people in a down to earth way. Those are the musicans that we can grow to like. True entertainers.

    Report Abuse
  • 8 MayerFan's Avatar
    Posted by 8 MayerFan Thu Apr 30, 2009 7:50am PDT

    Oh, come on ppl!! really! Get off of him !! He is human!! I love him faults and all !!

    Report Abuse
Comments 731-738 of 738

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Updates Chatter on Shine…

Health Byte

Tune in to our fitness forecast! These are the top ten exercise trends for 2010.