Parenting

Sunday, November 8, 2009

A guy's take on: Circumcision...why you shouldn't (and why you should)

by Cole Gamble

To cut or not to cut: that is the question. Any parent about to have a boy faces this quandary. In ancient times circumcision was a must. Lack of proper hygiene made foreskins a liability. This is the modern era, however. The old slice n' dice routine is more choice than mandate. Some of you made your decision the second you discovered the sex of the baby. "I'll chop the sucker off myself if I have to!" Some of you were a bit more hesitant.

The same problem saddled my wife and I two years ago. One of us was very pro-circ (wife) and the other less so. For full disclosure's sake, I myself am not circumcised and it doesn't bother me one iota.

So I laid out my case to save the foreskin. Here's what I told my wife:

 Penis Styling as Fashion

Save the religious exception, most parents chose to cut because they simply think it's a more fashionable look. The line I got from my wife was, "Girls like them better." To which I replied, "You married me, didn't you?" At which point she added, "Oh, but yours is 'special,'" patting me on the head reassuringly. Um, nice save. My father in law tossed in his two cents: "The boys in the high school showers will make fun of him." "Oh really?" I said, "Well then my son can just say, 'Dude, you're the one staring at my penis.'" Face it, parents circumcise because they want their boy to be like all the others. They're shaping their child to conform from birth. Is that what you want, a conformist? Do you want to a kid who is a genital sheep, or do want one who rocks the system with a penis with personality?

Great Names

All the euphemisms for circumcised are played out. Bald headed soldier. One eyed snake. Yawn. Think of a cut penis as a wellspring of inspiration for new names. Like "The Sleeping Bag" or "Mr. Turtleneck."

Men with Uncircumcised Penises Have More Pleasurable Sex

Okay so you're not giving a lot of thought to your child's future sex life. Fair enough, but many experts believe that circumcision leads to lessened penile sensitivity...

Possible Surgical Risk

Any and all surgery (and circumcision is surgery) comes with risk.

 It Is Not Too Much Trouble to Care For

 This was the big argument my wife trotted out. “You don’t want to clean it everyday, do you?” Turns out you are not even supposed to touch the thing until the boy is three, and by then it pulls back naturally and you clean it just like you would a normal penis. So there, you penis scrubbing fanatics!

Read part 2: Why circumcision is good


More by this Author:

Child Prodigies So Amazing They'll Make You Feel Bad About Yourself

The 26 Most Disturbing Kids Movies Ever

7 Classic Kid's TV Shows Clearly Conceived on (Bad) Acid

12 Pregnancy Myths

The Sh*t List: 10 Bizarre (or Terrific?) Potty Gadgets

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 41
  • Katja C's Avatar
    Posted by Katja C Mon Oct 6, 2008 10:20pm PDT

    I'm so happy to hear this. My son isn't circumcised, and I got all sides of the family screaming at me over it, except for my own mother (she didn't have my brother circumcised, either). I was able to debunk all the medical myths, but the only thing that slowed me down was when my aunt told me about how my son might get made fun of by other boys, or might be embarassed about it, or be uncomfortable having sex one day. I mean, I don't have a penis, hwo would I know how men feel about their foreskins? I know that I personally have been with a couple "uncut" men, and it didn't bother me. I asked my brother if he was embarrassed about being uncut, and he said that he's never lost any sleep over it, but I still worried that one day my son would hate for me not having him cut.

    Anyway, I'm glad to hear that it's not nearly as common as it used to me, and that there are even a few benefits to keeping his foreskin (as weird as it is thinking that my toddler will one day have a sex life, I'm glad to know that he won't have the decreased sensation of circumcised men).

    Report Abuse
  • hey you's Avatar
    Posted by hey you Thu Oct 9, 2008 2:02pm PDT

    My twin boys are not cut and I have heard it from everybody right down to their second pediatrician. I probably would have except they were premies and it could not even be considered until they were almost one year old before they were healthy enough. At that point I thought why put them through any more!! I did have an awful experience once. My boys original pediatrician (who by the way was wonderful and very supportive of my decision) moved away and the man that took his place was an older docter. When the boys were about two he told me that I had messed up by not pulling the skin back and cleaning it before then. He made me feel awful about not having them cut in the first place. He told me to go home give them a bath and then wrap them in towel and hold them down. So that I could pull the skin back and clean it. I being a young 22 year old single mother thought oh my gosh what have I done?? I was worried if I didn't do what he had instructed they would get a terrible infection. This is what he said would happen. So I did it. I held them down pulled back the skin all the way behind the head so I could clean it. It was awful!! My little boys screamed in horror I was crying they were bawling. They were completely inconsolible for 25 minutes at least! I think that they may have almost gone into shock! Then for the next six months anytime I changed their bums they cried and said don't touch my penis! I changed to a different doctor and asked her about it. She said that I should have never done that and my previous doctor needed to go back to school. Times have changed. The skin will naturally retract when they are older and as long as you cleaned around the opening everything would be fine.

    I am still comfortable with my decision my boys are almost 7 now and they do not remember that incedent. I, on the other hand will never forget. All I can say is educate yourself. Never take someone elses word for anything. Do what makes you feel comfortable.

    Report Abuse
  • Beth's Avatar
    Posted by Beth Thu Oct 9, 2008 2:35pm PDT

    Good stuff here. It's kinda funny, when I found out I was having a boy, I just figured circumcision came with the territory. I didn't know anything about it, except that my brothers are circumcised, my father is, my husband is, so I just thought my son would be. But after what can only be described as a lecture from my OBGYN, I started doing some reading and realized there was absolutely no reason at all to have it done. So we didn't. And I'm so glad now, I was especially glad to not have that little injury to take care of in addition to everything else during his first days. It's your decision, sure, but I'm a big advocate for just leaving well enough alone.

    Report Abuse
  • LydiaB's Avatar
    Posted by LydiaB Thu Oct 9, 2008 3:01pm PDT

    well, i had my son circumcised, and he never even cried about it. i agree its a personal choice, but all you have to do is put a small amount of protective cream around the tip at diaper change. it healed up in no time, and i'm glad i did it.

    Report Abuse
  • HotCrossBuns's Avatar
    Posted by HotCrossBuns Fri Oct 10, 2008 5:44am PDT

    We didn't cut our son, either. Mostly because we were not able to find any convincing arguments to support the procedure. We've never had any adverse health issues, and now that he is 6 he's been taught how to clean it properly himself.

    That argument that boys should look like their fathers who are cut never held any water with me. Does that mean if my son came out with a different nose than my husband that we should get him a nose-job right away? Or if my daughters end up with a different bra size than I, then I shoud get them boob-jobs?

    And the argument about the increased risk for infection seems so rediculous. Along that same vein, ears seems to be pretty risky organs to have around. Should we start cutting them off too?

    Foreskins have a purpose. Circumsicion isn't like removing a pesky useless mole. It's mutilating a very sensitive and functional organ. What a way to welcome your child to the world: "I love you, baby boy! Now I'm going to hand you over to this doctor so he can cut off half your penis!"

    Report Abuse
  • kitty's Avatar
    Posted by kitty Fri Oct 10, 2008 6:57am PDT

    I did not circumcise either of by boys, nor will I do it it my next son. My husband is from the Islands and its just not done there.

    Report Abuse
  • Andrea B's Avatar
    Posted by Andrea B Fri Oct 10, 2008 7:07am PDT

    I was on the fence with this one, but my husband was adamant that our sons be circumcised. He said the locker rooms in middle and high school are rough enough w.o. adding more "differentness".

    My brother is not cut, and he did have an issue with it when he reached puberty because he was not taking care of daily cleanings. I can see that. After all, I'm not sure many 10, 11, 12, 13 year old boys do a very good at cleaning as it is.

    Report Abuse
  • JeanneMommy's Avatar
    Posted by JeanneMommy Fri Oct 10, 2008 8:21am PDT

    I think it depends on the father. My husband is circumcised and believed very strongly our son should be too. Who am I to argue? The main reason for this decision, my husband didn't want a girl to laugh at him when he is 16 or so. At the end of the day it is an individual decision, doesn't matter one way or the other.

    Report Abuse
  • Cody's Avatar
    Posted by Cody Fri Oct 10, 2008 9:30am PDT

    I have two boys, one is circumcised and one is not, my youngest boy is 4 and at birth my ob explained that he had a condition that left a small pocket in the foreskin and that it would be a breeding ground for bacteria and would be best for him if he was circumcised.I agreed because my uncle had the same condition and at age 18 had to have a very painful circumcision. My oldest boy was not circumcised because we felt the same way as the writer and did not want him to have to conform to society's perception of "normal" what is normal anyway?

    Report Abuse
  • dragnflygrrl's Avatar
    Posted by dragnflygrrl Fri Oct 10, 2008 10:56am PDT

    congrats and spreading HPV more easily to his gf's and freaquent UTI's. I work in health care I've seen the reports.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 41

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

parenting byte

When entrusting your child's health to a pediatrician, you are bound to have concerns about whether you are picking the right practice or doctor. Here are five questions to ask when choosing a pediatrician.