Parenting

Thursday, December 10, 2009

A guy's take on: Circumcision...why you shouldn't (and why you should)

by Cole Gamble

To cut or not to cut: that is the question. Any parent about to have a boy faces this quandary. In ancient times circumcision was a must. Lack of proper hygiene made foreskins a liability. This is the modern era, however. The old slice n' dice routine is more choice than mandate. Some of you made your decision the second you discovered the sex of the baby. "I'll chop the sucker off myself if I have to!" Some of you were a bit more hesitant.

The same problem saddled my wife and I two years ago. One of us was very pro-circ (wife) and the other less so. For full disclosure's sake, I myself am not circumcised and it doesn't bother me one iota.

So I laid out my case to save the foreskin. Here's what I told my wife:

 Penis Styling as Fashion

Save the religious exception, most parents chose to cut because they simply think it's a more fashionable look. The line I got from my wife was, "Girls like them better." To which I replied, "You married me, didn't you?" At which point she added, "Oh, but yours is 'special,'" patting me on the head reassuringly. Um, nice save. My father in law tossed in his two cents: "The boys in the high school showers will make fun of him." "Oh really?" I said, "Well then my son can just say, 'Dude, you're the one staring at my penis.'" Face it, parents circumcise because they want their boy to be like all the others. They're shaping their child to conform from birth. Is that what you want, a conformist? Do you want to a kid who is a genital sheep, or do want one who rocks the system with a penis with personality?

Great Names

All the euphemisms for circumcised are played out. Bald headed soldier. One eyed snake. Yawn. Think of a cut penis as a wellspring of inspiration for new names. Like "The Sleeping Bag" or "Mr. Turtleneck."

Men with Uncircumcised Penises Have More Pleasurable Sex

Okay so you're not giving a lot of thought to your child's future sex life. Fair enough, but many experts believe that circumcision leads to lessened penile sensitivity...

Possible Surgical Risk

Any and all surgery (and circumcision is surgery) comes with risk.

 It Is Not Too Much Trouble to Care For

 This was the big argument my wife trotted out. “You don’t want to clean it everyday, do you?” Turns out you are not even supposed to touch the thing until the boy is three, and by then it pulls back naturally and you clean it just like you would a normal penis. So there, you penis scrubbing fanatics!

Read part 2: Why circumcision is good


More by this Author:

Child Prodigies So Amazing They'll Make You Feel Bad About Yourself

The 26 Most Disturbing Kids Movies Ever

7 Classic Kid's TV Shows Clearly Conceived on (Bad) Acid

12 Pregnancy Myths

The Sh*t List: 10 Bizarre (or Terrific?) Potty Gadgets

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 11-20 of 41
  • coolgal18's Avatar
    Posted by coolgal18 Fri Oct 10, 2008 11:01am PDT

    this article is making me squirm thinking of a knife going there..

    poor guys.

    Report Abuse
  • Science mama's Avatar
    Posted by Science mama Fri Oct 10, 2008 11:18am PDT

    Thanks for this article. I think the argument that he will be made fun of does not make sense, because nowadays more and more boys are not getting circumcised. If there are a lot of boys not circumcised that are his age, why would they make fun of him?

    Report Abuse
  • Mommy Darla's Avatar
    Posted by Mommy Darla Fri Oct 10, 2008 1:04pm PDT

    i didnt with my son...number one the choice was mine and they say you sholud have it like the fathers!! number two...who am i to take away his sexual pleasure later on in life! i dont believe in the whole "look" and if some girl doesnt like the way it looks then she doesnt deserve to be with him! now the hygiene is simple and he should get it when he does! i just think it really is parnets chioce these days!

    Report Abuse
  • mighty_mouse's Avatar
    Posted by mighty_mouse Fri Oct 10, 2008 1:13pm PDT

    Uncircumcised penises have a higher chance of contracting HIV and other STD's.

    They also spread STD's more than a circumcised penis.

    And yes, women really do like circumcised penises better. I've been with both.

    Report Abuse
  • lena_abf's Avatar
    Posted by lena_abf Fri Oct 10, 2008 2:52pm PDT

    I had my son circumcised. My husband wanted too. We came to our decision because of the fact that my husband had a infection when he was around 12 years old and he had to be circumcised.

    Report Abuse
  • Lisa's Avatar
    Posted by Lisa Fri Oct 10, 2008 2:55pm PDT

    I did not circumcise my son. I didn't want to do that to him. Well he is now 16 years old and want to have it done. We have an appointment on Monday to talk to the doctor about it. It's his body and if he wants it done then we'll do it. I don't regret my decision. I hope he doesn't either.

    Report Abuse
  • Maria's Avatar
    Posted by Maria Fri Oct 10, 2008 2:56pm PDT

    I don't know...I've been with both as well, and I liked the uncircumcised better....Well, my son had to be circumcised because he had a hypospadias (I would explain what that is, but it would take up too much space). Otherwise I was going to just let him be. The doctor gave me a huge folder of info on the differences between circumcised and uncircumcised penises, and the main issue was the circumcised men had loss of sexual feeling as well as some length. Anyway, it's (in my opinion) a rather barbaric practice. And just as useless as female circumcision which is just as barbaric. That's another thing, if anyone even suggested circumcising a girl baby over here, people would be horrified. It's a bit of a double standard.

    Report Abuse
  • Nina T's Avatar
    Posted by Nina T Sat Oct 11, 2008 5:47am PDT

    Did anyone ever consider that forskin was there for a reason? Who are we to mess with whatever Mother Nature/God created? Just leave the damn thing alone! BTW my husband and my son are both intact and quite happy about it.

    Report Abuse
  • Creamiese's Avatar
    Posted by Creamiese Sat Oct 11, 2008 10:58am PDT

    gross...it needs to be cut for cleanliness...besides in the near future it will be a problem for confidence...any woman will tell that they prefer for it to be clean and cut...when it not cut it brings diseases and yeast infection and beside it is a big issue when you think its not

    Report Abuse
  • DAVID G's Avatar
    Posted by DAVID G Sat Oct 11, 2008 12:46pm PDT

    I'm am 33 years old and umcircumcised. It hasn't caused any confidence problems for me. No one has laughed at me. The only argument for circumcision that makes any since to me is the increase risk of past on a std which could be decrease by simply cleaning it properly. It works the same whether it is circumcised or not. a woman's preference is not a strong enough reason for me to consider circumcision for me or my son.

    Report Abuse
Comments 11-20 of 41

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Updates Chatter on Shine…

parenting byte

When entrusting your child's health to a pediatrician, you are bound to have concerns about whether you are picking the right practice or doctor. Here are five questions to ask when choosing a pediatrician.