Parenting

Tuesday, February 9, 2010

Are School Lunches Causing Childhood Obesity?

A new report from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation's Healthy Eating Research suggests the USDA's subsidized lunch program is contributing to the childhood obesity epidemic, according to the Organic Consumers Association.


The USDA provides commodity foods--grains such as rice and pasta; meats and cheeses; fruits and vegetables--to national school lunch programs. There are 180 commodity foods offered to schools and they make up the largest single source of foods for schools, according to the report summary. The report says these foods often set the tone for the entire meal, and many meals are planned around high-fat items.

At the same time, childhood obesity has become an epidemic. The report says that low-income students are disproportionately affected by childhood obesity and they also make up two-thirds of the school lunch program participants.

The study showed that more than 50 percent of commodity foods are sent to processors before they are sent to schools. Processing these foods often means adding fat, sugar and sodium. So cheese goes on pizza, poultry becomes chicken nuggets, and fruit shows up in a dessert item.

In addition, the authors compared the recommendations from the USDA Dietary Guidelines, and the actual funds spent on federal commodity foods. In the report, you see an inverted food pyramid; the bulk of dollars spent on the school lunch program are for meat and dairy products, instead of fruits and vegetables.

Looking at California specifically, school districts spent more than 82 percent of the commodity funds to order meat and cheese items, and only 13 percent of funds on orders of fruit, fruit juice, vegetables and legumes.

The researchers offered some suggestions for addressing the problem:

    * First, the USDA should align the lunch program standards with current Dietary Guidelines, and ensure schools are meeting these standards.
    * Implement nutrition guidelines for processors so that processed foods have to align with the Dietary Guidelines for Americans as well.
    * The proportion and amount of fresh fruits and vegetables purchased by the federal government for use in the school lunch program should be increased.
    * And finally, the report suggests giving grants to schools for one-time only infrastructure costs, such as the creation or expansion of refrigeration and freezing capacity for fruits and vegetables.

More from The Daily Green:
Top 10 Food Sources of Vitamin C
Top 10 Food Sources of Iron
4 Ways to Green Your Kids' Lunch Boxes
7 Super Foods
For More Tips & Tricks You Can Count On: Subscribe to Good Housekeeping & Save!

Reprinted with permission of Hearst Communications, Inc.
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-9 of 9
  • Doll's Avatar
    Posted by Doll Thu Nov 13, 2008 11:43am PST

    When my son started school, I took the easy way out and gave him lunch money. In February I went to have lunch with him for his birthday. I almost cried after seeing what he had been eating: fried chicken patties w/stale bun and no condiments, half cold corn, a tiny juice box/or a pear, and strawberry milk. From that point on he brought his lunch. It is not the schools responsibility to make sure my son is not overweight. Obesity runs on both sides of his family, and we make sure he knows, and always eats right.

    Report Abuse
  • PMT's Avatar
    Posted by PMT Thu Nov 13, 2008 3:13pm PST

    This has been a hot topic in this country. I used to work in public health and childhood obesity was and still is a huge issue. It's awful what schools feed kids, although a lot of schools are really trying to offer healthier choices like salad bars.

    It's really important that kids learn about proper nutrition at an early age. Here are some helpful tips for parents--it needs to start at home as well. Educators could take a lesson or two when it comes to health and nutrition.

    http://buzz.prevention.com/community/lindsey/do-you-force-your-child-to-eat-healthy

    Report Abuse
  • Chana C's Avatar
    Posted by Chana C Fri Nov 14, 2008 8:41am PST

    I think the school my kids go to actually does far better at school lunches then when I was in school myself. Back when I was a student it was Reagan times. Katchup and pizza sauce were allowed to be classified as a veggie. Often lunch was something like a little piece of pizza or a mystery meat, a slice of white bread, milk, and occasionally a couple slices of fruit.

    The first day my kids had hot lunch available at their school after having to pack cold lunches in the past, I was a tad nervous. Not only on the health level of the food, but also the fact that both my kids eat more then most adults I know and a small lunch wouldn't fill them up enough to concentrate. When they got home I asked how it was. Both kids listed off the foods they had, including the fact they had some choices offered which put them more in control of what the main part of the meal consisted of. They also had fresh fruit and veggies offered, and were even allowed to get some more if still hungry.

    The school lunches are offered on a sliding scale so affordable, and if there is a day the kid does forget his lunch ticket, the cost can be put on account and billed later. So no child goes hungry which I think is very important at an elementary age. A hungry child is one that can't learn well and I speak from experience.

    Report Abuse
  • tweet's Avatar
    Posted by tweet Fri Nov 14, 2008 6:44pm PST

    not the schools...the parents are to blame for fat kids...becuase they are fat most of the time also. eating healthly and keeping fit is a family affair.

    Report Abuse
  • blahblahblah's Avatar
    Posted by blahblahblah Fri Nov 14, 2008 7:56pm PST

    YES, YES,YES Schools are definately to blame for childhood obesity or at least playing a VERY LARGE part in it!!Parents are not totally to blame for childhood obesity when schools sell kids Gatorade (big bottles), ice cream sandwiches, doughnuts and other assorted high calorie snack foods in addition to all the fried crap on their regular menu and then let them go back and purchase seconds.

    Report Abuse
  • HotCrossBuns's Avatar
    Posted by HotCrossBuns Sat Nov 15, 2008 2:56pm PST

    www.feingold.org

    Check this site out to see how obesity is not the only problem school lunches are creating. The chemical ingredients commonly found in their foods also contribute to the growing numbers of learning disabilities(can you say counterproductive?), hyperactivity disorders and aggressive behaviors just to name a few.

    Report Abuse
  • AJL's Avatar
    Posted by AJL Mon Nov 17, 2008 9:16am PST

    First of all I do not have children (I'm 25) but I think the amount of time children have to eat during lunch at school is contributing to childhood obesity. When I was a child we literally had 30 minutes to get in line, get our food, pay for it, eat, clean up and get back to class. That is not enough time! When I would have a meal at home or at my families homes I would eat so fast that I would literally be in pain! I haven't been in the school system for 7 years now but I have friends who have grade-schoolers and their lunch menus are full of low-fat and whole wheat food options. Those two words were never in my lunch rooms ever! About 2 weeks ago there was a report released that said that people who eat faster tend to be more over weight... no wonder the childhood obesity epidemic is so bad! I still eat way too fast but as an adult I am more cautious of what goes in my mouth. Children don't do that.

    Report Abuse
  • jesse's Avatar
    Posted by jesse Thu Nov 20, 2008 7:08pm PST

    Personally, I think that school lunches are not to blame for childhood obesity. At least, not entirely. Parents are. We do not teach our children discipline when it comes to food. And we sure aren't trying to get them to go outside and work off all the calories we are allowing them to consume. We have no problem allowing the tv and video games do our jobs. When kids are young parents sit them in front of a tv so mommy/daddy can do what they want. By the time we realize we need to get our kids outside it is too late, they are already overweight couch potatoes with no desire for physical activity.

    Report Abuse
  • ahyoka's Avatar
    Posted by ahyoka Fri Dec 19, 2008 7:37pm PST

    I don't think the schools are the only ones to blame. Our school has a wellness program. All of the food is baked nothing is fried. Fresh fruit instead of desserts or canned fruit. About once every nine weeks the students have a bag of Baked Lays, which they love. Also our students have water bottles on their desks all the time. No other drinks besides milk is sold. There is no pop or candy sold to students. I think one of the biggest problem is TVs, computers, and video games. Kids use to get outside and play. Now they just set around. They need to move more.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-9 of 9

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

parenting byte

Keep your family healthy without changing where you shop.  Healthy living costs less at Walmart.