Parenting

Tuesday, December 8, 2009

Do Sitters with College Degrees Make Better Caregivers?

Back of a graduation cap, saying 'Senior'

By Sittercity.com

In today's competitive job market, babysitters and nannies know they need to do a little extra to stand out in the sea of resumes. Along those same lines, parents are starting to become a little pickier about who they choose to care for their kids -- especially when it comes to a caregiver's education.

We came across a recent article titled "Nanny positions requiring college degrees," which focused on this growing trend and argued against why an education is necessary when caring for children.


THE AUTHOR'S OPINION

Said the mom who wrote the article:

While earning a college degree is a major accomplishment it doesn't mean you know squat about parenting or caring for kids.

As a working single mom, I relied heavily on nannies and babysitters when my daughter was much younger.

The nanny my daughter loved the most was a high school dropout with three grown kids. She cared for my daughter for two straight years until it was time for her to start pre-school.

She was loving, playful and creative. But she was also stern, disciplined, and organized. She knew my daughter so well she called my attention to things her pediatrician missed.

When I panicked about certain behavior, she was able to tell me from her own parenting experience, not to worry, it was a phase. And she was flexible, which was a big plus in my line of work.


OTHER PARENTS' AND SITTERS' OPINIONS

When we asked Sittercity members what the most important caregiver quality was a while back, education never even came up.

Both parents and babysitters cited work ethic, flexibility, communication, patience -- never "a college degree." And that hasn't changed, for the most part.

The general consensus seems to be that experience matters more than a degree and that a degree alone won't land someone a nanny job. However, having a college degree IS a sign of a well-educated nanny, which many parents seem to prefer, especially in today's saturated child care market...


To read what parents and sitters are saying about caregivers and college degrees, click here.




Read More:

Sittercity.com's Child Care Blog

Search for Sitters:
Find the perfect caregiver for your family on Sittercity.com.

[image credit: nsaplayer]
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-6 of 6
  • springtime's Avatar
    Posted by springtime Wed Jul 22, 2009 10:59am PDT

    If that degree is in marketing or engineering, how will it be helpful? If it is in early childhood, that's another story. Three ingredients are necessary: 1) a love for children 2) common sense

    3) age appropriate communication skills

    Report Abuse
  • Brittany G's Avatar
    Posted by Brittany G Wed Jul 22, 2009 12:40pm PDT

    I dont think so. My uncle has a degree & hates kids but I dont have a degree but im the oldest of 4, love kids & so ive always been great with kids& now have 1 of my own. How does education have any thing to do with your skills as a caregiver??????

    Report Abuse
  • erin's Avatar
    Posted by erin Wed Jul 22, 2009 4:00pm PDT

    It's not about the care giving so much the parents are concerned with it's the educational elements and hopeful discipline and respect the college grad will have. The college grad is probably more open minded than your high school grad/dropout and is willing to try more new age parenting techniques. As a college grad I know that the degree does not ensure great child skills but if your babysitting then you probably have them by this age and thats not so much part of the argument. I think it's what people expect from the grad, their smarts their determination to rub off on the child, the ability to inspire as well as educate which parents are looking for, they want to know that the person can help with home work and improve their childs verbal skills, communication skills and creativity. Something i'm sorry to say your not going to get from a drop out or a person with only a high school education if your thinking of long term babysitting.

    Report Abuse
  • Spam I Am's Avatar
    Posted by Spam I Am Wed Jul 22, 2009 10:49pm PDT

    If the college grad is more willing to try out "new age parenting techniques" then that's NOT a good thing...

    Who can say that a "drop-out" or "just" a high school graduate will not have smarts? Everybody is different.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-6 of 6

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

parenting byte

When entrusting your child's health to a pediatrician, you are bound to have concerns about whether you are picking the right practice or doctor. Here are five questions to ask when choosing a pediatrician.