Parenting

Sunday, November 29, 2009

The 10 Most Violent Video Games (And 10 Alternatives)

Arm Yourself With Information

The names of violent video games tend to travel fast among preteen and teen gamers. And the next thing you know, your kid wants to play them.

Our list of the 10 most violent video games is designed to arm you with enough information to help you make informed choices about what to allow your kids to play. And beyond that, we offer less-violent alternatives with the compelling gameplay that kids want. No parent wants to say "no" all the time.

Why care about violent video games ? Prolonged exposure to violent media leads to aggressive behavior, anxiety, bullying, and desensitization. This cause-and-effect relationship is now part of the American Academy of Pediatrics' official policy to help doctors and parents create a "safer" media environment for kids.

At Common Sense Media, we're all about sanity, not censorship. So here's our list of the 10 most violent video games -- and 10 you can say yes to.


10 Most Violent Video Games

1. Manhunt Players advance by stalking and killing victims, all for the delight of a "director" who urges you to make the killings bloodier, more cunning, and ever more horrific. Manhunt 2 is more of the same, but now you've been injected with a drug to bring out your "homicidal tendencies."
Alternative: Mirror's Edge

2. Resident Evil 5 Using guns, swords, or a chainsaw, you shoot, hack, and slash oncoming enemies, producing copious amounts of blood. And the game's racial undertones are hard to ignore, as the white hero (accompanied by a light-skinned African American) has to kill mostly black victims infected by the zombie-causing virus.
Alternative: Uncharted: Drake's Fortune  

3. Dead Rising Based on the 1978 Dawn of the Dead zombie splatter flick, this game combines gory imagery -- like shotgun blasts, chainsaw dismemberment, and hand-to-hand combat -- with images of nude women on various objects.
Alternative: Prince of Persia

4. Resident Evil 4 Players must stab, shoot, and bomb their way through hundreds of realistic-looking humans and monsters. Cursing and sexual dialogue round out the mix.
Alternative: Ghostbusters: The Video Game

5. Grand Theft Auto (specifically Grand Theft Auto IV and Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas ) Players can kill other humans, including police officers, or drive into pedestrians on sidewalks and in parks. Gang warfare, beatings, drive-by shootings, and bloody deaths are all shown in gory detail.
Alternative: InFAMOUS  

6. God of War II Players can do everything from ripping the eye out of a Cyclops to twisting the head off of Medusa to slicing off enemies' arms with chains strapped to their wrists. There's also a sex mini-game.
Alternative: Batman: Arkham Asylum  

7. Mortal Kombat: Deception The goal of this game is the same as other Mortal Kombats: Kill or be killed, and make it as horrific as you can.
Alternative: Mortal Kombat vs. DC Universe

8. MadWorld With the Wii remote and Nunchuk in your hands, you simulate the motions used to split someone open with a chainsaw, punch opponents with your fists, or pick up and use assorted objects scattered throughout the levels to dismember, bludgeon, and impale your foes.
Alternative: Punchout  

9. Gears of War You can use a chainsaw to rip apart enemies or machine guns to spray them down. Characters and world are photorealistic, making bloody battles seem even gorier.
Alternative: Halo Wars  

10. Saints Row 2 The protagonist never shows hesitation or remorse, often deliberately choosing the most violent means possible of carrying out missions -- declaring such methods "more fun" at least once -- and taking pleasure in homicide.
Alternative: Battlefield Heroes  

Compiled by Common Sense Media's expert game reviewers, who play thousands of video games a year and contribute reviews to USA Today, The Globe and Mail, and Boy's Life, as well as Common Sense Media .


Do your kids play violent video games? Do you allow them in your home?
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 19
  • Zom-B's Avatar
    Posted by Zom-B Fri Oct 30, 2009 6:17am PDT

    GOD OF WAR FREAKIN' RULES.

    Just sayin'.

    Report Abuse
  • Ellen's Avatar
    Posted by Ellen Fri Oct 30, 2009 6:59am PDT

    I love these games and own half of them. You may also notice that ALL of them are rated MATURE!!! duh...it says right on the box that its not for children and it lists all the reasons why. If your kid is old enough to be playing mature games ( 17+ ) I doubt he is going to be interested in some of these lame subsitutes. The alternatives you listed don't even make sense. Ghostbusters instead of resident evil 4? RE4 won the game of the year award and ghostbusters was rated as "okay". Did you even play these games? Seriously, i've been playing dead raising for years and have never seen a naked woman's image on anything. Get your facts straight before you bash some of the greatest video games of the passed 5 years.

    Report Abuse
  • E. Boost's Avatar
    Posted by E. Boost Fri Oct 30, 2009 8:00am PDT

    I'm 19 and own many of these games too. My mom is constantly complaining that I play violent/aggressive games but really, I'm not in any way influenced by them, they are just fun to play. It does not mean I'm going to get the nerve to do a school shooting or be violent with anyone in my in and outside of my life. Also, these games are rated (Although most of them can also be found online) you can easily get the ratings from the game's website or on the box. If it says M then please keep your small kids away from it if you would like to. I personally believe the only people who are affected by games like these (besides children) have some influence problems and are misguided too easily.

    Report Abuse
  • Lord's Avatar
    Posted by Lord Fri Oct 30, 2009 10:56pm PDT

    I'm 17 and played all the games(as far as i could)!No matter +1 or +25!and i say mostly games have no effect on me....for example i played Half Life when i was just 9!

    Report Abuse
  • m.'s Avatar
    Posted by m. Sat Oct 31, 2009 6:55pm PDT

    The problem is that most gamers wont be affected by the content matter, but SOME will. Therein lies the problem. Out of hundreds of thousands, if not million of gamers on a worldwide scale are unaffected, than that means that there are a huge tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of problem people out there that are being swayed and influenced very negatively by these games. I have been a gamer since they first came on the market (yep, that old), i do love them, but i do believe in more stringent classification and sale control on them so they don't fall into the hands of the mentally vulnerable or the too young.

    Report Abuse
  • Erick's Avatar
    Posted by Erick Sun Nov 1, 2009 12:37am PDT

    Yawn. Here we go again. While I agree with the point that outrageous video game violence is bad for kids (and everyone, I suppose), why call Resident Evil 5 racist? Only morons do that. The other parts of the R. Evil game series have barely even included any Black presence, and the victims are almost entirely White. Suddenly the killing of Black victims touches off a firestorm? Ridiculous.

    Report Abuse
  • You dont need to know's Avatar
    Posted by You dont need to know Sun Nov 1, 2009 7:47am PST

    Thank's for the info on these games. My ex got our 7 year old Halo and I had no idea what it was about. I even got it for my house off ebay with out reading about it. His teacher took me aside and told me to read up on it. Now the game is off the computer at my house and I have put it up for when he is the right age of it. I wish that I could say the game was off computer at the ex's house. I now know there is a age rateing on the games and that needs to be looked before you buy.

    Report Abuse
  • Nick's Avatar
    Posted by Nick Sun Nov 1, 2009 10:54am PST

    i love how the "violent games to avoid" get long descriptions and the alternatives none. this article should do a good job of building demand FOR the violent choices. and the complaint of "racist overtones" in resident evil is absurd. yes, now in the 5th game of the series you kill some black zombies -- oooh. the writers of this article should suffer the same violent deaths of the games they review.

    Report Abuse
  • Caitlin's Avatar
    Posted by Caitlin Sun Nov 1, 2009 2:44pm PST

    1) As many before me have said, just check the flipping ESRB rating on games. If you feel your child is mature enough to handle the content then let them try it other wise forget it.

    2) All the games on this list are rather sensationalistic and dare I say obvious choices. Everyone knows that GTA and Manhunt are violent games. You have to be living under a rock to know that every game on this list isn't meant for young children

    3) These alternatives aren't bad. Indeed I'm a huge fan of Prince of Persia and Punch Out but I have to question the choice of Prince of Persia. I mean even the more light hearted first installment includes a pseudo-sex scene.

    4) I started off on Spyro The Dragon when I was little which was perfect for me. Little kids need platformers, people! Platformers! (Now I play all kinds of stuff, though I tend towards RPGs.)

    Report Abuse
  • April's Avatar
    Posted by April Sun Nov 1, 2009 8:41pm PST

    I agree the alternatives don't make sense at all. And Resident Evil 5 is not racist. In fact, it was more racist before when there were only white zombies. Now it is an equal opportunity zombie killing game.

    And definitely, DON'T BY YOUR KID A MATURE RATED GAME! Everyone wants to blame the games but it is the parents... I used to manage a video game retail store and 95% of the time, no matter how hard I tried, the parents would buy mature rated games for their young children. I had one mom buy GTA for her 6 year old. NO LIE. I told everyone a list of all of the mature content and they still bought it... Think people!

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 19

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Updates Chatter on Shine…

parenting byte

When entrusting your child's health to a pediatrician, you are bound to have concerns about whether you are picking the right practice or doctor. Here are five questions to ask when choosing a pediatrician.