Parenting

Saturday, November 7, 2009

TMC Confessions & Answers with Brett Berk: Get the baby out of your bed!!!

TMC mom: Our baby is 13 mos old. She sleeps in her crib half the night and in our bed the other half. I want my room back! I want my sex life back. I want privacy. I want to sleep more than two hours at a time.

Uncle Brett:

If your baby is 13 months old, my guess is that she's probably not a particularly competent walker--and that her perambulatory capabilities are significantly diminished when she's asleep--so I'm willing to put money on the assumption that if she's getting into your bed with you half-way through the night, she's not doing so of her own accord or on her own power.  Given this supposition, the reverse is also likely true: that once she is in your bed, she's not skilled, capable, or motivated enough to remove herself from it, and clamber back into her crib.  My conclusion therefore is that you are the one bringing her into your bed half- way through the night.  If this is the case, the solution to your sleep, privacy, and intercourse-related issues is simple: Don't bring her into your bed half-way through the night.  Next question?

In all seriousness, your daughter is not going to "solve" this problem for you--especially since you're the one who's creating the dilemma.  You have to take charge of it (and yourself.)  If she cries, go over to her crib and comfort her--pet her or feed or turn on her Fisher-Price Crib Pal Soothing Music Generator--but do it there, and then leave her there.  She might cry.  She might cry a lot.  You can go back and lovingly reassure her another time if you want.  But then walk away.  My sister was in your situation for months.  When she followed my advice, it took exactly one noisy night for her daughter to learn to sleep on her own.  Your child may take longer, but in order to know, you have to grab the reins and start the process.  You don't want to be one of those moms (and they really exist) making this same complaint about their 13 year old.

Have your own baby in the bed confessions?? Share them in the confessional!

*Brett Berk, M.S.Ed has worked with young children and families for over twenty years, and is the author of The Gay Uncle's Guide to Parenting (Random House, 2008).  Visit him at www.askgayuncle.com

More on TMC:

How do I stop hating the ex wife?

I've never carried pictures of my kids with me!

Pre-teen years = invasion of the body snatchers! Help!








Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 25
  • Allswell's Avatar
    Posted by Allswell Mon Nov 10, 2008 6:37am PST

    I have to agree with Brett on this one...If you allow your child to sleep in bed with you, you are in for a rough road ahead. It may take a few nights to get her into a routine and ajusted, but a few nights is well worth it over a few years. Take the advice and get her out of your bed ASAP!

    Report Abuse
  • Saku's Avatar
    Posted by Saku Mon Nov 10, 2008 11:18am PST

    I agree also with Brett, becuase I know my sister has a 12 year old son who will cry and get very violent when nshe will not sleep in his bed. it is such a sad sight, but sometimes i can't help but laugh everytime she complains sbout it. so take care of that problem BEFORE they become adolescents

    Report Abuse
  • HotCrossBuns's Avatar
    Posted by HotCrossBuns Mon Nov 10, 2008 1:05pm PST

    omg...I actually agree with Brett on something! Times they are a-changin'!!! hehe

    Although I did keep my newborns in bed with me after the middle of the night nursing sessions, I evicted them to their own crib by the time they were a couple of months old. I think both infants and toddlers sleep longer and more soundly when they have their own bed to themselves.

    Report Abuse
  • Janet's Avatar
    Posted by Janet Mon Nov 10, 2008 2:21pm PST

    A friend of mine wants to send her 2 year old child into surgery for sleep apnea but I suggested she try dealing with his all night, every hour on the hour screams for mommy, behaviorially first! Starting by checking hers. Easier said than done. Brett you rock!

    Report Abuse
  • MistressMinx's Avatar
    Posted by MistressMinx Tue Nov 11, 2008 6:01am PST

    I disagree (as usual). My daughter is 9 and still sleeps with me. Of course, her dad and I aren't together and there isn't any "adult activity" going on in my bed. Still, its called the "family bed" and it isn't wrong. People in the U.S. are so hung up with this notion. I want my daughter to grow up confident and self-assured. One way to accomplish this is letting her know that I'm there for her - 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.

    No, she doesn't cling at any other time. She has friends and loves school. She is intelligent, an avid reader and has her hobbies. She plays at her friends and even spends the night there. But, we spend our days apart. I think she uses this time to re-connect with me and to feel close to me.

    I know she will eventually gain her independence and will no longer stay in my bed. Until then, I'm happy to just be able to cherish my little girl, while she is still little. All too soon these moments will be gone.

    Report Abuse
  • heartland canuck's Avatar
    Posted by heartland canuck Tue Nov 11, 2008 7:00am PST

    The family bed is a choice, not a dysfunction. My son is 7 months old and still sleeps with Mom 'n Dad. Why? I like to sleep. Breastfeeding was just too tiring when he slept in a bassinette. I had to get up, grab the boppy pillow and sit a chair whenever the little guy was hungry. Now, if he wants a snack in the night, he can just hooks up to the tap. No crying, no fuss. I saw no point in "putting him on a feeding schedule," to fit my own needs.

    We do not use sleep aids or go to bed drunk and are not heavy or restless sleepers. He will not get rolled on. We have a big enough bed that our son can spread-eagle between us. My husband and I use separate throw blankets instead of a big comforter so the baby will not get smothered or over-heated.

    My Mom is all hung-up that he should be sleeping in his crib at night. But then again, she was a bit shocked the first time she saw me nurse in public. (Why should I have to pump and pack a picnic every time we leave the house? ) She'll get over it.

    Report Abuse
  • Magen's Avatar
    Posted by Magen Tue Nov 11, 2008 8:55am PST

    Ok Mistress Minx and Heartland Canuck...it's great that you have a family bed and that works for you. However, the issue here is that the person asking Brett the question doesn't WANT a family bed situation, in fact the child doesn't start the evening in bed with the parents. This isn't about beding against or for family beds...although I'm sure it will turn into that. This is about someone is having issues with getting their child to sleep in the crib the whole night as they would like. Oh and I have a sister who did a family bed until her son was 2 so I understand the merits of it, but if it's not something you want or are uncomfortable with, then it's simply not going to work for your family...in fact it will probably lead to more issues because one or both parents are unhappy.

    Report Abuse
  • Science mama's Avatar
    Posted by Science mama Tue Nov 11, 2008 9:01am PST

    To those saying that the family bed is not a dysfunction, that is true. However, the person writing in for advice is saying they don't want their baby in their bed anymore. If this parent is not getting more than 2 hours sleep at a time, they are probably having a hard time functioning. This is not saying anything against people who want a family bed, but Brett is giving advice to someone who does not want it anymore.

    Report Abuse
  • Paula K's Avatar
    Posted by Paula K Tue Nov 11, 2008 10:07am PST

    It's hard, but you have to force the child to realize his/her bed in their room is THEIR space. My son is 6 and creeps into my bed occasionally and I let him as a special treat. But he also knows that I can say "no" and he must stay in his own bed. He knows I am there for him 24/7, he knows that if he is sick or scared we will rock and snuggle, but he also knows his bed is for him. I buy sheets and blankets that he likes to make it HIS space.

    You put them in their bed/crib in THEIR room (not YOURS), you pat them, tell 'em you love them, re-affirm a few times, but you leave them. That family bed thing was great when we lived on the prairy in the 1800's in a one room shack.

    Report Abuse
  • Shana R's Avatar
    Posted by Shana R Tue Nov 11, 2008 10:10am PST

    You and your spouses' bed should be just that... Yours and your spouses... No kid anything in your bedroom!!! Either you keep having your child in your bed for sleepless night after sleepless night, or you lose sleep for a few nights making sure your little one is in their own bed. No family bed!

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 25

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Updates Chatter on Shine…

parenting byte

When entrusting your child's health to a pediatrician, you are bound to have concerns about whether you are picking the right practice or doctor. Here are five questions to ask when choosing a pediatrician.