Parenting

Thursday, December 3, 2009

TMC Confessions & Answers with Brett Berk: Get the baby out of your bed!!!

TMC mom: Our baby is 13 mos old. She sleeps in her crib half the night and in our bed the other half. I want my room back! I want my sex life back. I want privacy. I want to sleep more than two hours at a time.

Uncle Brett:

If your baby is 13 months old, my guess is that she's probably not a particularly competent walker--and that her perambulatory capabilities are significantly diminished when she's asleep--so I'm willing to put money on the assumption that if she's getting into your bed with you half-way through the night, she's not doing so of her own accord or on her own power.  Given this supposition, the reverse is also likely true: that once she is in your bed, she's not skilled, capable, or motivated enough to remove herself from it, and clamber back into her crib.  My conclusion therefore is that you are the one bringing her into your bed half- way through the night.  If this is the case, the solution to your sleep, privacy, and intercourse-related issues is simple: Don't bring her into your bed half-way through the night.  Next question?

In all seriousness, your daughter is not going to "solve" this problem for you--especially since you're the one who's creating the dilemma.  You have to take charge of it (and yourself.)  If she cries, go over to her crib and comfort her--pet her or feed or turn on her Fisher-Price Crib Pal Soothing Music Generator--but do it there, and then leave her there.  She might cry.  She might cry a lot.  You can go back and lovingly reassure her another time if you want.  But then walk away.  My sister was in your situation for months.  When she followed my advice, it took exactly one noisy night for her daughter to learn to sleep on her own.  Your child may take longer, but in order to know, you have to grab the reins and start the process.  You don't want to be one of those moms (and they really exist) making this same complaint about their 13 year old.

Have your own baby in the bed confessions?? Share them in the confessional!

*Brett Berk, M.S.Ed has worked with young children and families for over twenty years, and is the author of The Gay Uncle's Guide to Parenting (Random House, 2008).  Visit him at www.askgayuncle.com

More on TMC:

How do I stop hating the ex wife?

I've never carried pictures of my kids with me!

Pre-teen years = invasion of the body snatchers! Help!








Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 11-20 of 25
  • SandraW's Avatar
    Posted by SandraW Tue Nov 11, 2008 4:06pm PST

    Its not alright to have this sleeping situation going on any further,you should try to whine the child from sleeping in the same bed as you and your spouse slowly, using the phrase big boys/girl need to sleep in their bed. For the first couple of nights stay in the room and comfort him/her by rubbing their back humming or singing to them til they are sound asleep. To get them into a rountine of their own to fall asleep by themselves in their own bed, and not to suffer from separation anxieties.

    Report Abuse
  • Amanda's Avatar
    Posted by Amanda Tue Nov 11, 2008 4:28pm PST

    Ok, I kind of take offense at the assumption that since the child is only 13 mo old that Mom or Dad has to be "helping" the tot. I can tell you that ALL 3 of my kids were walking by 9 or 10 mo old AND they were all climbing out of their cribs with it in its lowest setting and nothing to aid them up and over by the time they were 11 mo. They also could climb up into my bed *without help*. My first two were easy to break of the habit, but my youngest is proving to be even more difficult. How do you break the habit of a 3 YR old who climbs into bed, and if you try to put her back in her own bed she comes back? There is no crib to keep her contained. We go back and forth night, after night, after night, after night. She doesn't just cry it out and she won't stay there either. What then?

    Report Abuse
  • Kate W's Avatar
    Posted by Kate W Tue Nov 11, 2008 5:28pm PST

    I think anyone who has an older baby/child sleeping with them is doing it more-so for their own comfort rather than the child's. After a few months a baby is capable, and SHOULD be sleeping through the night. Bad sleep habits are caused by parents who would rather take the easy way than just tough it out for a few nights while their kids get used to sleeping on their own. Your spoiling your kids... yes... yes your are.

    Report Abuse
  • DMLady's Avatar
    Posted by DMLady Tue Nov 11, 2008 5:51pm PST

    ok, so for those who think that there is no problem with having your child/children sleep with them each and every night, let me ask you a question. what do you do, then, when you and your spouse want a bit of intimacy? just roll junior over? or have you and your spouse already gotten rid of that aspect of marriage/

    Report Abuse
  • Katja C's Avatar
    Posted by Katja C Tue Nov 11, 2008 8:23pm PST

    Can we stop being so judgemental? Moms have gotta do what works for us, and during those baby/toddler times, we all just need to concentrate on getting as much sleep as humanly possible. If having your kid in your bed keeps you up, then by all means do whatever you have to do to get him to sleep alone. If your kid wakes you up crying every 2 hours when they sleep alone, but sleep soundly in your bed (that's my situation, and I get a lot of crap for it, but I get WAY more sleep than most moms I know!), then let 'em! Who are you hurting? My son's starting nursery school next year, so I know our life will need to be overhauled, but, honestly, for the last two years, we've had it pretty nice! We stay up until midnight and sleep soundly until 10 am or so. It may be anethema to other moms, but it works for us, and that's all you should care about in how you parent. If you and your child are rested, happy, healthy and relaxed, you're doing fine. I'm so sick of everyone condemning each others parenting choices. If I'm not shooting my son up with heroin and letting him play with chain saws, what do you care?

    Report Abuse
  • Becky's Avatar
    Posted by Becky Wed Nov 12, 2008 7:08am PST

    My son crie for 45 minutes the 1st time he slept the whole night in his crib. He slept with me until he was 3 months old. So, it was a transition and it took more than one night for him to adjust, but it was much easier for him by the end of the 1st week. He sleeps more soundly in his own bed :O)

    Report Abuse
  • Donna's Avatar
    Posted by Donna Wed Nov 12, 2008 7:10am PST

    My sons slept with my husband and myself until they didn't want to anymore, so the older they got, it was more like a special night here and there. It never had an adverse effect on our romantic interludes; we just snuck out. By the time they were 5 or 6, they didn't want to sleep with us anymore. I really think Americans are overly concerned about this natural event. I have a friend from Thailand, and she slept with her brothers, sisters and parents until she was married herself. She really is quite healthy and happy; not to mention a strong bible-believing christian.

    Report Abuse
  • Doll's Avatar
    Posted by Doll Wed Nov 12, 2008 7:30am PST

    My son is 7, and the only time he sleeps in my bed is when my husband is away on business trips. This is bonding time for us. We lay there and talk about life, we giggle, and it is also a time when my son can ask me questions that he might be embarrassed about (since it's dark he doesn't have to look at me when he asks, so it is easier for him to talk about embarrassing stuff).

    As a baby and toddler, we did not have him in our bed very often, so it has not been a problem for us.

    Report Abuse
  • Rowdygirl's Avatar
    Posted by Rowdygirl Wed Nov 12, 2008 7:49am PST

    Get her out of there.. My niece is 11 and still sleeping with her mom...

    Report Abuse
  • Caramel Cake's Avatar
    Posted by Caramel Cake Wed Nov 12, 2008 7:52am PST

    I ahve been trying fo rmonths to get my 10 month old back in his bed, but his father seems to disagree. It makes the whole night very uncomfortable, there are feet in his face, then you have to worry about whether or not you are laying on him; that's it! He is going back in his bed tonight!

    Report Abuse
Comments 11-20 of 25

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Updates Chatter on Shine…

parenting byte

When entrusting your child's health to a pediatrician, you are bound to have concerns about whether you are picking the right practice or doctor. Here are five questions to ask when choosing a pediatrician.