Love + Sex

Sunday, December 6, 2009

Dating diaries: A theory on why long distance relationships don't work

I have a lot of friends who are questioning whether their long distance relationships are worth the trouble. Ever since I tried it (even though I was 18 and it was only about an hour's drive distance), I've sworn I'd never try it again.

I've developed a theory on what makes a strong relationship. It's called the Down Time-Crisis Theory. Take a look, and tell me if you agree with it or disagree. It is the main reason why most long distance relationships don't work.

The Downtime-Crisis Theory states that no relationship is strong and complete without a sufficient amount of down time spent together along with crisis situations.

Everyone has fun on big event dates. Let's say you are compatible and have a great time together. So, you got out on a lot of big event dates: dinners, weddings, Broadway shows, movies, etc. Who doesn't enjoy a wonderful meal at a great restaurant? The argument can even be made that a great dinner or Broadway show makes your companion even more attractive. I mean, an awesome dinner and show would make even Darth Vader bearable.

Darth Vader

Would you let this guy take you to a Broadway show?

This thinking lends credence to the idea that relationships gather strength during down time. You're not hitting the best bars and restaurants, traveling to beautiful seaside towns, or frequenting top-tier art openings. You are taking walks, vegging in front of the TV, running errands together, maybe cooking dinner at home and watching a movie. The smaller things without the fanfare put more focus on your conversation. Walking around in jeans and socks in your apartment with your significant other feels much more down-to-earth than appearing together at a black tie event. Of course big dates are wonderful and a necessary part of a relationship. But if it's disproportionate to the down time you spend together, you may not get a good read on how compatible you are.

The crisis part of the theory states that you must go through crises together to understand how compatible you are. In an earlier post I mentioned running out of gas together. It can be any sort of crisis such as babysitting a friend's poorly behaved child together, getting stuck with a creepy person at a wedding table, running out of money in a foreign country on a trip together, or getting dragged to a Celine Dion concert with friends. How do you guys work it out? Do you work together as a team, and find the humor in it jokingly blaming each other or playfully taking credit for solutions? Or do you freak out and blame each other, proposing theories like: If you had just listened to me, this would have worked out. Also stated in a previous post: crisis situations can actually turn out to be some of the most romantic times of our lives.

Celine Dion

Crisis: Trapped at a Celine Dion Concert

So you want to try the long distance thing. It may not work in light of my Down Time-Crisis Theory. When you see one another, you re always going to be on the go.

OK, you're coming to town, we have to go to dinner here, see my parents here (which actually might give you a chance for crisis), see this show, and (wow there's only a week together we need to squeeze all of these activities into a short amount of time)...

There's no down time. No calling up on a whim and watching TV together or making dinner together or going on a spontaneous day trip or picnic. And, even if you can, separation is inevitable because the visiting significant other must go back to wherever they live.

Plenty of regular non-long-distance relationships suffer because people are always on the go and don t take the time to actually get to know each other. The Down Time-Crisis Theory simply says that you need to have low stress time and high stress time together to really get to know each other. Long distance doesn't permit that time. However, plenty of long distance relationships work. So, those of you who have successfully accomplished it how have you done it? And, also, do you all agree or disagree with my Down Time-Crisis Theory?


Posted by Rich



Related links from Marie Claire:

25 Beauty Products That Will Change Your Life
Enter to Win a Giveaway-A-Day
Virtual Hair Salon: Try on a Hairstyle
MC Psychic - Ask Advice, Get a Free Reading
Looking for More Love, Fitness & Career Advice? Subscribe to Marie Claire & Save!

Reprinted with Permission of Hearst Communications, Inc.
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 20
  • __A_YAHOO_USER__'s Avatar
    Posted by __A_YAHOO_USER__ Mon Apr 28, 2008 7:36am PDT

    Just look at all the celebrity divorces. They're always in different countries, spending too much time apart and when they finally talk about why the relationship failed, they almost always say that they grew apart & the relationship couldn't withstand the distance.

    I guess if it were me and I was living on my own, doing everything by myself, dealing with life's problems alone, then why do I need someone else? High phone bills and no sex? I prefer online dating than distance love, You can find me and my photos at BlackWhiteKiss .c om where i met many handsome black and white men ..

    Report Abuse
  • __A_YAHOO_USER__'s Avatar
    Posted by __A_YAHOO_USER__ Mon Apr 28, 2008 9:07am PDT

    I think it depends on how long the LD relationship lasts...

    For me, in the beginning, of course, it is no doubt high-energy weekends of going here, there and everywhere around town. But after a few months, let alone years, that activity stops, and those high-energy weekends turn to chillaxing in front of the TV with take-out, or challenging one another's educational skills with a game of Scrabble. If the relationships last, there is no doubt that crises will arise. Probably not as many crises as a couple that live in the same city or town, but I think, it if last long enough, with time people in LD relationships can have the same shared experiences as those who are not.

    Report Abuse
  • jaja's Avatar
    Posted by jaja Mon Apr 28, 2008 9:28am PDT

    im in a long distance relationship and i have to say that it depends on the love... my boyfriend and i have been together 5yrs now... we have a daughter even tho hes not here to see her all the time we love each other spend alotta time getting to know each other and seeing our differences. even tho i am only 19 i can say i dont honestly agree that LD relationship dont work... celebs always have people wanting them (not saying that there arent guys that want me) but i know how to handle mself and so does my boyfriend so we can be honest and not cheat

    Report Abuse
  • Beth's Avatar
    Posted by Beth Mon Apr 28, 2008 12:43pm PDT

    I think that is a pretty good theory. There are of course always exceptions to the rule. My boyfriend and I started off in a long distance relationship that lasted a year, then we moved in together and have been for 8 years. I think I enjoyed the long distance relationship better lol because they take the time to give you those big dates. hehe

    Report Abuse
  • Brunette Princess's Avatar
    Posted by Brunette Princess Mon Apr 28, 2008 1:30pm PDT

    Im in one now and have been for about 5 months....I will let you know how it turns out, lol

    Report Abuse
  • Kimberly's Avatar
    Posted by Kimberly Mon Apr 28, 2008 4:15pm PDT

    I agree with the comment on the love in the relationship... and you have to remember going into a L.D.R. is a big commitment... You both need to sit down and talk about what you expect to happen with the relationship and what you both need in the relationship... and yes while it does suck that you can't have sex... you can do creative and imaginative things for one another... (ex. sexy pics. or phone sex) that can help... plus things like web cams, chatting online and talking on the phone really gives you time to talk to the individual to see if you have more in common than just sex. The great part is there are free online programs that you can use to talk to your boyfriend/girlfriend for free... Example would be SKYPE it is a great way you can make phone calls to people all over the world.... after all it is what you make out of the relationship that will make it last! :-) But I do agree with your theory about the down time but it depends on the relationship and how much time you spend together... and it takes both parties to want to be in the relationship... and yes I am speaking from experience ;-)

    Report Abuse
  • Calypso's Avatar
    Posted by Calypso Mon Apr 28, 2008 4:29pm PDT

    totally disagree! I was in an LDR for a year -- west coast to east and back and we had up time and down time. We never had the urge to always be on the move. We both have kids (teens/tweens) so we had to tend to their needs as well. Movies, dinners out or at home, walks on the beach or in the city, museums on both coasts -- it was fine. The downtime we had, while we couldn't be physically spontaneous which was sometimes a drag, was phone time and emails. Phone was great as it forced us to really talk when we couldn't be together. So we learned how to communicate -- which a lot of couples on a day to day basis don't do. I'm not saying LDRs don't have their challenges, but i really think its about the people in the relationship and what they want to do with their time -- be it down or up

    Report Abuse
  • Candie's Avatar
    Posted by Candie Mon Apr 28, 2008 5:36pm PDT

    I agree with this article. I've been in a long distance relationship for 1 year and 9 months. I agree with this article because LDR's aren't for everyone. It depends on the couple and their committment. My boyfriend lives 3 hours away from me and we are both busy with school and work such, but we make time for each other. I said that I agreed with this because you can't always be on the go. My boyfriend and I make it a point to spend at least 1 day just us two whenever we get the chance to see each other. LDR's can't be done by many people, but those who really care about their significant other can do it!

    Report Abuse
  • Diva-lish's Avatar
    Posted by Diva-lish Mon Apr 28, 2008 11:11pm PDT

    I have been talking to a guy who lives 4 hours away since September of 2007. We speak almost daily, but have not had a face-to-face as of yet. We have learned quite a bit about one another in this time, and plan to get togther next month. I feel like this has been our down time. I know that we will go out a couple of nights, but I also plan to experience downtime with him while we are together. As far as how we react in "pressure situations", I guess that will come in time. I will continue to pursue our relationship, and will post when I have more to add.

    Report Abuse
  • 's Avatar
    Posted by Tue Apr 29, 2008 8:47pm PDT

    i definitely agree. my boyfriend lives 8 hours away, and we haven't been dating THAT long i guess (10 months, but it seems like longer!). it's really tough, but we try to see each other as much as possible, and i feel like we've had a good balance of tough times to our down time. i'm moving to his town in august, so i'm anxious to see how a REAL relationship will work (he is my first boyfriend) with seeing each other all the time. i feel like the phone is an important tool, because it gives you the chance to actually get to know each other, without the temptation of physical aspects of a relationship.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 20

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Updates Chatter on Shine…

Love Byte

Skip the multiple-choice quiz, and read up on if you're a mom, a nag, too clingy, or perfect in every way. Aren't we all?