Love + Sex

Friday, December 11, 2009

Do you overanalyze your love life?

Recently, I wrote an essay in a very public forum about a past relationship. I know, I know, I do that all the time here, exploring the awkward, the anecdotal, the everything, but this blog doesn't have my full name attached, and, as such, feels more private, as if I'm speaking to a large (virtual) circle of friends. This particular essay, on the other hand, used my real name-first and last-and the guy's real first name. For the month after it was published, I held my breath, both hoping and not hoping the guy in question would read it.

Thankfully, while plenty of other ghosts from the past (ex-roommates, middle school english teachers, my best friend from first grade's mom) found it, he didn't. And while I was proud of the piece, I still felt a little guilty, that I had in some way, betrayed him. And, strictly speaking, I did. And, even more strictly speaking, I would do it again in a heartbeat.

Sometimes I wonder if I'd have better luck, relationship wise, if I didn't talk so much about what was going on, as it was happening. I say I do this because I'm a writer, but I don't think that's entirely correct. It doesn't take too much analyzing to realize that, more likely than not, I'm doing it because dating is inherently so full of uncertainty and roasting someone behind their back-talking about a gross habit, a bad date, etc, etc, etc-to other people at least makes you feel less alone.

And I'm not alone. I feel everyone does that in the beginning of a relationship-picks apart their potential partner in front of their friends, analyzes their weird tics and confessions-and, when observing my friends, I always find it so interesting and telling when that stops; when suddenly, their relationship and what goes on behind closed doors becomes more or less private.

For the most part, I'm fine-ish with living out loud. But I'm still trying to navigate the somewhat tenuous line between PRIVATE PRIVATE and personal, but not private.

What about you? Do you have any tips for how to keep the balance in check when it comes to talking about your romantic/sex life?


Posted by Alice


Redbook
* Get More on Love, Family & Fashion - Subscribe to Redbook & Save up to 82%!
* Don't-Tell-the-Wife Secrets All Men Keep
* 21 Little Sex Moves That Will Rock Your World
* Marriage Makeover -- Our Renovation Is Ruining Our Marriage
* Take Your Sex Life to the Next Level


Reprinted with Permission of Hearst Communications, Inc.
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 19
  • princess's Avatar
    Posted by princess Mon Nov 10, 2008 1:35pm PST

    There are some things that I NEVER reveal, such as if he is good in bed or penis size (especially if its huge!)I do discuss things like how well he treats me, his romantic side, etc...(I like to brag about my Man!!)

    Report Abuse
  • Richard's Avatar
    Posted by Richard Mon Nov 10, 2008 3:05pm PST

    i can,t find one that, like me

    Report Abuse
  • 's Avatar
    Posted by Mon Nov 10, 2008 3:09pm PST

    Well if you don't mind me saying so, SHINE constantly puts emphasis on analyzing sex, yours, mine and his. You name it they've broached the subject and to my delight. :-)

    Report Abuse
  • opiniononly's Avatar
    Posted by opiniononly Mon Nov 10, 2008 4:37pm PST

    If you feel a need to discuss your personal life in a public forum, no matter how it is defined (i-net or print), I would think that without express permission, any reference to another person should be as an alias.

    That being said, far too many people prefer to over-analyze their relationships instead of actually just having it. Discussions with friends about what was said, what wasn't, what it meant...all have the potential to create problems where there aren't any and artifically escalate issues to ridiculous proportions. Most issues that get discussed could be resolved if, instead of talking to everyone else, the conversation would happen between the parties involved. If you can't/won't have the conversation with your lover/partner, you shouldn't be having it with others.

    "It doesn't take too much analyzing to realize that, more likely than not, I'm doing it because dating is inherently so full of uncertainty and roasting someone behind their back-talking about a gross habit, a bad date, etc, etc, etc-to other people at least makes you feel less alone."

    Sounds to me like you have two problems to resolve....1) You have some boundary/discretion issues that cause you to talk too much, and 2) you talk too much because you have a self-confidence problem. If you resolve the second, the first will disappear.

    Report Abuse
  • opiniononly's Avatar
    Posted by opiniononly Mon Nov 10, 2008 4:40pm PST

    If you feel a need to discuss your personal life in a public forum, no matter how it is defined (i-net or print), I would think that without express permission, any reference to another person should be as an alias.

    That being said, far too many people prefer to over-analyze their relationships instead of actually just having it. Discussions with friends about what was said, what wasn't, what it meant...all have the potential to create problems where there aren't any and artifically escalate issues to ridiculous proportions. Most issues that get discussed could be resolved if, instead of talking to everyone else, the conversation would happen between the parties involved. If you can't/won't have the conversation with your lover/partner, you shouldn't be having it with others.

    "It doesn't take too much analyzing to realize that, more likely than not, I'm doing it because dating is inherently so full of uncertainty and roasting someone behind their back-talking about a gross habit, a bad date, etc, etc, etc-to other people at least makes you feel less alone."

    Sounds to me like you have two problems to resolve....1) You have some boundary/discretion issues that cause you to talk too much, and 2) you talk too much because you have a self-confidence problem. If you resolve the second, the first will disappear.

    Report Abuse
  • Rae's Avatar
    Posted by Rae Mon Nov 10, 2008 5:16pm PST

    If you reveal penis size then get ready to break up. Unless you are saying that he is so good that it dosent matter...then brag.

    If you reveal too much about what kinks you guys are into then watch out, he may end up with your best friend because he IS the bomb or his best friend is hitting you up because you do something his girlfriend wont do. Watch out for that one.

    If you rag on him expect him to find out. Nothing is ever secret unless it dosent come out period. Otherwise you might find you are stuck having to explain why you dont like his dress style, or his kiss, or his dog, or whatever it is that your spilling out to friends. Make sure you have expressed the issue to him at least once before you tell anyone else, because people do NOT like being the last ones to know about personal problems.

    Oh and try to keep your financial issues out of the picture. Unless your starving and cant pay the rent you really need to suck it up and keep the trap shut about spending habits. Everybody has an opionion about money and if your not happy then break it off and go out with Warren Buffett or something but dont drag your partner through credit h*ll with your friends. At least not untill its OVER.

    Other than that, your friends can keep you good with him if you vent to them and then go home happy to be in a relationship. I think that guys just hate to be nagged/complained to, its a fix it or be quiet untill its fixed kind of thing for them. Just remember what you share will come back so you had better keep it to things that you can handle if returned right in front of your sweety. Take Care-Rachel.

    Report Abuse
  • Bobbylane's Avatar
    Posted by Bobbylane Mon Nov 10, 2008 6:12pm PST

    a secret is always best as just that a 'secret' , when you begin the journey of bragging about how cute this new one is how you are beaming with such confidence ,remember one thing . Other women will see that and will ither cut you down in the middle of beam or will make you think the whole relationship totally wrong which will cause self doubt in you.

    In the way the society is constantly changing and the totally backstabbing that does take place over frivolous jealousy, its good to just keep a good steady head on the goal at the end of the tunnel,and not on the drawn out self proclaimed bragging that some women tend to do.Besides, if it doesn't work out, you feel as stupid I would think.

    Report Abuse
  • Cosmo's Avatar
    Posted by Cosmo Mon Nov 10, 2008 6:22pm PST

    Hmmm, first up I can't understand why some people love talking about their relationships to everybody all the time. It doesn't become special when the story is discussed repeatedly and you risk putting your partner in a negative light.

    My colleague goes on about her new husband who is unfortunately irresponsible with money. We're all sympathetic and offer advice, but honestly, we do see him in a diffrent light after the stories.

    Most people think they have Titanic Love Sagas, but the truth is, the only people really interested to know about it are the two people in it.

    I'd choose my closest friends and vent.

    Report Abuse
  • Finejonz's Avatar
    Posted by Finejonz Mon Nov 10, 2008 11:49pm PST

    I'm a very reserved individual so I don't discuss my personal business in regards to my romantic relationships no matter how serious. If I feel like venting I usually tell someone who's impartial to the situation and that way I get a unbiased answer without the drama. My dude and I keep our relationship very private we don't let outside people corrupt our relationship. If we have an issue with eachother we talk about it and try to find some common ground or we give eachother space. However we both have aggressive personalities and don't like to keep things bottled in too long. Sometime's he's very passive and avoids certain issues and I always end up being the bad guy. At the end of the day its about respect, trust and honesty. I'm content in knowing that we have a strong bond and care about eachother.

    Report Abuse
  • Nose's Avatar
    Posted by Nose Tue Nov 11, 2008 3:28am PST

    If I have a problem with the boyfriend, I talk to him about him first. I also have a therapist who I can vent on as well as a few close friends who I trust will be honest with me as well as supportive, but they will tell me if I'm wrong or whatever. Shoot......I'm still analyzing what went wrong with the last relationship as my awareness of things is so much clearer since I've been out of that one. And past relationships affect a current one when one carries over some of the conditionings and paradigms that have been set in place. By understanding what happened and how, you can improve the current relationship. I'm trying to get used to being treated so well by the boyfriend...I'm not used to that. It's weird.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 19

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Love Byte

Skip the multiple-choice quiz, and read up on if you're a mom, a nag, too clingy, or perfect in every way. Aren't we all?