Love + Sex

Sunday, December 6, 2009

Do you try to be a good daughter-in-law?

Because the Jen/Brad/Angelina saga will never die, there was a story up on MSNBC today called "Brad Pitt’s mom prefers Aniston to Jolie." In it, a "source" reveals, "Jane [Pitt's mom] has seen, first hand, how difficult Angelina is. She never comes to visit the family in Missouri and is always prickly on the rare occasions they have got together. Jennifer was the total opposite — charming, friendly and the perfect daughter-in-law. She always made time to be an active part of the family, whereas Angie just turns her nose up.”

Whether or not this is actually true, we'll never know. Though it does seem plausible, if only because Jennifer Aniston seems like the kind of girl who wants a person's mom to like her, and Angelina seems, well, not like that kind of girl.

That's not to say either type is bad. It's just that the mother-in-law/daughter-in-law relationship is tricky and can be difficult to navigate, and the burden of keeping this connection peaceful and happy (sadly or not) usually falls on the son's wife.

I know I work on my relationship with my mother-in-law, I'm on my best behavior when I'm around her--I'm considerate, attentive, and thoughtful. I remember birthdays and holidays, send thank-you notes, call to check in, set up visits, and I help clean up after big family meals. I put more effort into this than I do with my own family, but that's because it's important to me to have things between us be pleasant and peaceful for many, many years to come. I respect her and, more, I respect my husband, and I don't ever want him to deal with the extra stress that a conflict between me and and his mother would cause. Whenever I see friends engage in really ugly arguments about their in-laws, I always think these are fights no one can win.

Is there something about this that's old-fashioned? Sexist? Icky in a wife-bot way? I don't know, but the nice, friendly Jen Aniston version of a daughter-in-law has always seemed to me like the smartest--not to mention the most polite--way to go.

How do you manage your mother-in-law?

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 181-189 of 189
  • ReAune S's Avatar
    Posted by ReAune S Tue Jun 30, 2009 10:32pm PDT

    sigh.... i hate my mother law. but one day she will grow old, wither and make food for worms... so everything works out in the end.

    Report Abuse
  • Courtney E's Avatar
    Posted by Courtney E Wed Jul 1, 2009 7:24am PDT

    My MIL is my total opposite. She's loud, controlling, never holds her tongue, and insists she's right even when proven wrong by multiple sources. She caused my own mom to spend most of my wedding reception in tears. She also tends to shoot down anything i try to do as a new wife/mother. But she LOVES her family... even me! So I bite my tongue, vent only when necessary, and pick my battles carefully. It's taken time, but we've learned how to handle each other (somewhat!) and she's showing more respect toward me.

    Report Abuse
  • Michele's Avatar
    Posted by Michele Wed Jul 1, 2009 11:47am PDT

    I liked My MIL better then my husband, soon to be ex-. Next time I'll marry the man not the family...

    Report Abuse
  • TabithaB's Avatar
    Posted by TabithaB Thu Jul 2, 2009 3:11am PDT

    i get along pretty well with my MIL. she's actually a nice person. we live too far from each other to visit but we email and talk on the phone so it's all good. there have been times when i've actually preferred my inlaws over my actual parents. i figure if she's nice and respectful to me then i should be nice and respectful back.

    Report Abuse
  • Carrie's Avatar
    Posted by Carrie Thu Jul 2, 2009 7:57am PDT

    I avoid her at all possible costs.

    Report Abuse
  • sibaby's Avatar
    Posted by sibaby Thu Jul 2, 2009 8:56am PDT

    i don't get along with my mil she dont call or everning chatting when i am at her place,everytime when i called she can't tell me anything or evening when i bought her things she does not bored to thank me,what she does is to sms his son and thank him about those things which are from me.And its always comes between me and my husband and when it comes to money i always think of divorce coz i don't evening know what he does with it coz his mother told him not to gove me his money

    Report Abuse
  • sun2go's Avatar
    Posted by sun2go Thu Jul 2, 2009 9:40am PDT

    A good daughter-in-law has been made to feel welcome, and she reciprocates the kindness & love extended. I never got that, so I've never gone out of my way with my MIL, and neither has she with me. She told relatives that it's MY job to reach out. I feel it's the in-laws' job to make the newcomer feel welcome in the family, it is not the newcomer's job to try to win over everyone and do a dog & pony show for them. If you love your son, and the woman your son chose to marry makes him happy, you have the problem if you want your DIL to jump through hoops to get along with you. She's not the girl you wanted your son to marry? Tough, it's not your life to control, it's HIS life to do as he pleases.

    Report Abuse
  • Red's Avatar
    Posted by Red Thu Jul 2, 2009 1:31pm PDT

    I hated my MIL..She tried to convince my ex husband that our baby was not his, set up a fake personal account in my name, and then disapeared for 2yrs and blamed it on me.(hence the reason for the divorce...ladies stay away from only child men) I would probably run her over with my car if I saw her walking across the street

    Report Abuse
  • jane's Avatar
    Posted by jane Tue Jul 14, 2009 2:25am PDT

    I am a mother in law to be to my sons serious GF. I have an unusual situation and wonder if anyone else can relate. My relationship with sons GF was amazing to the point of people who didnt know us thinking we were mother and daughter. I have no jelousy of my sons lovely relationship at all! The problem is sons GFs own mother who is jelous of my relationship with her daughter and tries to put her daughter against me by criticising everything I do or say,to the point of colouring GFs thoughts about me .What was once a fantastic relationship is turning a bit sour all because of a third party (her mum) who would prefer it if her daughter didnt get along with me! This is so sad, so I intend to communicate as much as possible with sons GF to make sure the poor girl never feels guilty for getting on with me or that she is betraying her own mum by doing so! If anyone can relate to this I would love to hear about it,even from mothers of daughters who may just recognise this and admit to it!!

    Report Abuse
Comments 181-189 of 189

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Updates Chatter on Shine…

Love Byte

Skip the multiple-choice quiz, and read up on if you're a mom, a nag, too clingy, or perfect in every way. Aren't we all?