Love + Sex

Saturday, December 5, 2009

Girl Talk: Is It Bad To Live Together Before Marriage?

http://static.thefrisky.com/images/uploads/moving_in_before_marriage_m.jpg
It’s undeniable that marriage and relationships in general look nothing like they did 40 years ago. What’s happened? Women’s lib, skyrocketing divorce rates, the death of the nuclear family—and that’s just for starters. The whole game has changed. Sometimes I think that each generation exhibits a reactionary trend to their predecessors. I am part of the “divorced parents” era. Although my parents are still married, about 60 percent of all people I meet my age come from broken homes. While this phenomenon didn’t necessarily make us “anti-marriage,” it has certainly made us “marriage cautious” or “marriage disillusioned.” As a modern woman I know the statistics – if I ever do tie the knot, I know it ain’t gonna be all sunshine and roses. And that’s why I plan to be as sure as I can possibly, possibly be. Before I exchange any vows, I’ve made a vow to myself: I MUST live with someone before I marry them.  I’m not alone in this thinking. About 70 percent of couples are cohabitating before marriage these days.

Now, I’ve heard all this “Why buy the cow, when you can get the milk for free?” business (wait, why does it have to be a cow?). And guess what? I don’t care because it’s not about my milk; it’s about the farmer. That’s why when Jeff and I were getting serious, I felt the natural next step would be for us to move in together.

When people say, “You never really know someone until you live with them,” they are speaking the truth. Even though Jeff and I had been dating for a year before we moved in, I had no idea I would discover so many new things about him.

Our first major moving-in fight totally caught me off guard.

“I am going to take up more of the closet because I have four times as many clothes as you,” I laughed as we were unpacking.

“No, I want half of the closet. We share this place,” he said, not laughing.

“Are you serious right now?”

“Yes.” And he was.

He proceeded to spread his four shirts out while I crunched my 50 million blouses, dresses, and pants into exactly one half of the closet.

Another surprising moment was our first laundry time together.

“Can you throw my towel in with your wash?” I asked casually.

“No, I don’t really want to mix our laundry.”

“Wait – really?”

“Yeah ... we should do our laundry separately.” I was speechless.

Other things I learned about Jeff: He always paid his bills on time; he didn’t mind doing my dishes; he spent a great deal of time cataloging his music collection; he was frugal, except when he splurged on important purchases; he was consistent night and day; and, most importantly, he was an extremely caring and generous person (except when it came to closet space). Living together is a two-way street. I’m sure Jeff had no idea that I hated doing dishes, slammed doors when I was angry, liked to eat out for almost every meal, couldn’t control myself around his ice cream, and hated to sit around the house doing nothing.

Even though Jeff and I ended up splitting after three years, I would not have traded the experience for anything. We’re still good friends and sometimes I call him up just to remind him about the closet fight. We both find it amusing in retrospect. Living with Jeff gave me a more realistic perspective of marriage and relationships. That’s why I’m very skeptical about a new study that claims that couples who live together before marriage have a way better chance of getting divorced. Really? The study suggests that couples who cohabitate may be entering into marriage for the wrong reasons – like financial convenience, testing out the waters, or because of a “We’re already here, why not?” mentality.

While the study may have a point, I don’t think it changes my mind in the least. The findings make me no less cautious about marriage. You’re damn straight I want to test-drive the car before I purchase it (to use another awful analogy). And believe me, this “cow” will be in the driver’s seat before she ties the knot.

-- By Ami Angelowicz at The Frisky

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 43
  • J.J.M.'s Avatar
    Posted by J.J.M. Mon Jul 27, 2009 9:02am PDT

    Well, leaving aside that I believe marriage to be a deeply flawed, unnecessary institution...

    I think that a couple who gets married before trying to live together is setting themselves up for a lot of disappointment when they realize that the person they hold so dear might have horribly annoying "Home-Habits"

    Report Abuse
  • Krystal K's Avatar
    Posted by Krystal K Mon Jul 27, 2009 9:12am PDT

    I agree. My husband and I lived together for almost 3 years before getting married, and I wouldnt change a thing!

    Report Abuse
  • Sarah's Avatar
    Posted by Sarah Mon Jul 27, 2009 9:17am PDT

    I live with my boyfriend...and we are currently engaged now. I love him and some of his annoying habits i learned after moving in. But it didn open my eyes to more of who he is and even who I am. I believe in our relationship and our future marriage. In my eyes...living with him is what showed me that he was who I wanted to spend my life with. I think if its not meant to be with wont be....whether you live with them or not.

    Report Abuse
  • Ahleah G's Avatar
    Posted by Ahleah G Mon Jul 27, 2009 9:43am PDT

    I also wholeheartedly support living with someone before marriage. You cannot see how compatible you are with someone day in and day out if you don't live together first.

    The old tradition of starting a new life when you get married and then have sex and live together worked when you married after high school and moved right out of your parent's house and into your husband's (well at least that worked for the living together part). That just doesn't make sense anymore. Most people are on their own before getting married. And not only does living together allow you to know more about the person you are with, it has the bonus of saving on rent.

    I want to get married even though we live together already because I want to make that level of committment. There are practical reasons too, but I would never want to get married just for a tax break or because, well, we already live together. I think that because divorce is such a common thing now, people don't place enough stock in the idea of marriage and too often give up instead of trying to work things out. Then again there are people who get married hoping their relationships will improve. Perhaps those are the couples who live together and have a higher divorce rate. If you are already having issues, marriage will not fix them.

    Report Abuse
  • JANELLE P's Avatar
    Posted by JANELLE P Mon Jul 27, 2009 9:50am PDT

    Ithink it is best tio live together before marriage,my husband and I lived together for 6 yrs and here it is 38yrs later we are still married and we are still very happy . our love is alot stronger than we we first met. I would not change anything .

    Report Abuse
  • Karna's Avatar
    Posted by Karna Mon Jul 27, 2009 9:52am PDT

    I can't figure out why people think that couples who live together and then break up would be happier if they had gotten married. No, you got the same result with less paperwork and court costs. I mean, okay, it might be true that couples who live together aren't as likely to get married-because you can figure out before you walk down the aisle that you shouldn't marry this person. Why is that a bad thing?

    so yeah, count me as firmly in favor of living together first

    Report Abuse
  • kamille's Avatar
    Posted by kamille Mon Jul 27, 2009 9:59am PDT

    I am twenty-nine and recently seperated from my husband. We hve three children jordan nine, jovn jr. five, and jayla four yers old. I never knew that after having a famly that we would seperate. It was a hard decision for me to make. After so many years he began to get too comfortable with me . He really did't appreciate me or the extea things that I did , including working and being the primary bread-winner in the house hold. I started to feel ugly and fat because of the lack of attention that I was getting from my husband. I told him this for years ,I lost weight to please him then changed my appearence. He did'nt show me any attention until it was too late. It was over by then. I did't feel the same way about him. The hard part was seperating the kids from the home they once knew that included a mother and a father. Now my son is living with him in Flordia,and I've got the girls with me in Memphis. Sometimes I think to myself , "what have I done to my family or its my fault that the girls can't see daddy and my son can't see me" . Maybe if we would have lived together before the kids and the marrage all of this would have been avoided. That means that I would have saw him for him and not what I was seeing at the time. I still love him, but now I am a different person, I'm not the girl that he married, I am the woman that left . I sometimes wonder if I should try agin just for the kids. It hurts me every time the girls ask about daddy , or when I talk to my son and he asks when am I coming to see him. I really don't know what to do.

    Report Abuse
  • FL Enginerd's Avatar
    Posted by FL Enginerd Mon Jul 27, 2009 10:01am PDT

    I really don't care to live with my boyfriend before being committed as a permanent union. If I truly love someone, those annoying habits will not make me fall out of love with them. I don't think I would break up with someone because he didn't give me more than half of the closet and he didn't want to wash my clothes.

    Report Abuse
  • None's Avatar
    Posted by None Mon Jul 27, 2009 10:04am PDT

    This is hard for those who want to remain virgins till marriage, but for me, I think totally with it, and/or then totally against it, living together before could ruin surprise and quicken the boredom, BUT, living together before the plunge lets you know if the annoying habits they do, is something you can't live with. Both have pros & cons.

    Report Abuse
  • opiniononly's Avatar
    Posted by opiniononly Mon Jul 27, 2009 10:08am PDT

    They have been saying living together ends up in divorce after marriage for decades. Living together/marriage works when both couples are clear about expectations, boundaries and goals. Regardless of status, if you aren't in agreement and avoided the discussions about those topics prior to making your decision, your relationship will be troubled. The difference is that living together doesn't require the legal hassle of separation/ending..but that doesn't mean it is less difficult to reach that decision and act on it.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 43

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Updates Chatter on Shine…

Love Byte

Skip the multiple-choice quiz, and read up on if you're a mom, a nag, too clingy, or perfect in every way. Aren't we all?