Love + Sex

Tuesday, November 24, 2009

Hot and bothered: Life on the B list

Getty Images

Getty Images


There's a fascinating article in the current issue of Psychology Today—unfortunately unavailable online, about the theory that humans have a romantic A list and a romantic B list—meaning, people will often hold hang onto a person who's not "the one," just in case partner A doesn't work out. It's sort of like nature's backup plan. This includes the ex who may call or e-mail you every few months, even though he's married, the former flame who doesn't mention he's married until you specifically ask him. Or, in my case, this includes The Professor (not to be confused, in any way, shape, or form with The Medievalist —a situation which I'm still kicking myself over)


As a recap, the Professor and I have known each other for 3 years as friends with benefits. And I saw him the other night. And in some ways, it was so, so good, and I like him so, so much. I feel like I can trust him in a way I can't with other guys—he's seen my freakouts, he knows my quirks, and I feel comfortable sharing things with him.

Like, after we had s-e-x, we were lying there, and I said, "I just want to move to the Pacific Northwest and have babies!" And then after, we locked eyes with each other, and, yes, we can blame part of that outburst on oxytocin, phenylethylamine, and other fun, post-sex chemicals, we can blame part of that on the fact that in the past week, my brother and his wife had their first baby and my best friend from high school announced that she was expecting, but the rest of that? As I watched the panic flash across his eyes, I added, "just kidding!" And that's mostly true. I certainly do not want and am not ready for children anytime soon, and I'm VERY careful about that. But, I think a lot of that is just that, in the dating wilderness of New York City, he's as close to a constant as I've had in the past couple years.

But. Anyway. I'm definitely his B-girl, and, to be honest, I think he's mine. Or, even different than that, I think we're both exclusively friends with benefits with each other. But I think that having him there (only 12 blocks away from where I live) is precluding me from REALLY devoting myself to searching for an A-lister. And everyone deserves that!


So, what do you think of the cassette tape theory of romance? Have you ever been a B-Lister or kept a B-Lister?


Posted by Alice


Redbook
* Take Your Sex Life to the Next Level
* Marriage Makeover -- Our Renovation Is Ruining Our Marriage
* 21 Little Sex Moves That Will Rock Your World
* Don't-Tell-the-Wife Secrets All Men Keep
* Get More on Love, Family & Fashion - Subscribe to Redbook & Save up to 82%!


Reprinted with Permission of Hearst Communications, Inc.
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 49
  • ruby5alive's Avatar
    Posted by ruby5alive Thu Jul 17, 2008 2:01pm PDT

    I'v been married now for two years And i think yes A & B For shur !

    the man i'm married to may very well be the B guy, because i feel like

    if some one better came along i would leave! Dont get me wrong I love my Husband But The conecttion is not that strong between us! Like a friend with/benefits and a Home.I'v Been in more loving relationships then this one and had deeper feelings for them then this one Too.

    but i'm getting old and dont want to die alone so B guy it is.......

    Report Abuse
  • Joi's Avatar
    Posted by Joi Mon Jul 28, 2008 10:20am PDT

    Well u dont have to just settle for wats going on. have u tryed going out or have u tryed something that is out hte ordasnry 4 both of u. because u know putting on that sexy dress or cooking a a romantic meal just for the bouth of u can and will help.

    Report Abuse
  • DLW's Avatar
    Posted by DLW Mon Jul 28, 2008 10:34am PDT

    Hmm, I have an A and B lister and I definitely am a A and B lister. Unfortunately I think I'm the B lister to my A lister!!

    Report Abuse
  • Ali's Avatar
    Posted by Ali Mon Jul 28, 2008 11:37am PDT

    Hugh!! I dont even have a B lister not to mention an A!!

    that sucks!

    Report Abuse
  • kanitra's Avatar
    Posted by kanitra Mon Jul 28, 2008 11:56am PDT

    Well at the moment I have an A and B list. My B list is my partner but he suck so I found me a A list guy. Which sucks also cause I want him to be on both list and I don't even think I'm on his A list which is really bad. So here I am stuck with a B list that I am very very very bored with. And a A list that rocks my world, But after a while you just begin to fell like you want more than just sex from your A list I want to see what else he has to offer. I am not an emotional person but after you cum and take a shower and lay back down what else do you have, a great A list????????

    Report Abuse
  • Mrs. Metroka's Avatar
    Posted by Mrs. Metroka Mon Jul 28, 2008 12:42pm PDT

    I have quite a few B-listers actually, but I love my A more than life itself and I know he feels the same way about me, so I doubt any of those B's will ever be taken advantage of! OH WELL! I should share with some of you ladies who need one!

    Report Abuse
  • Whew's Avatar
    Posted by Whew Mon Jul 28, 2008 1:11pm PDT

    I had never thought about this before but it is absolutely correct. I must be an A lister to someone who was on my B list because even though I have been married for almost 3 years now, he still gets in touch ever few months or so. I actually love my A lister and B knows that, but deep down I do enjoy the attention of my B's call every few months.

    Report Abuse
  • jessicatastrophe_70x7's Avatar
    Posted by jessicatastrophe_70x7 Mon Jul 28, 2008 2:44pm PDT

    i think ive unconciously got a b-lister. before i met my current fiance(who i love very very much and do not ever plan on actually needing the b-lister!), i had liked my best friend Jesse for a year. as soon as alex came, i kinda tossed jesse out of the picture romantically, but from time to time i wonder if i hadnt met alex, would I be with jesse? and when I think about it, its not that bad of an idea. jesse is an amazing guy, and attractive, too. i used to wish i could put both of those boys in one body and id be set. but now im perfect with alex. =]

    Report Abuse
  • kenyeita's Avatar
    Posted by kenyeita Mon Jul 28, 2008 3:04pm PDT

    well this is very interesting because i think i am an A lister but donot yet have an A lister there are some who came close and were on my A- list. What will it take to be on my A list, a whole hell-of-alot. because preecy dont settle for less. you have to have your own everything, big hands,bigfeet,and a big d@*.. well yaw know what i mean. so for right now i will continue to enjoy being ON THE A LIST TO THOSE WHO THINK THEY ARE ON MY A LIST.LOL ;)

    Report Abuse
  • MochaMama42's Avatar
    Posted by MochaMama42 Mon Jul 28, 2008 4:51pm PDT

    I was on the B-List of this guy I met 17 years ago. He would call me out of the blue every now and again over the course of the last 7 years..when I saw him 7 years ago, after he was married and I had been married as well, it was nice, but any remnant of attraction on my part just wasn't there. I liked him as a friend, that was it.

    He loved calling every 6 months or so, and acting like he was going to be in town, he wanted to see me, or whatever other drivel was going on in his head. Sort of venting/fantasizing, but wanting me to listen like an actual wife.

    I finally emailed him about 3 months ago, and just asked that he not get in touch with me any longer. The reason I did this was because

    A. He's married with children

    B. He lives on the West Coast , I am on the East Coast

    C. Even though it's flattering that he would say I reminded him of a Eva Mendes sexy while he was in Spain or I was so cool, and down to earth and what not...

    It just seemed like trivial banter, and he didn't appreciate me or was that into me when we were both available. Mostly he complained about his home situation (typical) and I just said, "If you put the energy into your marriage like you do complaining about it, it would probably improve exponentially".

    Ego boosts are nice, however, if I'm not A, then , it really isn't that important. And once your decision is made, A or B, then that's a wrap. Or at least it should be.

    For me, when it's over, it's over, however, yes, we all do it. A or B list, rank them, whatever....it's just that a decision needs to be made and be final.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 49

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Love Byte

Skip the multiple-choice quiz, and read up on if you're a mom, a nag, too clingy, or perfect in every way. Aren't we all?