Love + Sex

Tuesday, December 8, 2009

Hot and bothered: Life on the B list

Getty Images

Getty Images


There's a fascinating article in the current issue of Psychology Today—unfortunately unavailable online, about the theory that humans have a romantic A list and a romantic B list—meaning, people will often hold hang onto a person who's not "the one," just in case partner A doesn't work out. It's sort of like nature's backup plan. This includes the ex who may call or e-mail you every few months, even though he's married, the former flame who doesn't mention he's married until you specifically ask him. Or, in my case, this includes The Professor (not to be confused, in any way, shape, or form with The Medievalist —a situation which I'm still kicking myself over)


As a recap, the Professor and I have known each other for 3 years as friends with benefits. And I saw him the other night. And in some ways, it was so, so good, and I like him so, so much. I feel like I can trust him in a way I can't with other guys—he's seen my freakouts, he knows my quirks, and I feel comfortable sharing things with him.

Like, after we had s-e-x, we were lying there, and I said, "I just want to move to the Pacific Northwest and have babies!" And then after, we locked eyes with each other, and, yes, we can blame part of that outburst on oxytocin, phenylethylamine, and other fun, post-sex chemicals, we can blame part of that on the fact that in the past week, my brother and his wife had their first baby and my best friend from high school announced that she was expecting, but the rest of that? As I watched the panic flash across his eyes, I added, "just kidding!" And that's mostly true. I certainly do not want and am not ready for children anytime soon, and I'm VERY careful about that. But, I think a lot of that is just that, in the dating wilderness of New York City, he's as close to a constant as I've had in the past couple years.

But. Anyway. I'm definitely his B-girl, and, to be honest, I think he's mine. Or, even different than that, I think we're both exclusively friends with benefits with each other. But I think that having him there (only 12 blocks away from where I live) is precluding me from REALLY devoting myself to searching for an A-lister. And everyone deserves that!


So, what do you think of the cassette tape theory of romance? Have you ever been a B-Lister or kept a B-Lister?


Posted by Alice


Redbook
* Take Your Sex Life to the Next Level
* Marriage Makeover -- Our Renovation Is Ruining Our Marriage
* 21 Little Sex Moves That Will Rock Your World
* Don't-Tell-the-Wife Secrets All Men Keep
* Get More on Love, Family & Fashion - Subscribe to Redbook & Save up to 82%!


Reprinted with Permission of Hearst Communications, Inc.
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 11-20 of 49
  • jill's Avatar
    Posted by jill Mon Jul 28, 2008 5:39pm PDT

    I currently have an A lister and a couple B listers. True the attention of the B lister is flattering to me but only because I love the A lister to death and would NEVER dream of going back to the B lister. The B lister is ego pumping when I get those late night texts about "watching a movie" or such. I'm pretty sure I'm the A lister on my A listers ranks but we're relatively new and still establishing a "define the relationship" phase. He's very nurturing and I don't think he would do the things he does for me if I weren't an A lister to him. Love shouldn't be such a maze but it is.

    Report Abuse
  • Carly's Avatar
    Posted by Carly Mon Jul 28, 2008 5:52pm PDT

    I used to always have a "Plan B" as I called it back then. A guy I'd hang on to as a friend, eventhough, I knew he wanted to be more than friends. I'd keep up with the flirting with him while I was seeing my A lister, just to keep B hanging on just in case it didn't work out with A-which, it never did and I'd always have my B lister just a'waiting for me. It's different now for me though with my current A. I really have deep feelings for him and...I just don't have a B this time around. I think in the past, I always knew that it wasn't going to work out with my A's. But this A is different and I just couldn't see it not working out anytime soon.

    Report Abuse
  • Parrot Girl's Avatar
    Posted by Parrot Girl Mon Jul 28, 2008 9:09pm PDT

    I married my plan B 9 years ago. Over time it's turned out to the best decision I could have made. That's not to say that I don't have at least 2 new B list members in the wings just in case...I'm a B lister to one of them and I'm an A lister to the other. It's nice to have the ego boost of knowing you've still got game LOL!

    Report Abuse
  • JMR's Avatar
    Posted by JMR Mon Jul 28, 2008 9:29pm PDT

    I think thats a lot of pyscho babel bull s---. If you ponder about a "b" guy then why are you with your "a" guy- make a decision for petes sake!

    its unfair to you and the person you are with to be thinking that way. and if you are then maybe you should look inside yourself and deal with your insecurities.

    Report Abuse
  • Southern Belle's Avatar
    Posted by Southern Belle Mon Jul 28, 2008 9:34pm PDT

    I admit....I'm both with 2 different people. But me, everyone is a B-lister. Sucks to be them.

    Report Abuse
  • nuriyah's Avatar
    Posted by nuriyah Tue Jul 29, 2008 2:07am PDT

    i dont know wheter i am B list or A list. i dont really care about as long as i have some fans. I just cant life without fans. But i think i have A list and B list guy. Dont know who i will live with.

    Report Abuse
  • Destiny's Avatar
    Posted by Destiny Tue Jul 29, 2008 8:20am PDT

    I think this is really an interesting topic and thinking about it I have a lot of guys on my B list. Although I have to admit it is really hard to juggle all of them, but it makes you feel so good to know that all these people think are you just it. I am currently not in a real relationship with any of them..and honestly I don't think I will ever settle for a B lister. There is one guy who I would consider to be an "A" lister and at one time he had a girlfriend and we had dated. We agreed to not initiate an physical stuff besides hand holding, hugging, and little things. But he would never break up with his girlfriend. It went on for six months of me waiting, wondering, and falling even more in love. He used to do everything for me, but I could never figure out if I was A or B. It's been a few years later and we recently got back in touch. I would drop anyone of both lists for this guy..but I still don't know where I stand and it's really upsetting.

    Report Abuse
  • AnnMarie's Avatar
    Posted by AnnMarie Tue Jul 29, 2008 9:02am PDT

    I think knowing that he is there when you need him is keeping you from finding the one. I did that for three years and I passed up a lot of great guys because of him. Wish I knew then what I know now.

    Good luck. :)

    Report Abuse
  • CE's Avatar
    Posted by CE Tue Jul 29, 2008 10:44am PDT

    my 'b-lister' is actually my potential 'a-lister'. he's the man i want to spend my life with, but because we're still young we are not exclusive. i suppose we have a good-friends-with-benefits type deal. in the meantime before we hopefully settle down, all my a-listers are really b-listers to this man who i have on the backburner.

    backwards? yes. but it works!

    Report Abuse
  • Ashlee's Avatar
    Posted by Ashlee Tue Jul 29, 2008 11:38am PDT

    I am with Ruby5Alive.

    Report Abuse
Comments 11-20 of 49

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Love Byte

Skip the multiple-choice quiz, and read up on if you're a mom, a nag, too clingy, or perfect in every way. Aren't we all?