Love + Sex

Saturday, December 12, 2009

Hot and bothered: Life on the B list

Getty Images

Getty Images


There's a fascinating article in the current issue of Psychology Today—unfortunately unavailable online, about the theory that humans have a romantic A list and a romantic B list—meaning, people will often hold hang onto a person who's not "the one," just in case partner A doesn't work out. It's sort of like nature's backup plan. This includes the ex who may call or e-mail you every few months, even though he's married, the former flame who doesn't mention he's married until you specifically ask him. Or, in my case, this includes The Professor (not to be confused, in any way, shape, or form with The Medievalist —a situation which I'm still kicking myself over)


As a recap, the Professor and I have known each other for 3 years as friends with benefits. And I saw him the other night. And in some ways, it was so, so good, and I like him so, so much. I feel like I can trust him in a way I can't with other guys—he's seen my freakouts, he knows my quirks, and I feel comfortable sharing things with him.

Like, after we had s-e-x, we were lying there, and I said, "I just want to move to the Pacific Northwest and have babies!" And then after, we locked eyes with each other, and, yes, we can blame part of that outburst on oxytocin, phenylethylamine, and other fun, post-sex chemicals, we can blame part of that on the fact that in the past week, my brother and his wife had their first baby and my best friend from high school announced that she was expecting, but the rest of that? As I watched the panic flash across his eyes, I added, "just kidding!" And that's mostly true. I certainly do not want and am not ready for children anytime soon, and I'm VERY careful about that. But, I think a lot of that is just that, in the dating wilderness of New York City, he's as close to a constant as I've had in the past couple years.

But. Anyway. I'm definitely his B-girl, and, to be honest, I think he's mine. Or, even different than that, I think we're both exclusively friends with benefits with each other. But I think that having him there (only 12 blocks away from where I live) is precluding me from REALLY devoting myself to searching for an A-lister. And everyone deserves that!


So, what do you think of the cassette tape theory of romance? Have you ever been a B-Lister or kept a B-Lister?


Posted by Alice


Redbook
* Take Your Sex Life to the Next Level
* Marriage Makeover -- Our Renovation Is Ruining Our Marriage
* 21 Little Sex Moves That Will Rock Your World
* Don't-Tell-the-Wife Secrets All Men Keep
* Get More on Love, Family & Fashion - Subscribe to Redbook & Save up to 82%!


Reprinted with Permission of Hearst Communications, Inc.
Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 41-49 of 49
  • dana's Avatar
    Posted by dana Wed Jul 30, 2008 11:26am PDT

    I think that some of you women on here do not be committed! Some of you sound like the single life would be good for you until you are ready to settle down. I hate to break it to you all. There is no prince, knight, perfect man. Each guy has his faults as do we.. But, make sure that he values you and that you have enough in common and enough to talk about because growing old together is a lot of years. For those of you that believe in the "A" guy, marry him and you will see that everyone changes and that the lust goes away with the passion. It just has to be deeper females, realize that and you will be happy.

    Report Abuse
  • hottie's Avatar
    Posted by hottie Wed Jul 30, 2008 12:02pm PDT

    ive been married for 12 years and i believe have a b-lister thats my best friend for the past 17 years we love each other and care deeply about each other but were not in love with each other the good thing about him is that hes there when i need him be it a good f--- or as a friend so i would have to agree that having a b-lister is a good back up for the rainy days lol when it gets cold outside

    Report Abuse
  • Cam37's Avatar
    Posted by Cam37 Wed Jul 30, 2008 1:03pm PDT

    I dated my A list guy and he was my first love (high school and college sweethearts) but we broke up. I then married my B list guy and really tried to make it work but couldn't get A list off my mind. After only a year of marriage we divorced and I got back will my A man and we are now living together and engaged. Much happier now. B list is gone. I don't see how anyone could settle for less than the best.

    Report Abuse
  • Moe's Avatar
    Posted by Moe Wed Jul 30, 2008 2:57pm PDT

    Ima A-lister that has very recently been promoted from my B-List status. I guess putting your foot down and demanding recognition works though I still feel like a B-lister sometimes.

    Report Abuse
  • BeachLvr's Avatar
    Posted by BeachLvr Wed Jul 30, 2008 4:01pm PDT

    Exactly what "WHEW" said is true with me. I have an A and have a B who thinks of me as an A. Now me and B can't be friends because I LOVE my AliST and would not jeopardize A even for a very dear old friend/exbf (B).

    Report Abuse
  • aspeneyes's Avatar
    Posted by aspeneyes Wed Jul 30, 2008 5:23pm PDT

    Whatever. why can't they both be on the A list at the same time? It just seems too complicated to define an A and B. I'm not much of a believer anymore that "one" person meets my needs. In my case, a couple of men meet my needs.

    Report Abuse
  • DimSum's Avatar
    Posted by DimSum Thu Jul 31, 2008 1:44am PDT

    I definitely always have a B list but its not some deliberate thing or a lack of commitment on my part. B list are all men who I had close friendships with and who would like more from me, but for various reasons, things weren't exactly right for me to be with them. I dont, however, "keep them around" just in case my A relationship fails though! They are in my life because although we lacked something that my A and I do have, these men are close friends that I have very strong relationships with.

    But yes....if im in a committed relationship with some man I intend to stay with, I do limit time with Bs. I dont think its appropriate for two ppl in a committed relationship to have such strong relationships with someone of the opposite sex outside of the relationship and I dont think its okay to lead a B on just to keep him around in case you might need him.

    Report Abuse
  • the's Avatar
    Posted by the Thu Jul 31, 2008 7:18am PDT

    I could never have a B-list. I don't settle. I like to have what I want~

    p.s. is monogamy unheard of these days...?

    Report Abuse
  • Mary's Avatar
    Posted by Mary Thu Jul 31, 2008 10:41am PDT

    I don't ever wanna be someones b liter. if im not his a lister I gotta move on. why settle for anything less than the best!!! I desrve better!

    Report Abuse
Comments 41-49 of 49

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Updates Chatter on Shine…

Love Byte

Skip the multiple-choice quiz, and read up on if you're a mom, a nag, too clingy, or perfect in every way. Aren't we all?