Love + Sex

Tuesday, December 1, 2009

If he's already getting a divorce, is it okay to date him?

Is it ever okay to begin a relationship with a man who is “in the process” of getting a divorce?


This is a tricky one. Many years ago my sister stopped seeing a man she’d dated for only a few weeks because his divorce was not yet final, and she felt that was crossing the line.  It turned out to be something she now somewhat regrets because he was an intelligent, handsome, financially stable man, who went on to date and become engaged to another woman he met shortly thereafter.  Although I understood where she was coming from morally, I still felt as though she was being way too uptight and rigid about the whole thing.  I’m not so sure I still feel that way now. 


I’d be lying if I didn’t admit that one thing which bothers me about Cindy McCain is that she was, indeed, the other woman.  Regardless of how troubled John’s first marriage was, he was, in fact, still married when he began seeing Cindy. Whenever I see her on television, regardless of my political opinions, I cannot seem to get past the fact that she was the other woman, who went on to marry a man with whom she had an affair. Call me shallow or old fashioned, but I find it difficult to respect her, or envision her as First Lady, knowing she was a party to an affair which may have ended a marriage.  Now, most recently, there’s Barbara Walters and CBS correspondent Lara Logan. I don’t know if the married men with whom they had affairs were in the process of getting divorces when they began dating, or if the marriages simply ended on their own, but either way, I find it troubling. 


My current 40 year old perspective is that it is necessary to allow one relationship to end before beginning a new one.   In my opinion, a marriage ends when the divorce is final and the parties are free to marry again.  Many people believe a relationship may be deemed over when the parties are physically or emotionally separated, while others feel that if a marriage is already in trouble, it is okay to began dating the man...after all, since he’s going to date other women anyway, why not be one of them? 


I am interested in hearing others perspectives on this; in terms of when a marriage is truly over and at what point is it okay to began a new relationship.

Danine Manette
http://www.ultimatebetrayal.com

Syndication:

From the Community…

Comments 1-10 of 126
  • Nyia's Avatar
    Posted by Nyia Thu Jul 10, 2008 3:12pm PDT

    sorry but i think if he was ready to date he would have been FULLY divorced cause if he isnt then ur just another reabound and i dout that is somethig u want to call ur self

    Report Abuse
  • Michelle's Avatar
    Posted by Michelle Thu Jul 10, 2008 3:58pm PDT

    you said it yourself, he's just going to date other women anyway... it seems your man is ready to move on, and after a bad relationship, its probably the best thing for him... divorces can take a long time to get though the courts, especially in today's legal system, i'm not sure how long they've been separated for, but my guess is that it's atleast a little bit lengthy period of time... if you're into this guy don't worry about his legal title, as long as he's not actually seeing the woman, what do you have to worry about?

    Report Abuse
  • T's Avatar
    Posted by T Thu Jul 10, 2008 6:46pm PDT

    He's still married.. going through a lot of emotions.. and still has the right to connect with his wife.. Even when the divorce is final, you would be the rebound girl and nothing more. Think of it as a man that just got out of prison out of lock down. He's fresh meat, freshly hurt and hurt people, hurt people. Trust me he is not looking to get married again anytime soon. And if he's ready to date.. You will be the booty girl. The girl to vent his frustrations.. Preparing him for the new wife..If you decide to date him.. I would talk to him as a friend and nothing more until his divorce is final.. then take it super slow at your pace so that you can check out the waters.. Good Luck

    Report Abuse
  • Liz's Avatar
    Posted by Liz Thu Jul 10, 2008 7:58pm PDT

    I think it depends on the situation! I am getting married in October to a wonderful man! He was in the process of divorce when we met! I was not the cause of their divorce! Her dad was her lawyer and he was taking his sweet little time to get everything settled! The divorce process lasted 2 1/2 years! His ex-wife just got remarried last weekend! Their divorce wasn't final till March of this year! She was engaged before him and I were! Both of them moved on before the divorce was over! Now if I had met him sooner, things may have been different! So go for it if it feels right!

    Report Abuse
  • SpiceBoy23's Avatar
    Posted by SpiceBoy23 Fri Jul 11, 2008 7:00am PDT

    As a man in the process of getting a divorce I'd like to share my thoughts on this. In my opinion there are circumstances in which it is OK. Every situation is different. I wouldn't jump into anything. I would take the time to get to know this guy really well. If you have found someone you think is great except for the not yet divorced bit then you would be a fool to categorically deny yourself the opportunity to explore the possibilities. There comes a point in time where the divorce process itself is just a business transaction. You are asking questions which means you are not proceeding blindly. Keep your eyes open! Everyone deals with loss differently. "Follow your heart, your intuition. It will lead you in the right direction." (Jewel lyrics) Good luck!

    Report Abuse
  • Dreaming of when...'s Avatar
    Posted by Dreaming of when... Fri Jul 11, 2008 7:07am PDT

    I dont understant this so called moral dillema everywhere I look there r women complaining about men and their marital status once the relationship is over its over even if the stupid little paper isnt signed. If hes with you wants to be with you and both sides agree the relationship is over what the hell is the problem? I swear the women these days are just sickening uptight then amazingly hypocritical about everything!

    Report Abuse
  • MochaMama42's Avatar
    Posted by MochaMama42 Fri Jul 11, 2008 9:52am PDT

    In all honesty, a relationship is over when the people involved say the relationship is over. Therefore, whether or not someone's divorce is finalized or not, if someone wants to be with you they will, period.

    In a perfect situation, of course the divorce would be final, however, being realistic, things don't always work that way. However, I will make this comment:

    If you are involved in a relationship and find out the person is not divorced, has a girlfriend, etc, and you aren't comfortable with it, definitely end the relationship.

    Report Abuse
  • Paris44's Avatar
    Posted by Paris44 Fri Jul 11, 2008 11:42am PDT

    Do not wait until the divorce is final! My spouse and I separated in November after 15 years of marriage. The last few years were not the greatest and the last year was awful. I spent the last year trying to figure out what was wrong in my life and realized I was no longer in love with my husband. He ended up leaving on his own. Before it ended I started taking great care of myself and now I feel great about myself again. I feel emotionally ready to date again and am talking to someone currently. In my state I cannot file for a divorce for an entire year. I will soon be able to get a divorce, but I can't imagine letting just the formality of the final divorce decree rule my social life. Don't pass up a great opportunity!

    Report Abuse
  • Leea's Avatar
    Posted by Leea Fri Jul 11, 2008 11:47am PDT

    This is an opinion from a woman in the same boat. I am in the middle of a very long and drawn out divorce. Its an ongoing issue and not final due to child custody and a series of hard indesicions. I have started dating. Its hard to date you feel bad for the person your with because things aren't finished yet. Its also one of those closure things that some people need to help make sure that your not walking away from something that you can't replace.

    My advice is to make sure that papers are started, but mainly insure that there is a legal seperation inplace so that no one is being lied to. that is just my advice.

    Report Abuse
  • Inky's Avatar
    Posted by Inky Fri Jul 11, 2008 11:49am PDT

    When I was in college, I met a guy at a club one night. We started seeing eachother shortly thereafter. He had quite the tan line on his ring finger, and told me he and his wife had just divorced. A few weeks later, he said the divorce hadn't finalized yet, but was deffinately processing. I got a little suspicious, especially since we always went to my apartment. So I asked him if we could instead go to his. He said we couldn't because, though he and his soon-to-be-ex wife were divorcing, they still lived together, for the sake of their 2-year-old son, of course. When I asked him a week later who his divorce lawyer was, because a friend of mine needed one (a lie), he said they hadn't filed yet, they were just seperated. A few days after that, I ran into him at the mall. I threw my arms around his neck to kiss him and heard a woman scream his name. I spun to find a very pissed off woman shreiking in my face. I ran out of there with a quickness. He called later that night to tell me that they weren't quite seperated yet. Yeeeeeaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhh. So, unless I see SIGNED court documants PROVING a divorce, there's no way I'm going near a man.

    Report Abuse
Comments 1-10 of 126

leave your comment

You must sign in to post a comment

Sign In for personalized information

New User? Sign Up

Updates Chatter on Shine…

Love Byte

Skip the multiple-choice quiz, and read up on if you're a mom, a nag, too clingy, or perfect in every way. Aren't we all?